The same cities that many people despise living in yet do so for work? The same ones that basically everyone recognises aren't efficient at all. What is an ideal city in your opinion? San Fransciso? New York? Paris?
They are horribly inefficient places to live. Here in Sydney I know people who live in suburbia and need 20 mins in a car to simply buy a loaf of bread, there's no shops anywhere close by, it's just endless constant sprawl and 10 hours of commuting a week, 480 hours a year, and this is considered one of the most liveable places on Earth bizarrely.
I would love to hear what you think is a good proposal for a new city if this one is terrible?
> eat resources away due to the whims of one egoistical dictator
Not sure if you know much about the country, but prolific waste is basically their thing, as far as I'm concerned at least it's money not being spent on buying American bombs and military hardware. Every cent counts :)
Stockholm (my current city for almost a decade), Copenhagen, Berlin, Vienna, Amsterdam, Rotterdam, etc. are quite efficient and very pleasant to live in. The issue people currently have in those is cost of living.
I don't live in the US and I think American cities are horrors, just not as bad as in my native country (Brazil), which were completely "inspired" by American urban design.
Don't pigeonhole cities just in the ones you feel are terrible, get out of the bubble, there are plenty of examples of very livable and nice cities. The Americas are not in that category, generally speaking.
European cities are nice, but we know it is not possible for developing countries to repeat it, too expensive.
What costs are you talking about? There's nothing too expensive about doing decent urban planning in line with the resources you currently have, it's much more a question of follow-through on long-term plans than absolute cost of implementation...
The issue is much deeper and nuanced than cost, it's corruption, it's short-sighted politics due to populism and uneducated populations, etc.
Nothing is short signed, it is a decision over priority, and poor countries don't really have many options.
This is the kind of project where the experts criticising it seem to have very valid points, it doesn't make any sense when you look at it from the perspective of how humans organise into cities and the needs for such cities to be efficient.
Bold doesn't mean good just because it goes against the grain... It can also be completely stupid, even more when there is no force to push against it (like the market is for SpaceX and such). It can just eat resources away due to the whims of one egoistical dictator...