Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by ww520 on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @11:18PM
(#3327641)
The way to play the cash giftcard game is to take advantage of the cashback of the paying card. For example, Discover had a promotion on CyberMonday that paid $100 if I spent at least $1000 on that day. I didn't have anything pending to buy on that particular day, so I bought an $1000 Amex giftcard paid with the Discover card, pocketing the $100 cashback and had the $1000 giftcard to use in daily usage.
Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by kapilkale on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @09:43PM
(#3327306)
Amen!
There are a lot of niche use cases for them which most people don't see. For example, businesses use them to pay contractors when they owe more than a certain amount in order to avoid tax liability / paperwork.
We didn't pull much data on them, but I think you can buy them at a discount as well.
Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by dhyasama on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @09:54PM
(#3327342)
Hey Kapil, This is a tangent, but who designed your site? It's gorgeous.
Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by kapilkale on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @10:02PM
(#3327370)
Thanks for the compliment. Mike Kus designed it, though things like this content piece we did ourselves.
Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by jonknee on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @10:06PM
(#3327383)
They have interesting uses though, because they are effectively a credit card that you don't need a valid billing address for. Allows for fairly anonymous transactions.
Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by crazygringo on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @11:25PM
(#3327664)
Only in person, where you can use cash anyways.
Online they don't work, unless you get one of the few which allow you to fill in a real SSN matched to a real address, etc. -- at least in the US. If I recall correctly, it's due to a section of the Patriot Act. And apparently they actually verify the SSN+name now. I'm not aware of any prepaid credit cards that allow anonymous online purchases now in 2011, in the US.
Re:Gift Cards Are Worth Less Than You Think [data viz]
by jonknee on Thursday December 08, 2011 @06:31PM
(#3331713)
You can set a billing address online or with a phone call and use it online. I did that a few times this year, in the US. (This was to get MLB.tv at an alternate out-of-market billing address.)
Then they're actually less practical than cash. You have to spend exactly the card balance to use them effectively. So if I swipe it at Starbucks a few times until it's down to $1.49, the next transaction will simply be declined! I'd have to ask the barista ahead of time to split the transaction and charge exactly $1.49 to the card (so I have to mentally track the balance or call Visa/MC every time I use it). I'm guessing it's more likely that people reach the point where the card is declined and then throw it away, with Visa/MC pocketing the remains.
If you want to use it online, you have to go to the Visa/MC web site and register it (provide your personal details) so that the card is associated with billing details. Lovely side effect: they get your personal contact information to spam you with.
For the love of all that is rational, please don't give me these cards, I'd much rather have $28.95 cash than $25 + extra hassles. The best use of these cards I could come up with is converting them to a gift card at a particular store you actually like. Store gift cards have correct overflow semantics - the full balance of the card will be used and the register will ask you to come up with the difference.