Imagine a band playing a song. The drum beat drives the rhythm and plays a central role in whole performance, but these protons may well be like sand grains bouncing on the surface of the drum.
Also bear in mind that nothing they studied or observed correlates in any way with the specific quantum processes that occur in quantum computation.
What is causation?
That is true - but it does not say anything about the opposite, or say that the objects are not correlated, which is often forgotten, or said with an implicit "there's a 90% chance they aren't correlated" when the statement makes no judgement whatsoever on the likelihood they are correlated. There might be a 90% chance of causation, even if the statement remains accurate.
Example, this statement: Grass grows the fastest when the sun shines. Correlation is not causation - the grass does not grow solely because the sun is shining. Nevertheless the statement is true.
Edit: My main point is that anything can be simply hit with: "Correlation is not causation." It's a skeptic's cop-out because, who can prove causation, really? Technically speaking, is not even gravity only assured by the anecdotes of billions of people? But sometimes it is stupid to remain a skeptic even if the two aren't the same.
Nice.
There are many, many things that could be going on in these processes in the brain. The range of possible mechanisms and effects is huge, and this result gives us just a tiny bit of information, but nowhere nearly enough to determine which possibilities are more or less likely. Some journalist picked one possibility to promote because it's click-baitey, ok fine. It got me to read the article and it's interesting research so we're all good.
But simply pointing out that this one particular possibility isn't actually demonstrated and is highly unlikely, and that there are many, many other alternative possibilities that are each at least as likely is 'stupid'? Thanks for that.
Glue ? Nonono, you gotta use fractally dense nanoscale features that engineer the probability distributions of opposing charges. That's how you adhere to shit
Apparently nature found this so trivial, Geckos lost and re-evolved this ability nine times
This is very poor reasoning, to be frank. By this logic, every computer is a quantum computer. Which is an epistemologically useless distinction.
I'm not excluding the suggestion that quantum effects have macroscopic implications, but for example transistors only work due to quantum mechanical effects. That doesn't make all computers containing transistors 'quantum computers' in the accepted sense.