News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by ta8645 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:00PM (#33270334)
There are similar moves to "make people accountable" for their online actions in the west as well; only the details differ, the motivation is the same -- structural control of online activities and content.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:25PM (#33270481)
I'm one of those people who believe you should not be able to post publicly and anonymously.

Have all the private conversions you want, but if you start broadcasting and your speech causes harm, you should have to make it right.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by nomel on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:41PM (#33270603)
> your speech causes harm, you should have to make it right

Could you define “harm”?

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:20AM (#33271451)
Say for example, false accusations were made against somebody and they were fired.

Any place a lie is told, and somebody losses money or is otherwise harmed by that lie.

I'm not talking about peoples feelings being hurt.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by djbebs on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:57AM (#33271635)
Was the harm "being fired" or was the harm the "false accusation"?

Because I can think of plenty of things others do that get people fired, without any falsity to it. Should we prosecute calling up someone's employer and urging them to fire them?

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:11AM (#33271706)
Yeah, I was thinking about this when writing a comment above. If somebody outted you as Gay and you were fired from your job in a Catholic School, I would say the speech has harmed you. It might be true, but still harmful.

I guess it gets a little muddy because the speaker could claim they made the world a better place by revealing your secretes, that the lie told to the school in the first place makes revealing the lie justified.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by ggm on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:29PM (#33270514)
To me "post publicly" has to be contextually understood. The set of people who need to be psueodonymous is certainly non-zero, but even as a small cohort represent an exception to the norm. The set of people who need to be anonymous is highly specific, to me. It's people with legal obligations to them or from them, people at risk of harm. It's not "I feel like my free speech demands this" -note the use of "need" above. "want" is fine. I get that many people want things.

Most normal discourse, in the wider space, I believe even if you have a self chosen tag, your identity should be knowable, if some things arise. I can handle that its a high barrier to entry (to uncover it), but the supposition all posts all the time have complete anonymity, simply because you assert you want it, that the supposition fails for me.

This causes free-speechers a lot of grief. My personal view is informed by many many years participating in national and international forums discussing what hate speech does, and what free speech means. Inside any cohort who are typified as "wanting anonymity" you find people who also suffer the consequences of being targetted by anonymous hate. I don't see how to reconcile speech rights, with harm minimisation except by requiring identity, even if hidden behind a veil.

I appreciate this has chilling effects. I kind-of go to that if it chills the "shout fire in crowded theatre" thing, its done it's job.

I also appreciate its not free speech in the wider sense, and it may not even be capable of being free speech in the narrower senses for a lot of people. I think reductionism over free speech is one of those things which really falls down a hole. Almost all 'there is no constraint on my speech' claims fall over when it comes to national security (for instance)

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by insightcheck on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:30PM (#33270515)
Anonymous speech is important for anti-corruption. The Washington Post's Watergate investigation would not have taken place without the anonymous sourcing by "Deep Throat."
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by moviewatcher333 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:34PM (#33270563)
Opponents of anonymous speech are aware of this. That’s why they’re opposed to it.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:26AM (#33271481)
I'm not an expert on the matter, its a little before my time, but I think a journalist went on the record and reported than an anonymous source told him of X, Y, and Z.

I don't know about the US, but I believe in some jurisdictions the newspaper and the journalist risk lawsuits if the information they report is a lie.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by Gigachad on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:31PM (#33270534)
This is probably not the worst idea. Would mean a lot of sites go invite only though. Which might be an improvement but it does lower accessibility though.

And I don’t think it would be enough for the modern wave of political censorship. It isn’t enough to just not look at content you don’t like, you have to ensure others can’t see it either.

Stuff like semi private discord servers for example are being targeted.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by arthurcolle on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:31PM (#33270524)
Other than a direct threat or call to action that involves direct threats, how is speech "harmful" - sure, sometimes I get my own tyrranical bents and wish that certain things would be better left unsaid, but realistically, what is "harmful speech" besides someone with particular foul breath?
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:50AM (#33271595)
A lie. A false accusation can have devastating consequences.

Even a truth that you were not ready to share with the world could be very harmful.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by bigDinosaur on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:34PM (#33270559)
The greatest damage ever done by speech (i.e. motivation to start wars, genocides) has been done by fully identifiable people. Anonymous online speech is a total red herring. All current major threats are due to fully non-anonymous people doing bad things (e.g. Putin, heads of cartels, the current head of $terrorist_group), not anonymous online commenters.

Conversely, one of the greatest threat to authoritarians is speech that cannot be easily traced. Hard to put you in prison (or cross international borders to kill or capture or threaten you) if you're anonymous.

What if your online comment is discussing the latest example of police corruption you've seen in your local PD? That would be a very local example of where not being anonymous may easily threaten you, but being anonymous can still let others start investigating.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:57AM (#33271636)
You could tell the "investigators" directly and anonymously. That way if your comment about police corruption was not true, nobody would be fired for no reason. That is precisely the point.

No point discussing the speech of criminals like Putin, lies are just the tip of the iceberg.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by sofixa on Thursday October 20, 2022 @04:21AM (#33272071)
> The greatest damage ever done by speech (i.e. motivation to start wars, genocides) has been done by fully identifiable people

I think your information might be out of date. The Rohingya genocide is a good example of a modern genocide incited on Facebook by regular humans and bots.

In modern cases such as Brexit, Trump, various far right candidates (Zemmour, Bolsonaro), a massive amount of people/fake people on social media talking about them, their talking points (ludicrous and false as they are) have brought them their success, despite the obvious massive red flags.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by kornhole on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:33PM (#33270554)
Then why are you on HN? HN is a great example of where people can speak honestly and respectfully without worry of recrimination from companies or governments.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by lostcohort on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:38PM (#33270592)
To be fair, he's not hiding his name or anything, so he's upholding his end of the non-anonymity part.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by hndamien on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:30PM (#33270519)
How does speech cause harm?
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by mc32 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:36PM (#33270575)
"It makes my brain hurt" or "I think other people could be offended by it".
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:17AM (#33271435)
I was thinking more like, I lost my job because you accused me of Piracy in the newspaper, and its not true.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by threatofrain on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:09PM (#33270383)
Making people accountable offline can be quite grave as well.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by Barrin92 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:06PM (#33270365)
people are and always have been accountable for their actions both online and offline, that's how things are done in any country with the rule of law. The issue is of course what activities and what content and whether lawmakers are accountable to the people. The internet is not a magical land of anarchy.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by api on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:10PM (#33270388)
The Internet has magical lands of anarchy like the dark web, but the fact that the security and anonymity are fairly symmetrical adds a layer of protection for the one visiting these lands. There's also an awareness that the information in these regions is even less trustworthy than random stuff from the clearnet since you know literally nothing about it.
[dead]
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by moviewatcher333 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:29PM (#33270512)
Clueless people will happily trod down this path and not see where it leads. People who’ll say things like “people should use their real names online and be held accountable!” go silent when the places mandating this are the ones killing people for saying the leader is a flawed human or because someone didn’t properly cover their hair.

VPN bans make the oppression inescapable. You see who the real dangerous people are when those who’ll still defend it come out.

It’s easy to think these dangers are just “over there.” It’s important to remember these things will happen here if we’re not careful.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by phantom_of_cato on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:31PM (#33270530)
> What is the point of making this comment?

The point is that if we don't resist internet censorship here in the west, for which the pressure is building up, there won't be a free internet Iranians could connect to using a VPN.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by honkler on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:27PM (#33270495)
I care more what happens to me, than what I care what happens in a random part of the world. You may not like it, and it may not suit your agenda, but it do be like that.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by uni_rule on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:28PM (#33270501)
And that alleged agenda is?
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by honkler on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:56PM (#33270677)
taking americans for a ride. Toppling governments because of your own ethnic gripes. Enough of this.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:20AM (#33271751)
I don't know if somebody is being funny, but I think it's cool that my post on free speech was flagged and censored.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by w1nst0nsm1th on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:43AM (#33273192)
5 days ago, HN admins have removed a post about the desastrous effects of liberal policies (shock doctrine) on Kirghistan economy and societal fabric adopted after the collapse of Soviet Block.

I only had access to it because my rss reader had already saved the link to the blog post in its internal database. But there wasn't any reference of it anymore on HN when I wanted to reach the comment page.

Beside that, the rumors of journalists being fired from english media sphere for their coverage of the recent Nord-stream sabotage and the self-censoring (kind of olympic level mental gymnastic) of some other reporters about the event is mind-bogging.

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by OrderlyTiamat on Thursday October 20, 2022 @11:35AM (#33276321)
Political articles that are very likely to devolve into mudsling fests are regularly nuked from hn, as I'm sure you and everyone who uses the rss feed knows. I'm frankly fine with that. It's not the focus of this site. Occasionally those articles are pretty interesting, and then I'm happy I see them from the rss, but usually I can see why they were removed.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by dang on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:59PM (#33291060)
What was the post? It was most likely flagged by users, not admins.
Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by dang on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:00PM (#33291066)
Posts about divisive ideological topics are often (in fact usually) low-quality and lame, so it's natural for them to be downvoted or flagged. That's to be expected on a site that is trying to hover at least a little above internet default, with its flames and its rages and its repetitions.

People don't post about these things out of intellectual curiosity—they mostly just reiterate pre-existing positions and points and agendas. Such comments typically make up for the lack of curiosity or information with rhetoric and indignation. That's what we're trying to avoid on HN.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Iran's government moves to criminalize VPNs by jay_kyburz on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:05PM (#33292474)
Hi Dang, thanks for reading and commenting.

I know my position on the topic is a little controversial, but I wasn't deliberately trolling, I do genuinely believe what is wrong with today's internet is a lack of accountability.

TV, newspapers, books, magazines were all held accountable for spreading disinformation and harmful speech. I think we need the same protections on the public facing internet.