1. River barge within the Mexican interior picks up a shipment intended for the Honda plant in Ohio.
2. Shipment is transferred to a larger vessel in Coatzacoalcos, Mexico for voyage to Houston Texas.
3. Vessel travels along the coast, which makes for a perfect transport waterway because of its shallow and calm waters.
4. Vessel stops in Houston. picks up and drops off containers at various terminals.
5. Vessel enters the Mississippi river system and continues to drop off and pick up goods throughout its voyage.
6. Our original cargo we care about, is offloaded in Cincinnati at the Queen City Ohio River Terminal and transferred to the rail network, ultimately for delivery at the Honda manufacturing plant outside of Columbus Ohio.
Which IIUC is to try to offload some of the costs of keeping a ship building industry onto private industry [1].
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_Marine_Act_of_1920#Na... [2]: https://www.soapboxmedia.com/devnews/0605queensgateterminals...
But it seems especially fucked up to keep US minimum wage / protections in place while simultaneously not requiring the same thing for foreign flagged corporations performing the same service in a domestic capacity. As you say it's basically saying "if the trucker is American, follow us labor laws. IF the trucker is foreign, race to the bottom." Except instead of trucker it's domestic ship crew flying under a different flag. In practice it's just as bad as protectionism except -- it's protectionism for foreign labor and indeed works against the goals of even the Cato institute. It's the ocean going equivalent of allowing that foreign owned gas station on American soil to go by a completely different set of labor laws than an American owned gas station on American soil. And I say that as someone who really hates the principle of the Jones Act on ideological grounds.
Personally I would just completely deregulate US shipping, eliminate maritime labor laws and protections, and then kill the jones act. Everybody gets to go on equal footing. But with the system we live in, without overhauling it significantly, the Jones Act does make sense on some level.
Right now carpenters are in very short supply. An hourly rate of a carpenter in Hudson Valley is higher than Senior Engineer at Meta.... and there's less carpenters...
The average freight rail trip in the EU are much shorter which makes rail less competitive relative to trucks. That has nothing to do with the rail network and is instead a function of EU’s economy.
The difference in utilization largely comes down to geography and politics. America’s flyover states and high population costs just fit rail really well.
Which makes rail freight in US much more different, doesn't it? We cannot discount competitiveness when comparing rail networks in economics context.
The fact that US rail freight is so much more efficient makes any argument for internal water based transport much less sound.
It makes US rail less efficient vs EU rail, but more competitive compared to US trucking.
The United States has the largest internal waterways system in the world, and we basically only use it for bulk goods.
In Europe - yes, but not US.
Even the "old diesel" locomotives are still easily 40% efficient.
The thing about electric motors is the energy source is abstracted. So even if you’re generating electricity with gas, it’s usually much more efficient than a small localized engine.
So I think my point stands, if EU is electrifying its networks, I don’t understand how the US could possibly be more efficient.
True - so long as the navigable waterways reach the points which you need to ship from & to. And the cargo isn't particularly time-sensitive. And exceptional droughts do not lower the rivers so far that "navigable" is only on paper, and not on the no-longer-there water. That last issue is getting to be a major problem this year.
The thing is both you and the GP seem to be handwaving it. Efficient in what sense? Is freight rail in Europe slower, more expensive, dirtier, and if so how much? Or do they just measure/account for externalities differently? It doesn't require an essay to put assertions about efficiency in context.
(Short version - each of the major U.S. freight RR's is more-or-less a monopoly in the part of the U.S. which it serves. If management relentlessly optimizes for profitability, and doesn't much care about customer service, shipping delays, sustainable staffing levels, etc... Well, I'm sure RR management has enjoyed some fat profit-sharing bonus checks.)
US rail has it's problems but freight rail is not one of them.
The US on the other hand allows for much heavier and slower freight trains. It’s very good at moving heavy stable bulk loads like coal and corn, but less so about moving perishable goods. US freight trips to Mexico can take as long as 45-60 days.
Alas, just this week the news [1] is that the Mississippi river's water-level has fallen low enough that existing docks and routes are having problems.
So while it's an interesting vision, there are some risks with respect to reliable rainfall and water-usage.
[1]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/mississippi-river-approaching-r...
I believe the biggest infrastructure change the US could do is invest in a comprehensive inland terminal network. Europe is doing this. They have been working on strengthening hundreds of inland terminals. Check out this example linked below on google of terminal in Basel, Switizerland - literally in the middle of the continent[1]! Below is also a proposed project in Cincinnati, Ohio that never gained traction because of the issues with the Jones Act[2]. Imagine if every city along the Mississippi river network had a terminal like this.
I want to stress that the real use of a terminal network like this isn't only for delivering finished goods from outside the US to the interior of the country. The real value is to further integrate manufacturing transportation networks between US states, Canada and Mexico. I think this opportunity will fail to be realized because of our dysfunctional politics in Washington and too many powerful lobbies.
[1] https://www.google.com/maps/place/Swissterminal+AG+COBI/@47....
[2] https://www.soapboxmedia.com/devnews/0605queensgateterminals...