News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by senttoschool on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:56AM (#33260825)
So their AWS bill is $500k/year.

Hire one person to buy, configure, manage hardware is what? $250k/year? And is this self-hosting more reliable than AWS? For an email service, you'd think that you want the most reliable host.

Weird.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by 0xblinq on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:25AM (#33261106)
Yeah... I don't agree at all with their conclusions about running your own stuff "not that complicated".

Sure, it is not "that complicated" for basic stuff, simple sites, hobby projects or overall quick'n dirty solutions because you're under a budget, as with everything.

Doing infrastructure properly, with SLAs and a very high level of availability and redundancy (both in systems, and in people with the know-how) is incredibly complicated in my opinion.

I bet what they're going to save on the the Cloud provider is going to be spent (and probably even more) in salaries, if they keep the same levels of service.

Specially true considering they pay pretty good salaries.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by brenogazzola on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:17AM (#33261006)
Their RDS and ES are 500k. They still need to pay for EC2, S3 and any other services they might be using, like ELB and Elasticache. So probably higher than that.

He also did not mention if they are going to self-host, colocate, or rent bare metal in a more traditional host (like softlayer). Probably colocate as I think that’s how they used to run?

Both your points are still valid though.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by senttoschool on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:19AM (#33261036)
So they'd need to hire a person to setup and manage hardware. And another person to setup and manage RDS, ES, etc.

If it's $250k each, that's already $500k. Unless they can find someone who can do both for... $300k?

I don't know.

He doesn't provide enough details to make the math work.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by 988747 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:50AM (#33261365)
$250k is Sillicon Valley rate. In Europe similarly skilled people earn less than that, typically $80k.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by pmontra on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:57AM (#33261452)
Even $25k if you look at small companies in southern Europe.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by danwee on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:54AM (#33271922)
That's just for juniors. Seniors are more around $60K-$70K (although, it's still a low number of US standards, yeah)
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by mgdev on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:33AM (#33262814)
37signals pays SV rates for global staff on principle. They publish their salary information, based on job family and job level.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by deltarholamda on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:48AM (#33263025)
Very important point. There are plenty of skilled people who live in places that don't require that kind of salary in order to afford a decent place to live. Why not hire a guy in Kansas to remote manage your infrastructure?

Silicon Valley culture isn't nearly so critical or valuable that your organization requires it in order to do the necessary work.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by datanerd613 on Sunday October 23, 2022 @07:23AM (#33306116)
He mentioned in the podcast that they rent a space at the data center so I assume colocate
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by kmos17 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:45AM (#33261306)
Managing AWS services also requires staffing, so most likely these would be the same people in a small organization. Self hosting in my experience can be very reliable if you over provision redundant enterprise grade hardware, once it’s running you can get 6-10 years of usable service life. The hardware cost itself is negligible even more so when amortized over a long life cycle.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by Nextgrid on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:54AM (#33261412)
> Hire one person to buy, configure, manage hardware is what?

This point gets raised every single time bare-metal comes up for discussion and at this point I'm not sure if people are legitimately unaware or if there are hidden agendas at play.

There are plenty of providers out there who will handle the logistics for you with an interface similar to AWS EC2 - ask for server and get SSH access in minutes/days/weeks (depending if it's an off-the-shelf or custom build).

From there, your existing DevOps guy (which you must have to navigate AWS' complexity) can take over.

It's only at either extremely large scale or very unusual requirements that managing your own hardware makes sense. Until then, you will never be able to beat the economies of scale of managed bare-metal providers.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by ignoramous on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:07AM (#33261571)
> There are plenty of providers out there who will handle the logistics for you with an interface similar to AWS EC2...

I am sorry but how's that different from leaving BigCloud for SmallCloud? That's like saying, I'd no longer use Java/Kotlin because Oracle/Google but I'll however use Clojure because JVM.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by jstrong on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:32AM (#33263680)
what do you get for $250 a month on ec2? is it 24c/48t dual xeon with 96gb ram, 2x 960gb nvme, with bare metal performance? https://us.ovhcloud.com/bare-metal/infra/infra-4-le/
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by Kon-Peki on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:15AM (#33262536)
> Hire one person

Go back and re-read :)

They [believe that they] don't need to hire anyone. They already have a staff of ops folks that run their cloud operations. And those folks will run their on-prem operations.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by dijit on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @04:50PM (#33267772)
Also, Hardware isn't as hard as people make out, you install it once and it runs; if it fails there's a special out-of-band manager built in so you can remotely debug it, datacenters have remote-hands personel.

If you're constantly installing stuff then you're scaling up a lot, and that's the level where it would make sense to have someone hired dedicated for it.

You can also rent hardware.

the thing is: cloud ops are also quite complex but it's a different kind of complexity. I don't know how many people are required.

The largest teams I've been on have been cloud deployments, and some of the smallest teams were bare-metal; but that's just an anecdote.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by Nextgrid on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:04PM (#33281979)
> Also, Hardware isn't as hard as people make out, you install it once and it runs; if it fails there's a special out-of-band manager built in so you can remotely debug it, datacenters have remote-hands personel.

If you're "cloud native" you've already architected your stack to be horizontally-scalable and distributed (partly because the cloud is so expensive that running at peak load capability all the time would bankrupt you) so hardware failure should matter even less.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by segmondy on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:19AM (#33263499)
MSB don't pay $250k/yr. For $100k/yr they will find someone in USA who will enjoy racking servers, wiring, configuring networks, installing OS, etc. If they look outside of US, they will find it for cheap.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by PeterStuer on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:46AM (#33263884)
If you run anything non trivial in a cloud, chances are that one person will still be cheaper than the one or more person cloud operations team that you have now.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by ProAm on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @05:17PM (#33268055)
> Hire one person to buy, configure, manage hardware is what? $250k/year?

I think you already pay this guy to manage your AWS instances. so you get the benefit of the full 500k

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by codegeek on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:03PM (#33278390)
"Hire one person to buy, configure, manage hardware is what? $250k/year? "

Outside of expensive Silicon Valley and FAANGs, where do you get this $250k/Year ? I think most of us on HN are normalizing this whole "devs make 250k/year" thing when in reality, it is a tiny percentage of people. Tiny when you look at the entire ecosystem.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by Breza on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:16AM (#33304763)
Agreed. Managing servers isn't easy, but it's also not going to get you a quarter million bucks a year.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by jjav on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:50PM (#33282812)
> So their AWS bill is $500k/year.

> Hire one person to buy, configure, manage hardware is what? $250k/year? And is this self-hosting more reliable than AWS?

A company which has a total AWS bill of $500k/yr is a very small one (the article says 500K is just the RDS/ES bill, so total is surely much higher for them).

Our (tiny startup) AWS bill is ~200K/yr and the amount of compute and storage we do could very easily be handled by one single physical server.

Now, sure, if we went to self-hosted we'd split that into multiple servers for redundancy and growth headroom, but in any case definitely less than a dozen boxes.

You don't hire anyone to install and manage the hardware at that scale. Someone from the ops team goes to the colo for a day or two to set it all up and then you only need to go back when something needs replacement, which at that small scale is going to be very rarely.

That's exactly what we did at a previous startup and the company grew to many, many hundreds of people before there was so much infrastructure that it became worth thinking about hiring a dedicated person. By that time you'd be in the 10s of millions in AWS spend.

Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by wazoox on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:12AM (#33285736)
Also nowadays hardware as well as software are incredibly reliable. You can basically set up a Debian web + postgres server with automatic updates enabled and not need to even log into it for months and months.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by CoolCold on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:28AM (#33416914)
it would be "interesting" to see such production where DB can be restarted [by autoupdates] on it's own. Should be fine for personal stuff of course.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by Breza on Sunday October 23, 2022 @01:21AM (#33304788)
Well said! It's amazing how much power you can get in a $10,000 server. If you have a simple stack and consistent demand, self hosting makes a ton of sense.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by pikseladam on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:49AM (#33285250)
You don't need to hire.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by pelasaco on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:32AM (#33285875)
Person + data center, right? Either he will build his own small server room or have to do co-location somewhere..
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by Abe9000 on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:21AM (#33286467)
WIth 500K yearly you can do a lot!! Including renting 3 office spaces in multiple locations in the US and using them as data centers. Offices cost about $1000 - $3000 yearly, he doesn't need a premium space in a big building but for $500K yearly you can do a lot! In 2 years you would have spent 1M. That is more than enough to have a dedicated devops that travels to all the locations and setup the super beefy servers you can buy with that budget.
Re:37signals Leaves the Cloud by pelasaco on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:47AM (#33288539)
Ok but 500k is the whole budget for location, backup location, energy, devops people, operation people, etc.. I run part of our infra on-premise, and part of on AWS.. in the summer, we had issues with our air-conditioner (europe) and we had to turn-off partially our service, now in Winter because of the raising costs, we are discussing again what to do with the on-premise services, employees getting ill, etc but AWS, in another hand, is just a bill.