News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by ugh on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @11:57AM (#3324591)
That sounds a lot like trademark infringement, not copyright infringement.
Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by redthrowaway on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @01:03PM (#3324963)
I'm far from an expert in Chinese law, but I could see the two being reasonably treated as equivalent.
Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by dctoedt on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @03:39PM (#3325878)
Trademarks and copyrights aren't equivalent. I'm not licensed to practice in China, but from everything I've ever read, Chinese law [1] isn't so different (at this level) from that of other countries.

TRADEMARKS: Generally speaking, a trademark is something that signifies or evokes a product provided, sponsored, or endorsed by a particular source. TRADEMARK EXAMPLES: * Word marks such as Apple and iPad; * Logos such as the apple logo; * Sounds such as the "Intel inside" sequence of notes; * Colors, even (sometimes) such as pink for Owens-Corning-brand attic insulation.

(Trademarks are for products; service marks serve the same function for services.)

In a sense, the "owner" of a trademark is really just its government-appointed custodian or guardian. (It's sort of like the old joke: Dogs have masters, cats have staff.) When a trademark owner enforces its rights against an infringer, what the owner is really doing is performing a public service, namely keeping the market free of marks that would be likely to confuse the public.

COPYRIGHT: In contrast, copyright applies to original works of "authorship," regardless whether associated with a product or service.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_in_the_Pe...

Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by PakG1 on Thursday December 08, 2011 @01:17PM (#3330318)
Further analysis seems to say that this was indeed a poor translation. It's a trademark case, not a copyright case. ugh was on the mark.