News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by redthrowaway on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @11:47AM (#3324539)
The article's pretty clear. Proview registered the iPad trademark in 2001, Apple licensed it for use outside of China in 2009, but then went on to use the trademark in mainland China without signing a licensing agreement.

That's copyright infringement, plain and simple.

Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by ugh on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @11:57AM (#3324591)
That sounds a lot like trademark infringement, not copyright infringement.
Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by redthrowaway on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @01:03PM (#3324963)
I'm far from an expert in Chinese law, but I could see the two being reasonably treated as equivalent.
Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by dctoedt on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @03:39PM (#3325878)
Trademarks and copyrights aren't equivalent. I'm not licensed to practice in China, but from everything I've ever read, Chinese law [1] isn't so different (at this level) from that of other countries.

TRADEMARKS: Generally speaking, a trademark is something that signifies or evokes a product provided, sponsored, or endorsed by a particular source. TRADEMARK EXAMPLES: * Word marks such as Apple and iPad; * Logos such as the apple logo; * Sounds such as the "Intel inside" sequence of notes; * Colors, even (sometimes) such as pink for Owens-Corning-brand attic insulation.

(Trademarks are for products; service marks serve the same function for services.)

In a sense, the "owner" of a trademark is really just its government-appointed custodian or guardian. (It's sort of like the old joke: Dogs have masters, cats have staff.) When a trademark owner enforces its rights against an infringer, what the owner is really doing is performing a public service, namely keeping the market free of marks that would be likely to confuse the public.

COPYRIGHT: In contrast, copyright applies to original works of "authorship," regardless whether associated with a product or service.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_in_the_Pe...

Re:Apple can't call an iPad an iPad in China, says court. by PakG1 on Thursday December 08, 2011 @01:17PM (#3330318)
Further analysis seems to say that this was indeed a poor translation. It's a trademark case, not a copyright case. ugh was on the mark.