It was more pleasant to look at and provided more useful functionality on the UI.
The modern trend of wasting space and erasing colors is really bad.
The only new feature I like is the "tab" categories (but only on desktop). Though they really botched it because now I'm confused about the difference between categories and labels so I don't use labels anymore. IMO they should have used the existing labels system for that.
It was also pretty easy to find and read your email, which it currently is not.
I wish there was a better balance between both UIs. The "better looking" one wastes too much resources (CPU, memory, screen space).
It's not about resource cost for me, I use high end hardware and fast connections (coupled with ad and script blockers, both in-browser and at network level, which are probably adding to the frustration) and not only does it load and run like complete crap, I literally couldn't find an email I knew was there in my "inbox" last time I opened it.
I only use Gmail/Workspace for family/personal stuff so I just use mobile apps 99% of the time now, but if I had to use it more regularly I'd be quite annoyed.
Not that Office 365 which I use for work is any better in a web browser.
The "basic HTML" version is probably not exactly as any previous version but it's a good approximation. I think it makes much better use of color and space, and the buttons have text labels instead of using an arcane symbol language I have to relearn every time I have the misfortune to use it.