The cost and time for the construction of new one not included and the risk of sabotage not mentioned. I bet russia will at least try to damage them as a revenge for the help of Ukraine.
It's funny how the Green idea of a large grid that shares power, i.e. it's always windy somewhere, suddenly falls flat when the neighbors wind(nuclear, in this case) is no longer blowing.
The only fault of France is trusting Germany to have a sane power production plan when they entered a peering agreement with them.
More problems like Asse and Brunsbüttel
There is a difference between the outage of an nuclear power plant and the outage of wind turbine.
One power plant less has a much bigger effect than thousand wind turbines without wind. Nuclear power plants are the equivalent of Cloudflare, one outage has massive effects. Wind turbines are decentralization and that's better especially since Russia return as the bad guy.
Didn't hear much fear about Ukrainian wind turbines but lits of worries about nuclear power plants.
The analogy is about how people pushing for wind and solar only/main are relying on every other area to be able to pick up the slack when their area is down. And the fact that they are not able or willing to pick up the slack when someone else's area is down.
Your comment was that Germany is having to support France while they have their reactors down and viewing that in a negative light. If France was supplying power to Germany during a lull in the wind, the response would be "This is just so, even though the wind does not blow all the time, with enough interconnects we can ensure that a green grid is possible."
There was even talk about expanding Europe's grid across to Libya in order to ensure that the wind would be blowing somewhere.
That is just holding one energy source to an impossible standard(i.e. zero downtime) while giving generous excuses to the other.
Last I checked 1840 was not 20,000 times 16. And an ancient leaking nuclear plant barely has a higher capacity factor than current gen offshore wind.
> And an ancient leaking nuclear plant
According to whom? Not the nuclear safety bodies at least.
> current gen offshore wind.
Those are a bit worse than nuclear plants but take roughly the same time to build anyways, the one in France which just went into production took 10 years of development + 4 years of planning so about 14 years.
Which is still about half of the net capacity of new onshore wind. And every year the turbines get bigger.
Dogger bank is a first of its kind project and is on schedule for first power 5 years after site selection.
Hornsea one was one year from construction start to first power and two years to full operation.
Hornsea two was six years from planning start to full operation
Gemini was two years from construction start to full operation.
Triton knoll was five years from planning approval to full operation
Part of the reason that the construction took so long was that the containment building was redesigned to be stronger, that caused a redesign of all the internal components that were already being built.
> In December of 2011, a 19th revision was written for the AP1000 Design Certification, which effectively included a complete redesign of the containment building: >The wall is appropriately reinforced and sized where the composite wall module joins the reinforced concrete sections and as appropriate to accommodate seismic loads and aircraft loads. This design is new to the amendment; previously the structure was all reinforced concrete. >As this change to the design requirements was made after engineering contacts were already signed and manufacturing had begun on the reactor's long-lead-time components, it resulted in a halting of construction as the containment building had to be re-designed.
For a large scale project that had the design changed drastically, I think 10 years is not bad.
> On August 26, 2009, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued an Early Site Permit and a Limited Work Authorization. Limited construction at the new reactor sites began,
13 years and counting, 14 if nothing else goes wrong (unit 4 scheduled for end of 2023).
Then there's all the projects that go the way of VC Summer which get conveniently forgotten about. Vogtle is the 'success' story.
California is building a new desalination plant, a fairly straightforward project with no surprises or midstream design changes, construction is expected to take 3 years.
Let's look at something simple, such as a railway in California. >On December 2, 2010, the Authority Board of Directors voted to begin construction on the first section of the system from Madera to Fresno. >In July 2012, the California legislature and Gov. Jerry Brown approved construction of the high-speed system. >Fresno hosted a groundbreaking ceremony on January 6, 2015, to mark the commencement of sustained construction activities.
It took 5 years from the vote to begin construction to groundbreaking. In 2022, there is still not a ride able section of track yet. The Fresno station, where groundbreaking occurred is scheduled completion in 2029. 14 years, or about the same length of time as Vogal if everything stays on track.
The point is, big construction projects take time and are complicated. If they whipped up a nuclear plant in 3 years, there would be fear mongering about how they must have cut corners and it is unsafe.
We could get the plant completion times down by committing to build more of them. Then all the large and specialized components would be built in more of a production manner rather than a bespoke manner, allowing for both cost and time savings.
If that's true then go for it (it never happened in the past -- costs increased exponentially even before three mile island), but don't ask for special treatment. Whatever deal you demand in terms of fast tracking environmental assessment, guaranteed loans, billions of dollars for free insurance, public resources for security and 40 year guaranteed price for generation should be available for anyone who can meet the 50g carbon intensity target, risk of major accident, and a minimum availability. If you need just two (or ten) more $13/W projects to get you started, then offer the same $30 billion guaranteed loan to tidal and see what happens.
On a level playing field noone in their right mind is going to choose to build nuclear.
I give you the nuclear heat source up front for free. Brand new AP1000 appears up to the second cooling loop by magic.
Steam turbines sans the emission control equipment are about $3k/kWe
Fuel rods are $10-20/MWh. Take it at a constant $10 for an AP1000 (costs of uranium and SWUs go up, but fuel efficiency and fabrication improves at about the same rate).
Decomissioning is underfunded at $10/MWh but we'll pretend this is enough
O&M costs for a steam turbine sans fuel is $10/MWh
Demonstrate how nuclear makes sense with these constraints vs wind at $2000/kW net or solar at $2500/kW net while the gas turbines still run.
Demonstrate how nuclear makes sense vs. Projected costs of pv + wind + h2 + batteries.
How is France dealing with their waste? Can Germany pay France to take it?
Germany's CO2 output is thanks to some politicians who sabotaged the expansion of renewable energy on purpose.
The crisis in both countries is caused by renewables, just in different ways
The reactor France builds is many years late and extremely expensive. France has for decades extremely nuclear friendly governments. The actual problem is money, number of engineers, technical capabilities, ...
To my knowledge, that's the only form of energy with a specific target of reduction in the law, not even petrol is subject to it.
The truth is that the nuclear grid is holding up quite well considering those facts, I don't know anything else where which would still work after two decades being forced to sell electricity below production costs to "competitors" (another subject)
> France has for decades extremely nuclear friendly governments
No it hasn't since the 90s at best.
There were never greens in the French government.
> they even put the reduction of nuclear straight into the law
after decades of little investing in renewable energy, which is now cheap. France has a long coast and lots of sunshine...
Example: there are thousands of offshore wind turbines in Europe. A tiny fraction of those are in France.
> two decades being forced to sell electricity below production
The French nuclear industry now is mostly government owned. It picked up the failed business of EDF, which had debt of around 60 billion euros from exploding costs of new reactor constructions. It was always a political instrument to sell cheap electricity, while the tax payer pays for the hidden additional costs.
France is a democracy, you don't need to be in the governement to have an influence. They had agreements with Chirac and then Hollande against nuclear for their votes.
> after decades of little investing in renewable energy, which is now cheap. France has a long coast and lots of sunshine...
France has invested half of the total price of the nuclear grid in renewable. I do agree that those tremendous renewable investments went poorly though.
Since you're talking about wind turbines, the last one opened took 14 years to build.
> The French nuclear industry now is mostly government owned. It picked up the failed business of EDF, which had debt of around 60 billion euros from exploding costs of new reactor constructions. It was always a political instrument to sell cheap electricity, while the tax payer pays for the hidden additional costs.
Again, I don't see how anything else would have been better. Renewable companies won't last 20 years without investments (that's the full lifetime of solar and wind turbines anyways...) and forced to sell electricity below production cost to their competitors.
Real influence is when a party is part of the government, has ministers, etc. Like the greens in Germany.
Just see the difference renewable energy for electricity production in France is at 20%. In Germany it's currently at around 50%.
If the 'greens' had any influence in France, this influence is not very visible in the results.
> I do agree that those tremendous renewable investments went poorly though.
The investments in nuclear went much worse: half of the reactor fleet is offline and more than a hundred billion Euros is needed for this fleet just to keep it running and replace some of these aging reactors. No wonder EDF is nationalized, with huge debt and billions of more needed - a normal company would already be bankrupt.
> Renewable companies won't last 20 years without investments (that's the full lifetime of solar and wind turbines anyways...) and forced to sell electricity below production cost to their competitors.
Renewables are currently the cheapest source of electricity and its getting cheaper.
Nuclear is only getting more expensive. See the French nuclear power plant in UK (Hinkley Point C), which a very expensive way to produce electricity. Delayed. Cost increases.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/may/20/hinkley-poin...
The new cost increases are paid by the French tax payer.
Yes that's what happened. Real influence is when you sign agreements for your votes at the presidential election in exchange for a few ministers, exactly what the greens did during the past 20 years.
> If the 'greens' had any influence in France, this influence is not very visible in the results.
I can point at actual laws propped up by the greens against their votes if you want, at this point it's just denying reality.
> The investments in nuclear went much worse: half of the reactor fleet is offline and more than a hundred billion Euros is needed for this fleet just to keep it running and replace some of these aging reactors. No wonder EDF is nationalized, with huge debt and billions of more needed - a normal company would already be bankrupt.
Well that's what happens when you stop investments and force selling electricity to below production costs yeah, again you're lucky it's nuclear we're talking about, it would be renewables, the production would have dropped to zero at that point.
> Renewables are currently the cheapest source of electricity and its getting cheaper.
France spent around half the price of the nuclear grid on renewables ... for 7% of the production. This puts it at around 5 times more expensive than the existing nuclear grid without taking into account the backup infrastructure.
The french investment on renewable was one of the most expensive with the lowest output ever performed by the country
This also did not help the current situation either.