Curiously though, since the 1800s analytical mechanics, too, began to be seen as a branch of mathematics. But I think that in this case, just as in the case of quantum mechanics, it is still extremely important to see the physical content, and the physical principles, that allow us to apply this or that mathematical framework. The fact that physics is a heavy user of mathematical methods (probably the heaviest of all sciences) does not mean that it reduces to mathematics. Don't lose the forest for the trees.
That kind of put me off physics, and I've been longing ever since for someone to build a course that essentially covers physics historically, starting from the problems physics helped us solve, and that puts modelling and experiment at the center, instead of just teaching recipes.
I feel the like incredibly common idea that all applications derive from theory might be one of the must harmful misconception in education.
That is, Scott Aaronson should go sit in some collaborator's lab and set up all the apparatus and analyze all the data, before he gets to spew about "quantum" to the general public. This should also apply to any theoretical physicist- I would love to see String Theorists in a lab setting up a michaelson morley experiment.
In that case perhaps attempts to fit QM into continuous physical space is misguided, similar to attempts to explain planetary motion using epicycles.
The realization, apparently due to quantum computing people, that you can get away with not doing QM to things in continous physical space and still understand quite a lot of fun and useful QM stuff is very much valuable; you absolutely can build good courses that way. It’s just that I think that the pedagogical problem of laying out this general “quantum dynamical systems” approach in a compatible and not terribly redundant way to include the things learned a “quantum mechanics in space” course—which is absolutely required if e.g. you want to move on to QFT in solid-state or high-energy physics—is unsolved and to a large extent even untried. (Susskind’s semi-popular book is a notable exception, but I don’t feel he managed to pull it off.)
And, as usual, calling the traditional approach “historical” is a huge stretch. The standard QM course doesn’t talk about the founders’ (valid but extremely clumsy) approaches to relativistic corrections to the hydrogen spectrum any more than the standard calculus course talks about Newton’s early forays into algebraic and (what would come to be called) tropical geometry. (Or the standard programming course talks about native–bytecode interworking in the AGC, but even the most academic of programming courses are rarely branded as historical.)