You're missing the leverage that software gives you. A bakery that keeps track of its Yelp reputation and works hard to maintain a 5-star rating will attract customers from all over the city. It might even start attracting out-of-towners who are in for a visit. This bakery's "market" is effectively unlimited because in any major city, there are going to be out-of-towners flowing in and out on a regular basis, and some of them will be looking for a bakery.
A bakery that doesn't do as well at maintaining a good reputation on Yelp will have its market limited to reach of its advertising and the word-of-mouth of its customers. Now, in a relatively tech-heavy town like San Francisco, that might be fine. If you provide good croissants, you'll get mentions on blogs and Twitter, which would magnify the word of mouth effect in a manner similar to Yelp. But if your customers aren't bloggers or heavy users of social networks? You could have the best bread in the world and not be rewarded commensurately, simply because not enough people know that you have the best bread in the world.
There are "bad breads", or even "mediocre breads", but beyond that, all breads are interesting, each in its own way. I'm not sure I would want to eat the same bread everyday just because it's the "best" one (according to a bunch of Yelp users).
I don't think this "winner takes all" analysis really works for food.
Let's think about something else outside of food. There is probably such a thing as "the world's best laundry service", but do I care? I won't drive ten miles (or even 1 mile) to find a better laundry service, be it marginally better or even incredibly better, if the one that's nearest me is affordable and good enough. I will never know they exist because I won't look for them.
So I'm not sure "winner takes all" works for proximity services in general.
That's not to say that technology cannot disrupt those markets; someone could build a machine that lets people cook incredible bread in the house (it's been tried, and failed miserably up to now, but that doesn't mean it can't happen).
But the whole "bakers need to become experts at managing their online social reputation" line of reasoning strikes me as misguided and, frankly, the root of a lot of evil in modern society.
I'd rather patronize bakers who are experts at baking. There are many of them.
Never used Yelp, but do you really need a developer to do that? Would think the easiest way to get a good rating would be to hire some people to write good reviews for you and trash the competition.
(OT, but I bet sites like that will get less and less useful as more companies start gaming them)
However, it's inevitable (or at least hugely likely) that you will be found out and your repution ruined. Competitors will likely sue.
It's probably cheaper and easier to hire a developer who can write tools to monitor reviews posted online, manage a website, run your facebook group/app, write an app to make it easy for customers to order bread from their mobiles, and so on.
All of those things are legitimate activities and add genuine value to your business. They are also things that are impossible to achieve if you don't have technical knowledge.
> > Hiring people to "write good reviews for you and trash the
> > competition" is a quick way to establish a very short-lived
> > repuation boost.
>
> However, it's inevitable (or at least hugely likely) that you will
> be found out and your repution ruined.
Short of your reviewers deliberately snitching on you, how exactly is
anyone ever going to find out?I'd really, sincerely like to know -- as I can't tell which strongly positive or negative reviews on various sites like Amazon, IMDB, etc, are written by hired reviewers and which are real.
Of course, I have my suspicions.. but no real proof. And I don't see any way to ever get real proof -- unless the reviewer confesses.
So.. what's the secret?
Secondly, a sudden increase in the number of positive reviews should be fairly easy to spot by a competitor who has already hired a developer to watch for such things and do automated sentiment analysis on the reviews of competitors.
Thirdly, it's entirely possible that a broader-spectrum monitoring of reviews (perhaps provided by a third-party service) could identify common authors and/or text that is likely to be fake by analysing the content of the reviews themselves. This would help pick up paid reviews that were placed over a long period of time.
Why would they go public? They're presumably making (what they consider to be) good money writing fake reviews. By going public they'd be 1 - losing their revenue from you, 2 - undermining the public's confidence in reviews, which would translate in to a less lucrative business for the provider of fake reviews.
As for blackmail, I'm sure it happens from time to time. But I don't know how to estimate the frequency with which fake reviewers blackmail their clients. What is your basis for estimating the probability of such blackmail as "very likely"?
Furthermore, blackmail is an obvious risk for any secret/illegal undertaking, and yet people attempt try to do things in secret and break the law all the time. Clearly, for them the risk seems worth it (at the time).
"Secondly, a sudden increase in the number of positive reviews should be fairly easy to spot by a competitor who has already hired a developer to watch for such things and do automated sentiment analysis on the reviews of competitors."
So, the fake positive reviews might be staggered over a reasonable period of time. But even the business receives many positive reviews in a short period of time, that's not proof the reviews were fake.
"Thirdly, it's entirely possible that a broader-spectrum monitoring of reviews (perhaps provided by a third-party service) could identify common authors and/or text that is likely to be fake by analyzing the content of the reviews themselves. This would help pick up paid reviews that were placed over a long period of time."
Are there any such services which claim to be able to detect fake reviews? Or is this mere speculation on your part? Regardless, just because some service or algorithm claims a review is fake doesn't mean it is. Once again, their guess/estimate is not proof.
Sorry, my bracketed "(ex-)employees" wasn't really clear enough. I was trying to suggest a vengeful motive after they had been fired.
> What is your basis for estimating the probability of such blackmail as "very likely"?
Basic human nature. If you're directly employing people whose job is clearly unethical then you're painting yourself into a corner. Either they do in fact actively blackmail you or else you will feel unable to fire them in case they start telling people what you're up to - I'm regarding this implicit threat as passive blackmail here.
I agree with you that there are lots of people who seem perfectly happy to do unethical or illegal things in order to make a living. They calculate (if not always very accurately) that the potential gains outweigh the potential costs.
However, a lot of these people make such a decision in light of particular circumstances e.g. their low intelligence, or their lack of employability (due in part perhaps to an existing criminal record), or their unwillingness to work.
Someone who has established a business that is making enough money to pay the bills should clearly be reaching a different conclusion to these sorts of people (at least most of the time). Their potential losses are much higher (i.e. loss of the business) and the potential gains are actually not all that favourable compared to doing things the "right way" - for example, by hiring a developer who can boost your business in other ways.
> But even the business receives many positive reviews in a short period of time, that's not proof the reviews were fake.
It's evidence. What a business owner might do if they suspected a competitor had hired someone to "opinion spam" is up to them. If they though a competitor was paying someone to post negative reviews of their own business then they could very well sue, and request access logs etc. from the review site in order to further the investigation.
> Are there any such services which claim to be able to detect fake reviews?
I haven't looked. But it would certainly be possible to create such a service without too much difficulty.
That's a little too good to be true, and the bakery example stroke me as very ill-suited.
I enjoyed the article, though, and I wish it were true that clueless incumbents would die rapidly and developers would get infinite leverage.
What I think is true is that developers will get a little more leverage while clueless incumbents will take forever to disappear.
(Edit: in the long run, everyone will be a developer. There will still be good and bad developers, but there won't be non-developers professionals, just like today there are not many people with a job who can't read or write.)
We are not all mechanics. In fact, the knowledge of how to make a simple repair like fixing a puncture in a tire is much less prevalent now than it was forty years ago. Nevermind the knowledge of how to troubleshoot a vehicle that won't start.
The consequence of this is that knowledge of the mechanics of the complex system that is a modern vehicle is typically beyond any one person, and certainly well beyond the majority of its users.
Today there is leverage in far flung industries for the individual who has specialized knowledge of his field AND knowledge of how to apply software development to that field. But these opportunities will not last long. Any software that can increase profits in an industry will attract competition from other software developers. That software will be improved and refined by software specialists. It will (and has) evolved to a systemic complexity that equals the modern vehicle.
Software is a tool. The civil engineer who uses AutoCAD to design your road does not need to know how to code his own AutoCAD.
Although industry standard tools with scripting environments often have active communities of people developing sophisticated tools on top of them. Encase is one example; the Canadian Mounties write quite a bit. Splunk is another. Niches may asymptotically outrun good software.
A lot depends upon the focus and goals of the business owner. The owner that is happy staying as a corner boulangerie could get just as much accomplished by making sure that they are active on a neighborhood mailing list that distributes a hardcopy newsletter to each new resident arriving in the neighborhood, than by paying someone to manage their Yelp presence, for much cheaper. Somone who wants to run a local chain of coffeeshops that push their baked goods on the other hand, might find it more feasible to pay someone to manage their Yelp presence.
The author doesn't make this clear, but I suspect (due to the Forbes origination of the content) he assumes the reader is someone who intends to run a scaled-up business as opposed to a classical "small Mom & Pop" operation. Otherwise, I find the "software as core" argument he puts forward a little difficult to buy into.
(which does have excellent coffee, by the way...)
If you have to drive 30 miles to find a bakery then it makes sense to try to find out which one is worth the effort.
Which makes me wonder: is this an American problem? In cities where
1. almost anything is accessible by foot
2. driving is extremely annoying and expensive
you have an enormous incentive to choose services based on proximity rather than their current Yelp rating (or lack thereof).
It is a combination of hipster fantasies, delusions, and a hope for a business model.
Yet, I've never eaten anything from it, preferring several alternatives that are several blocks away. Why? My coworkers warned me of dubious sanitary practices (it even looks dirty), and none of them eats there. So "social" made me not choose that bakery.
A new worker at my building might not know of that, and thus might ignorantly go to that bakery. More likely, a contractor, deliveryman or similar, would find such a service very useful.
As usual, there are a few startups working on that :) (I know of one).
I still like the "trying out new stuff" approach, but I can see that experience being augumented by social networks.
I don't think this is true right now; I very much doubt it will ever be true.
I live within walking distance of not less than five excellent boulangeries and have never used any sort of "social" tool or other technology to select the one I'm going to buy bread from. I try them all regularly, know what they do well or less well (one is better at croissants than the others) and basically go to the one that offers the best version of the product I'm looking for.
Looking for "bargains" in bakery is asking for trouble; choosing your bread according to your "social network" (who's composed of people who do not live right next to you) sounds completely useless.
It doesn't seem like bakers need to worry about Groupon, or Yelp. Is this just a poor example or am I missing something?