News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calif. Law to Protect Children's Privacy Could Lead to In... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday October 08, 2022 @07:06PM (#33136902)
Do not collect data from anyone, including minors.

No one, whether they are 18 or 81, wants to consent to data collection.

But "tech" companies cannot survive without conducting surveillance. And so it is the false "tradeoff" (false dilemma) that they must sell to the public to survive.^1

Why do so many "dark patterns" exist. Because no one in their right mind wants to consent to what is actually going on with the collected data at these websites, which need not be disclosed by law so how would anyone on the outside even know. We let these websites get away with this nonsense in the case of adults but with children it is just too egregious to allow. Hence the AADC. This by no means suggests that adults want to consent. The dark patterns target people of any age.

1. If do not allow data collection and surveillance then there can be no web. That is total BS. We just saw instructions on how to download Wikipedia yesterday on the HN front page. We can build hospitals with opioid money but that does not provide a justification for selling opioids without restriction. We can also build hospitals with taxes or donations.

Re:Calif. Law to Protect Children's Privacy Could Lead to In... by LegionMammal978 on Saturday October 08, 2022 @07:32PM (#33137044)
Out of curiosity, what exactly would you define as "collecting data"? There has been much debate over what that particular term encompasses. Clearly, if a website sells users' browsing data to third parties so they can build an ad profile, they would be collecting data in your sense. But on the other end, if a forum site stores the contents of its users' posts to display them to other users, then it's considered business as usual.

So what exact actions make up "collecting data"? Is it how long the data is stored? How the data is obtained from the users? Whether the users are aware that it is stored? What kind of data is stored? How the data is used by the website? Whether the data is transmitted to third parties? Some combination of all of these?

People both on this site and elsewhere have come up with different answers to all of these questions, and we need to nail it down if we want to have effective regulations.