The usual ethical difference, as I've understood it from prior discussions, is that a legal adult user can always consent to a company using their data, so long as the data is knowingly given to the company, the user has been honestly informed of what that data is used for, and the user can revoke the company's access to their data at any point. (Some people recognize less-strict conditions as acceptable, I'm just taking these as a baseline.)
However, many of these new regulations outright prohibit minor users' data from being used in certain ways, even if those users have freely consented to it, with the justification that minors are unable to evaluate the full consequences of their data being used. Since businesses face major liability for violating these regulations, they have two options: either implement the strictest possible age-related regulation for every user, or implement an age gate that cannot be circumvented short of the user committing fraud.
In this particular regulation, some of the wording is vague, requiring a "compelling reason" to collect minor users' data, regardless of those users' consent. Businesses abhor that kind of liability: how do they protect every user as if they might be a vulnerable minor, under every possible interpretation of the regulation? The easier path by far is to require an age gate.
Thus, I'd argue that the better path would be to require uniform privacy regulations, recognizing that random websites don't want to be in the business of age verification. Either require the same strong privacy regulations for all users, or don't implement the new regulations for minors at all.
No one, whether they are 18 or 81, wants to consent to data collection.
But "tech" companies cannot survive without conducting surveillance. And so it is the false "tradeoff" (false dilemma) that they must sell to the public to survive.^1
Why do so many "dark patterns" exist. Because no one in their right mind wants to consent to what is actually going on with the collected data at these websites, which need not be disclosed by law so how would anyone on the outside even know. We let these websites get away with this nonsense in the case of adults but with children it is just too egregious to allow. Hence the AADC. This by no means suggests that adults want to consent. The dark patterns target people of any age.
1. If do not allow data collection and surveillance then there can be no web. That is total BS. We just saw instructions on how to download Wikipedia yesterday on the HN front page. We can build hospitals with opioid money but that does not provide a justification for selling opioids without restriction. We can also build hospitals with taxes or donations.
So what exact actions make up "collecting data"? Is it how long the data is stored? How the data is obtained from the users? Whether the users are aware that it is stored? What kind of data is stored? How the data is used by the website? Whether the data is transmitted to third parties? Some combination of all of these?
People both on this site and elsewhere have come up with different answers to all of these questions, and we need to nail it down if we want to have effective regulations.
https://www.thedailybeast.com/beyond-sketchy-facebook-demand...
https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/18/18485089/facebook-email-p...
Facebook does not sell user data. No need. They sell access to the targets of the collection to advertisers, including political campaigns, among other things. We have no way to know all the uses Facebook makes of the data they collect.
If Facebook were to go under, what would happen to the all the data collected.
What should be most concerning is that Facebook buys data. When combined with the data they have collected about people, this creates a potential hazard the Facebook user has no way to assess. There is nothing in any Privacy Policy, including Facebook's, that suggests a website operator will not obtain data about the website users from other sources.
In addition, with use of "beacons" or similar, Facebook collects data about what websites Facebook users, and www users in general, visit outside of Facebook.
Perhaps people would not consent to Facebook holding so much data about them, from various sources. Far more than what they themselves have voluntarily submitted to Facebook. We will never know because people are not full information and the choice whether to opt out.
Facebook is not a credit bureau. When credit bureaus tried to collect this much data about people from various sources, the practice became the subject of federal regulation. For example, FCRA, FACTA, FCBA and Reg B.
False dichotomy.
If the website protects the privacy of all persons, not just those under 18, then there is no problem complying this law.
It's like the folks who claim the web cannot or would not exist unless advertising is permitted. It is a self-serving statement of an opinion. It has no evidentiary basis.
This false prediction, nonsense reasoning is probably accepted by generations that did not experience the internet before advertising was permitted, before online advertising became pervasive, and/or before online advertising was based on data collection and targeted. The fact is the internet and web did exist without advertising. There is no technical limitation that requires a website to collect data and/or serve ads.
Common retorts to such historical facts include such gems as
"I would never want to go back to 199x", or
"All the wonderful content of the web today would disappear."
1. Computers and networks are never going to return to 1990's prices and speeds. Speeds keep increasing and prices keep decreasing.
2. Who would have guessed, but today's commercial web content is actually being generated mostly by web users themselves. "Tech" companies operating high traffic websites have promoted their own "business", online advertising, to lure people into uploading to their websites without expecting payment in return. Like some sort of opaque lottery. This is why the web has become a cesspool of "clickbait" and garbage "content".