Almost but not quite. I came to comment on this bullet point in the article because misunderstanding about PHI is so prevalent its nearly a meme.
PHI doesn't have anything to do with willingness or sharing. PHI is not a meaningful term constructed of its component words - its a specific legal term under hipaa. Any (noncovered entity) company can ask you anything about your health and it doesn't matter - airlines, restaurants, event venues, etc. They're allowed and it doesn't have anything to do with hipaa and they are not collecting/storing PHI.
HIPAA applies specifically to covered entities under its law. Its basically health care providers and health insurance companies. If you aren't one of those covered entities and youre not telling that info to a covered entity, there is no PHI.
If you want to boycot somewhere asking about covid or whatever - get down with your bad self. It just doesn't have anything to do with HIPAA.
A specific example: I work on an app that does include HIPAA-regulated PHI, and sometimes I'll demo stuff in production by demoing my own personal account. I usually preface it by saying "This is my account, so it's OK to share" so folks know I haven't just pulled up someone else's data. If I had pulled up someone else's data and shared it without their consent, that would be a HIPAA violation.
An excellent point. Which is why I don't share my Fitbit data (unisntalled the app after set up, no syncing of data) with Fitbit (now Google) and will (assuming it works as advertised) likely be moving to a MiBand with GadgetBridge[0] in the near future. And thanks to vanous[1] for posting[2] here about it a couple weeks ago.
I have no interest in sharing my health (exercise regimes, sleep cycles, heart rate, etc.) information with folks whose raison d'etre is to snarf up as much data as possible. What's more, since these folks aren't "covered entities" under HIPAA, they aren't required to put in the special safeguards for your health data.
And more's the pity.
[0] https://codeberg.org/Freeyourgadget/Gadgetbridge
Data brokers for pharmacy have your prescription data, your doctor is not protected information and other aspects of your care are available to many entities for purposes like insurance subrogation that also create data products.
HIPAA protects you from gossiping clerks at health facilities and HR. It prevents the use of some bad IT practices, and forces you to sign lots of disclosures. That’s about it.
If you want that type of information to be private, don’t collect it or don’t share it with 3rd parties in an accessible form.
Yes. Absolutely.
I thought that was what I said. Perhaps what's in my head didn't make it to the comment?
There are some carve outs. For example, financial services companies don't have any additional privacy requirements if you buy a prescription with your Visa instead of cereal. That carve out was specifically added to the HIPAA legislation.
https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/laws-reg...
Note that this is a high-level summary.
I think this just means health care industry and those who build systems for health care information?
Going to keep researching, but I don't think that it applies to literally every workplace.
That information is tainted with the restrictions and keeps them regardless of where it goes. If it gets disclosed outside of that it becomes a violation.
So nobody working for a hospital you get care for can disclose things. Nobody the hospital hires to provide services or handle your data, etc.
You can sign away those rights or give your own information away.
If the data doesn't come up through a relationship with a healthcare provider, it's not PHI.
It's not HIPAA protected because that person isn't Jenny's doctor, but it's still PHI.
Her boss doesn't have a duty to keep it private in any legal sense. Jenny can ask not to tell anyone, but legally, it doesn't matter.
But PHI as a concept doesn't need HIPAA. In fact, it's probably good practice to isolate PHI, even if you don't need to be HIPAA-compliant. The PHI is only one join away anyway.
Then again, a ton of practices described in the article are probably blatant violations of the GDPR like scraping LinkedIn to track the titles and job changes of champions. I guess a PII request under the GDPR would include data stored in Salesforce, which would make the result fairly awkward depending on what information sales people decide to keep in there.
Given that I've seen companies having to explain to sales people that they can't just repurpose dodgy e-mail lists for direct sales outreach without having any records suggesting the victi-... err... "prospects" consented to that use, I wouldn't be surprised if most sales teams are violating the GDPR left and right on a daily basis.
The reason I commented is because there is a ton of misunderstanding in the real world that confuses "Joe isn't on the call today because he's got COVID" with the legal responsibilities that, say, your doctor has when sending you your COVID results.
To be honest, I think there is a lot of unnecessary concern over health information due to this misunderstanding. Obviously there is a ton of information that people prefer to keep private, but in those cases, they keep it private, or would at least tell you not to tell anyone. Due to the misunderstanding about PHI, I think people mistakenly confuse any banal health information as inherently requiring a higher level of protection/discretion, and this isn't really true. Frankly, there is a ton of other info that people probably want to keep more private than whether or not they had COVID (these days, who hasn't?) or whether someone is pregnant (usually makes itself self-evident in any case).
First of all, you shared it. The whole reason for protecting PHI in the first place is limiting what others can do with your information, not what you can do with it. And if you share it willingly, and not for medical purposes, it doesn't mean that the person you shared it with suddenly has a higher burden of security/privacy with that info.
Just calling this out because so often see people that fundamentally misunderstand what "PHI" means in a legal sense, and specifically what the HIPAA regulations require.