The only ad they show is a regular display and on the right hand side out of the video frame, and as far as I know revenue from that ad is never given to the creator anyway.
It may depend on what country you're in or if you're on mobile or not. I wouldn't know for certain, I'm a uBO/NewPipe man.
I may be wrong but I don't see evidence that Youtube continues showing ads on demonetized content like these explicit Ukraine war videos. The reason is that the advertisers who pay money to Google don't want their brands associated with certain types of lurid content. (See Adpocalypse: https://www.google.com/search?q=biggest+advertisers+abandon+...)
So, Google is being extra strict with ads on these videos to avoid an angry call from a giant advertiser like Proctor & Gamble complaining, "Why are you showing my dish soap ads on a video of a naked guy getting killed while pooping?!?" (E.g.: https://www.tubefilter.com/2018/04/20/pg-resumes-youtube-spe...)
There also may be some confusion about some videos with ads and creators not getting the money: the creator has not been accepted into the Partner Program for revenue sharing. Yes, in those cases, the creators are not getting ad $$$ -- even for safe ad-friendly videos.
But these Ukraine demonetization videos seem more like not repeating the Adpocalypse debacle and Google will not run ads on them.
Of course, Google/Youtube's system isn't perfect so there will be false-positives. Will there be indecent videos that Google improperly display ads on? Yes. Will there also be high-quality channels that got unfairly demonetized even if advertisers would have no objection to their content? Yes.
You're quite right that there's some confusion between Partner Program eligibility and demonetization proper. This Ukraine war creator actually talks about being removed from the Partner Program in the video linked in this post.
† It was a deepfake of the current Israeli Prime Minister explaining why I should vote for Shas, a party of which he is most definitely not a member. Not relevant to this issue but too crazy not to mention.
Which all suggests, there is something going on other than "no cheerleading deaths".
The question I’d ask, is if it’s not above the Feds and Social Media to collude to censor COVID content, why wouldn’t they use the same techniques in an actual war? It’s pretty obvious what we’re seeing is a public-private partnership to censor content.
Patreon offers no way to add a one-time boost, which sucks.
Also added one for Suchomimus, who I assume has also been hit.
Now let's say you're on the other end, an advertiser that pays for placements, and you see your ads showing on videos where people literally die on camera, with funny reactions, videos and sounds. Do you think that it has the potential of ruining your business or not? Sorry to say but I take YT's side in this matter.
Nobody thinks an advertiser paid for a video of death and destruction. Everyone knows that sort of content is 100% between the uploader and YouTube.
Couple of possibilities:
- it may be a temporary false-positive for demonetization : their A.I. algorithm with (with imperfect heuristics) scanned a bunch of channels for questionable Ukraine content and automatically demonetized them skipping any human judgement. In some cases, the youtuber appeals it and they get re-monetized again. As an example, the youtube aviation channel "blancolirio" went through this. He started making videos about Boeing 737-MAX which automatically got de-monetized by the algorithm because it had "737MAX" in the titles but his later crash-analysis videos got monetized after human review. E.g. from [1] "(Note: after initially demonetizing this video, after a human review YT re-monetized it...Why? I have No Idea.)" And his recent video analyzing Las Vegas plane crash is also monetized with Youtube ads.[2]
- Youtube suddenly got stricter about the Ukraine topic so more channels are getting caught up in the dragnet. If that's the case, hopefully the high-quality channels will appeal and a human reviewing it will turn on monetization again. I'm guessing a quality channel like Perun will pass human review and get re-monetized to override the auto-demonetization. However, the channel (Artur Rehi) cited by this particular thread probably will not because his type of content is not "advertiser-friendly".
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8_vl3theT8, [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2Up_Cw8X-g
You are suggesting that there is some sort of moral equivalence between a Ukrainian fighting a war to defend the existence of their country and a Russian fighting to conquer said country.
That is just sad.
It's OK to cheer when the bad guy has a bad day.
In any case, why would you begrudge someone trying to tell the rest of the world what is going on there? It's not like you're going to find any dispassionate, unopinionated, completely neutral news agency out there. That just doesn't exist.
(And by the way there's a massive difference between biaised news, and posting what is basically snuff content... Advertisers have no issue rolling ads on CNN even when it covers wars, but there's a reason why they don't broadcast gore/graphical content.)
I understand his instinct to self-title his video as "I cover the war" which implies a noble journalistic service for viewers but in comparing other youtube channels talking about Ukraine that did not get de-monetized, I'm guessing his type of content crosses the line.
E.g. one of his videos shows a grenade being dropped on a soldier while he has his pants down taking a dump. His commentary is to joke about it and vocalize a "boom" sound effect. The video is not blurred out and he did not set the "age restricted" flag. I won't link the video directly but you can easily find it.
Another perspective to look at the above scenario... if Google Youtube splits ad revenue 55% creator + 45% to Google.... Is the public ok with Google getting 45% of ad money from someone cheerleading a war death?
That's not a rhetorical question. I didn't do a survey so I really don't know what the answer is.
I noticed that several other Youtube channels cover Ukraine topics without getting demonetized:
https://www.youtube.com/c/RealLifeLore/search?query=ukraine
https://www.youtube.com/c/Taskandpurpose/search?query=ukrain...
https://www.youtube.com/c/CaspianReport/search?query=ukraine
I'm guessing those channels will be fine because they don't show raw war footage while jeering at human suffering.
I don't know if Youtube automatically demonetizes because of an algorithm sweeping through the channels or there was a human that decided his particular channel.