News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by throwawaysleep on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:44AM (#33122065)
Isn't that the business model with low skill workers though? Figure out how to employ them in a way that they don't need training and all is well.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by willturman on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:54AM (#33122184)
I would argue that a "low skill worker" doesn't exist as anything but a pejorative stereotype for large swaths of people who form and perform functions that create the foundation on which an economy runs.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by commandlinefan on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:03AM (#33122309)
Well I mean c'mon... are you seriously trying to suggest that every job takes the same level of skill as every other job? There are people who don't want to spend years of their lives working math problems to get to the point where they can become highly specialized and are happy being "low skilled" because they get more time to themselves.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by tonnydourado on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:12AM (#33122440)
How many software developers do you think can work in a kitchen? Or clean houses? Or work on construction?
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by snapcaster on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:28AM (#33122647)
Probably almost all of them right?
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by danaris on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:37AM (#33122773)
Work in a kitchen: Maybe. Actually do a good job, walking in off the street? Nope. There are dozens of things you need to know and be able to do to work well in a kitchen—and those things change depending on what kind of kitchen it is, but one of them that doesn't change is clear, fast, in-person communication, including doing what you're told instantly. A software developer going into a kitchen job and thinking they're hot shit because they're coming from a "skilled job" and this is an "unskilled job" is going to get themselves or someone else badly injured very quickly.

Clean a house: Yeah, probably. Clean houses well enough to be paid for it: Probably not. Clean houses, well enough to be paid for it, 40 hours a week, for years: Very unlikely. That takes not just the skills to actually get each house professionally clean, but the mindset to be able to handle that sort of work for long periods.

Work construction: Almost certainly not. While not all construction requires heavy lifting, most does, and most software developers are not in good enough physical shape to do that on a regular basis without doing serious damage to their bodies. Not to mention the care and precision required to build things that will both look good and last.

Because "be able to do this job" doesn't just mean "has the basic understanding of how the mechanics of it work." It means understanding the details and nuances, being willing as well as able to do it for long periods of time, and being able to do it to a professional standard, not just "good enough for me".

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by ahtihn on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:12PM (#33123270)
Low skill is about whether you expect any experience or qualifications when filling positions.

Some businesses are built around the fact that most of their workforce will be composed of untrained people with 0 qualifications and very high turnover. See Amazon warehouse jobs, most fast food places. Lots of retail jobs.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by danaris on Friday October 07, 2022 @03:12PM (#33125661)
Sure; that's the reasonable way to talk about what "low skill" means.

The problem is that too many people are still stuck in classist, neofeudal mindsets and equate "working in a low skill job" with "being an inferior person, not worthy of respect/dignity/decent wages/a comfortable life/etc".

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by orwin on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:41PM (#33123703)
You are right, but tbh, the first and the third are considered skilled jobs. My sister had a work visa opportunity to the US with her cooking skills (she chose another path in the end), and it was easier for her than it is for most SWE.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by vinceguidry on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:42PM (#33124578)
> most software developers are not in good enough physical shape to do that on a regular basis without doing serious damage to their bodies

That's reaching a bit. I worked construction for years before starting a software career. There's lots of construction jobs that don't require a whole lot of heavy lifting. In fact, there are probably more of them that don't than do. And you probably overestimate the lack of health of office workers.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by dogleash on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:36PM (#33124504)
Nope. The group of people who succeed at desk jobs includes many people who can not cope with the different demands and stresses in menial jobs.

I volunteer a few days a year at an event that attracts white collar people as attendees and volunteers. It's a few days of blue-collar work that I find an absolute cakewalk but newbies wash out so often that first time volunteers are only allowed to shadow someone we trust not to quit on the spot.

I can't really explain without making some sweeping statements that will not go over well on HN. So I'll ask this: how many cords of wood have you stacked in your life? And do the personality types on HN strike you as the kind of people you'd ask to come help you stack your firewood?

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by tonnydourado on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:00PM (#33124808)
Not even in the same city of right.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by N1H1L on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:09PM (#33124126)
Absolutely true. This is where the privilege shows. I have helped friends run restaurants, and it's brutal and draining. And there is an enormous amount of pretty unique skills required to succesfully run a restaurant. And I am saying this as a scientist with a Ph.D. and multiple publications - the very definition of today's "skilled worker."

The weird thing that has happened is the "collegification" of skills. Unless the job requires an undergrad or, even better, a graduate degree, it's apparently not skillful.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by uncletaco on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:14AM (#33122466)
I don't feel like driving a UPS truck gives me more time to myself. Between driving around all day with no AC and hitting the gym so that I can continue to lift and run around with mystery boxes I just don't see all this extra time materializing.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by danaris on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:27AM (#33122637)
This is painting it as black and white: either there are jobs that require no skill or all jobs require the same amount of skill.

Neither of these are the case: Some jobs require significantly more skill and training than others, but no job is unskilled.

And, as others note, the idea that jobs that require less training give you more time to yourself is just ludicrously out of touch with reality. Not only are they more likely to be jobs that expect you to work grueling hours, they also pay so little that many people who work them must work more than one every day just to pay the bills.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by triceratops on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:25PM (#33123461)
Music, nursing, game development, animation, art, school teaching are all highly-skilled professions. They aren't particularly highly-paid.

We should maybe talk about high-supply and low-supply skills instead.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by Jensson on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:11PM (#33124167)
Those jobs are paid way higher than low skill jobs though, and nobody calls them low skill, so I don't see the problem.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by triceratops on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:14PM (#33127506)
Because the common rejoinder to the low pay of "low skill" jobs is to tell those people to become "high skill". When in fact, "high" and "low" skill is only one factor, and not even the major one, in whether you're going to be well paid.

Another reply said nurses are "highly paid" because they make an average of $70-100k. That is laughable. I made more than that at my first job, at a no-name tech company, when all I knew was jQuery and 4 HTTP verbs. Or compare the valuation of any medical tech, or biochem, or materials sciences company compared to the latest photo sharing phenomenon slapped together by some hungover Stanford grads. How much do experienced chemical, or mechanical, or civil engineers make compared to new grad software devs? Who's more "skilled"?

Supply and demand is where it's at. It's pretty easy to increase the supply of janitors or line cooks, so their pay sucks, even though demand is always strong and the work isn't particularly easy or pleasant. There are countless musicians and actors in the world, far more than there could ever be demand for. So their pay, on average, also sucks.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by Amezarak on Saturday October 08, 2022 @02:38PM (#33134780)
In flyover country, 70-100k is a fantastic wage for a software developer.

Source: after 10 years of being a star performer and job hopping I have nearly tripled my salary…to a little more than 100k. New hires are making less than half that at my current company.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by triceratops on Thursday October 13, 2022 @08:28AM (#33190066)
70-100k is a fantastic wage in Eastern Europe or Asia too. Not sure why that's germane to this discussion.

And no that's still quite low for a software developer in flyover country. It might be a good wage compared to median wages for everyone, but only because everyone else has lower wages too (to be fair, offset by lower cost of housing too).

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by Amezarak on Thursday October 13, 2022 @06:07PM (#33197073)
> And no that's still quite low for a software developer in flyover country.

If you know at what company I can do better without relocating, I'd be delighted to hear it.

> It might be a good wage compared to median wages for everyone

It's not even really that, it's a normal middle class professional wage, though the high end is good. We've had juniors leave to pursue other careers...one (who'd actually done fairly well, closer to 100k than 50k) left to be a nurse, because he'd make more money. Software isn't really that great a field unless you plan to move somewhere like California.

"Supply and demand" is highly regionally dependent.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by triceratops on Monday October 17, 2022 @10:44AM (#33234183)
Lots of California and East Coast companies are hiring remote these days. You could easily break $150k without moving if you interview well. $200k+ is attainable once you have more of a track record of working for such companies.

My resume is all Silicon Valley/Bay Area tech, so my inbox has more of these opportunities. It might be harder at the beginning but you only need one of those jobs to establish that "pedigree" (it's dumb, I know).

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by umeshunni on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:01PM (#33124832)
Music / Art - highly paid at the extremes. Probably because music and art are currently infinitely reproducible and so a small number of highly paid, high "talent" content creators can create content for billions of people.

Nursing - highly paid (https://nursinglicensemap.com/resources/nurse-salary/).

Game development - highly paid (https://builtin.com/salaries/dev-engineer/game-developer)

School teaching - low/medium pay - mostly for political reasons (i.e most are state employees).

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by triceratops on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:23PM (#33125079)
Yeah no nursing and game development are not "highly paid". They pay a middle-class wage.

Music and art paid like shit even when it wasn't infinitely reproducible.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by pdntspa on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:47AM (#33122107)
It's an incredibly shitty model for everyone but shareholders. Why do we have to institutionalize abuse?
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by DesiLurker on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:29PM (#33123520)
My high level analysis is that this is because of institutionalized 'dispersion of responsibility' stemming from the pure capitalistic doctrine we all have supposedly signed up for. Essentially you have individual entities whose responsibility (& only one) to maximize the profit. so anything that is measurable ends up getting projected on one dimension of 'capital'. There is a lot of talk about social responsibility but most 'don't be evil' lasts until a few bad quarters and then its back to same story.

No supposedly the govt/unions are supposed to provide a counterbalance to this but for some incredible reason folks here in America are convinced that any collective action is basically soviet style socialism hence out of question. So what we are left with is this dispersion of responsibility to do social good but no one actually in charge of it. And don't even get me started on the Senate composition/electoral college & institutionalized gerrymandering (so you can actually fix it with simple majority you need a special kind of majority).

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by yourapostasy on Sunday October 09, 2022 @10:25AM (#33141399)
> ...any collective action is basically soviet style socialism hence out of question.

Ironically, the set of interlocking directorships, foundation seats, advisorships, consulting arrangements, share holdings, etc. among politicians, C-suite and EVP layers is every bit as collectivist as an old Soviet farm or modern workers' union. I personally model it as the strongest union out there because it doesn't need to operate by open rules relying upon legislation but is instead an acculturated reinforcement mechanism amongst its members that flexibly adapts to its host socioeconomic framework, making it harder than any conventional union to bust up or influence.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by AlexandrB on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:02AM (#33122294)
The newer goal seems to be employing them in a way that doesn't need training, but then claiming that "flipping a burger" is a business secret and making them sign a broad non-compete anyway.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by UncleMeat on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:00PM (#33123990)
There is (almost) no such thing as unskilled labor. If you've ever tried to move your furniture to a new place and also paid people to move your stuff you'll see that movers are like 5x more efficient, yet it would be considered an "unskilled" job.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by bluGill on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:05PM (#33124890)
McDonald's is considered a low skill job, but in reality it is high skill, but they have done very well into breaking those skills down so that with just half an hour of "class room training" (on a video), and a couple hours with a trainer you can be productive. Repeat this for a new area a few shifts latter, soon you have a lot of skills with minimal investment.
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by SkyBelow on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:30PM (#33125165)
>There is (almost) no such thing as unskilled labor.

That is arguing against a strawman created by an argument that isn't fully specified.

Even walking takes skill. What is meant when people talk about the skill involved in work is how hard is it to train someone to do the job, generally someone with the knowledge and physical skills an adult is expected to have but without any special training beyond that.

Some jobs can be picked up in under a week of training. Other jobs require years of training. Some require physical skills that are quite common among the population even if the average adult doesn't have them (say something like a fitness level 1/3 of adults have).

Discussions of skilled vs. unskilled labor rarely if ever get into where exactly the line is drawn at, but there is a common understanding that jobs can generally be classified as either something an average adult could be taught how to do on the job or not.

Why this matters is that it determines competition for jobs. The more people able to do the job, the less one has to offer to find someone willing to accept. If you can train the average adult to do the job on the job, then you are competing with working adults at large. If you can't, at least reasonably, train someone on the job, then you are competing with far fewer individuals.

Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by version_five on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:20PM (#33124282)
I think your point could be rephrased around the business model being to turn jobs into low skill jobs (basically by removing any human agency) so that labor becomes a pure commodity. Uber is the closest I've seen to that I'm practice. I suspect some warehouse jobs are like that too. Most of the time it doesn't work, which is why Uber for X never really caught on, because you can't commodify e.g. a handyman the way you can a car ride
Re:Managers with a business degree reduce employees' wages, ... by ghaff on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:09PM (#33127466)
Driving at least in the same universe as competent is something that most adults need to be able to do for other reasons so Uber (sort of) works. And the product is pretty standardized--get me from A to B which is so far/so long.

Most handyman--much less general contractor--tasks are a lot more variable and I even have some issues with my lawn guy once I get beyond the contracted every two week mow.