News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by iainctduncan on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:09AM (#33121562)
The Gladwell book is so bad it's laughable. It's a gross misrepresentation of the work of Anders Ericsson, with completely unfounded extrapolations. So bad it prompted Ericsson to get a non-academic writer to work with him to write his own popular science version of his work, which is titled "Peak". Outliers is the worst example I know of of popular authors bending facts to make a narrative they want to tell.

In a nutshell, Ericsson never said "10k hours will make you world class" or "it takes 10k hours for mastery". He said (BIG simplifying paraphrase here) "the most notable difference we saw in elite performers between sub-elites and elites was practice, with most elites having achieved roughly 10k hours, or 10 years of 3 hours a day". He also limited this to PRACTICE, a part Gladwell totally missed. (ie the Beatles example is complete bullshit, gigs are not practice). He never said it was either necessary (lots of music prodigies are world class in way less) or sufficient (literally millions of people do 10k hours and get just decent).

So... throw that book in the garbage and make your decision on other criteria. There are many, many good books on learning and performance, but not by popular hacks like Gladwell. Anecdotally, I know lots of people who started new pursuits (and got very good), or successfully switched careers or started new businesses in their 40s.

It's really not about age, it's about all the parameters that are typically associated with age. As in, by the time people hit their 40's, most people can no longer carve out the time to consistently spend time learning a new thing, and are way out of practice at learning. Most, not all. I know lots of professional musicians, for example, who took up some other hobby late in life and got very very good, because their entire life has been constructed around leaving time for effective learning, and they are experts at learning something on their own. If you can rearrange life to enable you to learn effectively (or found a company, or whatever), 43 is a great age.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by adamgordonbell on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:41AM (#33122030)
Here's Gladwell himself:

    There is a lot of confusion about the 10,000 rule that I talk about in Outliers. Practice isn't a SUFFICIENT condition for success. I could play chess for 100 years and I'll never be a grandmaster. The point is simply that natural ability requires a huge investment of time in order to be made manifest. Unfortunately, sometimes complex ideas get oversimplified in translation.
I don't get why people love to hate on him so much. He was just popularizing the idea that talent takes effort and is not predominantly innate. ( But I do agree the Beatles example is BS and contrary to the DP principles )
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by MrsPeaches on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:50AM (#33122953)
> He never said it was either necessary (lots of music prodigies are world class in way less)

Gladwell:

"The point is simply that natural ability requires a huge investment of time in order to be made manifest" (emphasis added)

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by iainctduncan on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:26PM (#33124369)
But... this is wrong. The vast majority of the time, yes, but "requires" is a simplification. The amount of work required is massively variable and Gladwell skates right over that nuance. Prodigies exist! I've met some, they can be really nauseating to the rest of us, lol. There are more of them out there than you would think because they are often so screwed up in other ways that they don't become famous. Talk to anyone who has taught hundreds of music students and they can tell you some crazy stories. However, prodigies aren't much use if you can't count on them showing up to the gig. (Some savants are fortunate enough to get the support they need to function professionally, but many aren't)
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by Grustaf on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:56PM (#33123941)
The guy is a walking TED talk. I don't hate him, but he's supremely annoying in his smug triteness.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by iainctduncan on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:28PM (#33124387)
Ah but this is him defending himself after the fact. The book most definitely does create the "sufficient" impression, and deliberately, because it's such a nice story. This is attested to by the takeaways most people have from it. If they got the wrong impression, either he wrote it wrong or he's a shit writer - or both. Now he back pedals because he got called out on the bs.

Don't get me wrong, he's a very good story teller. But he's a complete crap "popular science" writer

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by tinco on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:39AM (#33122004)
There is a much better lesson to take from practice theory, and that's the skill curve. You might see it and think "oh it takes 10,000 hours to become a master". But it only takes 10 hours of practice to become better at something than literally almost everyone at any task. And in 100 hours of practice you would be considered a worthy peer in almost any community. 1000 hours will make you a respected professional in any trade.

You can apply it to any life skill. You could learn a new musical instrument every 6 months, you could be a plumber, a carpenter, an electrician. You could make learn a new way of fabricating things. Any sport, any dance. I applied it as a programmer, dabbling in compilers, operating systems, machine learning systems, web systems, games, various languages and paradigms. Now as the CTO in a small company my "expertise" in all of these fields makes me able to talk along with every team, no matter what they're working on.

You could be good enough in anything to impress a friend by practicing anything for 3 months. Not saying it's easy, real practice hurts your brain, not every day job leaves you with enough brain juice at the end of the day. But maybe you could practice in the morning.

When I was in college I had been playing guitar on and off for maybe 10 years. I didn't like practicing much and was mostly just playing the same bits and riffs for fun. There was a youtube hype around a guy called Andy McKee who played technically challenging pieces with a really cool vibe. I didn't even attempt it, considering it above my skill level. My housemate who hadn't touched a guitar in all his life, bought a $30 guitar and practiced for 3 months. By the end he could play the full song good enough for it to actually sound good and impress basically anyone. I'm pretty sure he could make some money playing on a street corner just playing that 1 song over and over again.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by iainctduncan on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:38PM (#33124533)
this is on the money. How good you need to be to do a job for a career - if that career is not performing in some insanely competitive field like sports or music - is so, so, so much lower than what we are talking about when discussing the practice history of elite performers.

If you learn to practice correctly, and get a good teacher, you will be amazing to most people in 2000 hours - 3 years of consistent two hours a day of good practice produces a shit ton of expertise.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by maxFlow on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:13PM (#33129485)
It brought a smile to my face seeing a completely unexpected reference to Andy McKee on Hacker News :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ddn4MGaS3N4

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by michaelcao on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:33AM (#33121904)
I like your opinion. I founded a startup at 40 as a part time job and it was a correct decision during covid19 crisis. My company is quite successful. It takes about 3000 hours to be sustainable. 10000 hours is an overrated term
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by sam1r on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:05PM (#33123178)
That’s awesome! I’d love to hear more about this.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by michaelcao on Thursday October 13, 2022 @09:38AM (#33190758)
I posted about my journey in the hacker news post "A disabled 40-year-old person founded a startup and makes a living". Thanks for taking time to read my post. Have a great day
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by daveevad on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:35AM (#33121930)
My favorite Gladwell book to rip on is Blink. It is 296 pages long and the main point was one only needs a few moments to understand complicated things.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by michaelcao on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:03AM (#33122316)
I haven't read the Blink yet. I will try to read it in the near future. Thanks for mentioning it.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by prepend on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:26AM (#33122620)
I think you should try to not read it as it’s bogus.

Picking some examples where people made split second decisions that are correct is so silly it’s weird that the book even exists much less is a bestseller. It’s basic premise is that people make split second decisions but never goes into whether these are correct or incorrect.

So it boils down to “sometimes people choose right” as it that was somehow novel or useful.

He’s a fun storyteller but dangerous when people believe and make decisions based on his writings.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by ghaff on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:30AM (#33122673)
I remember Tipping Point as being mostly OK. But it really triggered Gladwell's schtick of weaving a well-written entertaining narrative whether or not it's really supported by some cherry-picked anecdotes.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by swamp40 on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:08AM (#33122374)
I suspect he was joking...
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by daveevad on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:20PM (#33123386)
If you finish it, you should probably read it again. ;)
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by dexterdog on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:07PM (#33124086)
I think he was making the opposite recommendation.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by teachrdan on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:29PM (#33124409)
While I'm a huge Gladwell critic, I enjoyed that book quite a bit. But I disagree with your main point. I'd summarize it's conclusions as:

1. People make decisions very quickly -- like often in under a second.

2. These decisions are very powerful. 2a. Powerful in terms of accurately deducing things, and/or 2b. Powerfully emotional in how it sways you (not always in good ways!)

3. You can have some success in retraining your fast decision making.

This may seem slight, but I think these three main points are not necessarily obvious and are probably true. I've taken advantage of these by, for example, researching different mobile phones a bunch but consciously not making a decision until I walked into the store and I had a powerful interest in one of them on the shelf. That turned out to be the right answer for me.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by daveevad on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:39PM (#33124546)
I enjoyed The Tipping Point and was excited to read Blink but did not enjoy it nearly from the beginning. It was simply too much cognitive dissonance for me to continue when your point 2a kept being explained.

Admittedly I did not finish the book so point 3 does seem valuable to me in a way I probably under-appreciated.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by robswc on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:39PM (#33127735)
I have no opinion on Gladwell, as I haven’t read any of his books, but I swear those 3 things seem to be covered in almost every “self-help” book I’ve read. I don’t want to blame the authors either… but it seems like everyone is getting their water from the same well (thinking fast and slow?).

I’m always down to read an authors interpretation or experience with the concepts… but I’d be lying if I said I haven’t found it harder and harder to push through.

You’re totally on point though. A lot of things are simple and obvious but only when noticed or in hindsight.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by scifibestfi on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:19AM (#33122529)
> (ie the Beatles example is complete bullshit, gigs are not practice)

Why doesn't that count as practice?

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by ghaff on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:28AM (#33122655)
Because you're doing the same thing over and over and don't have a lot of latitude to experiment.

Mind you, there can be some value in repetition starting out especially if you make regular minor adjustments. But for someone already at a high skill level, just doing the same old activity probably won't help their skills much.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by myheadasplode on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:49AM (#33122952)
Playing as a dance/cover band as they did (compared to, say, classical music), they had plenty of space to experiment. The critical aspect that's different from practicing with your band in a rehearsal space vs on stage is that you get to see how an audience actually responds to what you're doing, which is the whole point of the game. Every audience is different. A musician who's played 100 sets of songs alone in a room will have nowhere near the same level of insight as a musician who's played the same number of shows for an audience.

As an instrumentalist, I can choose to play my part ahead of the beat, behind the beat, right on time, I can choose to embellish my part or play it as written, I can improvise a solo vs play something pre-planned, I can subtly vary the intensity of my playing, all while my bandmates are tweaking their performance in real time, too. There's also the telepathy you tend to develop with your bandmates when you're unable to stop a show and yell about mistakes or forgotten parts :)

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by huimang on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:29PM (#33123515)
Performances aren't practice. Practice is sitting down and working on what needs development, and doing self-introspection. Performances are where all of those get put together for an audience.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by thebricksta on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:46PM (#33123776)
I studied a number of books in that field last year, and much of this entire thread is missing some key points.

The learning psychology field often differentiates practice from deliberate practice, where practice is just about anything and deliberate practice is focused learning.

In deliberate practice, you have to work at near your skill level, you need to apply proven learning methods, it should take maximal effort, you need a feedback mechanism to course correct, etc. A great deal of focus goes into creating effective mental models and intentionally removing ineffective mental models. It requires good coaching. As you progress in expertise, your practice should involve more risks and failures. (And there's still much more to be said here)

Gigging and noodling aren't going to make for efficient practice as it likely won't be full concentration, won't involve feedback, won't involve challenging material at your skill level, etc.

Also, you can spend 10,000 hours jamming alone in your bedroom on same set of guitar tabs and make shockingly progress compared to someone who spends just a few hundred hours intensely studying music books with a metronome and tape recorder.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by iainctduncan on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:29PM (#33124414)
yeah, I didn't get into that (for space) but Gladwell basically ignores that side of it, while Ericssons work is ALL ABOUT the quality of practice.

10k hours of bad practice just makes you really good at doing something badly. ;-)

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by kashunstva on Friday October 07, 2022 @08:28PM (#33128650)
I think that one has to define terms first. Anders Ericsson - whom Gladwell relied on so heavily - was focused almost solely on a form of practice he called "deliberate practice"; and he set about defining its characteristics. Playing a gig wouldn't meet many of Ericsson's criteria. Mainly the goal, in the moment, isn't systematic improvement. That said, if we loosen the criteria, there's no reason we _can't_ count playing a gig as practice. After all, some neuromuscular/cognitive development is taking place.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by WheatMillington on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:25PM (#33125112)
Have you actually read Outliers? Gladwell was very specific about practice, and how deliberate it needs to be. He emphasized the way the Beatles used their gig time as practice.
Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by iainctduncan on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:30PM (#33125163)
Yes I have, cover to cover. And it led me on to reading the original sources and then getting disgusted with Gladwell's shoddy job.

Your example says it all.... gig time as practice is something only a non-musician and/or someone who really doesn't understand practice would say. He gives air time to the idea of deliberate practice and then uses examples that show how that he doesn't get it. AT ALL.

Read Ericsson and I'll be you will get disillusioned as did I.

Re:10k hours rule to master anything. Could I switch career ... by Jayakumark on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:14PM (#33127513)
Just curious to know about the books that are you referencing here for learning and performance.