My experience is that cost of ownership of solar models is much lower versus battery models, with less hassle (esp. if atomic syncing is an option). I just had the solar cell in an 18-year-old 5600 replaced. Not because it urgently needed it, but because it was clear the endurance without charging was declining a bit, and I was at the shop, anyway. (And I was pushing it on the seals.)
An OEM spec cell is ~$15-25 with retail markup, but my guy charged me about that for the swap, including new seals and a pressure test. OEM resins are still available for that model, too. I'm still running the original resin, but on other watches when replacing it I always bank a spare for the next swap.
Not that the battery models are bad, and they are definitely more field-serviceable given the comparative difficulty of finding suitable solar cells in more remote parts of the world.
There's really no bad G-Shock, just what works better for one's preferences and requirements.
To that end I picked up a dw-5600 square g-shock a few years ago. I gave it a bit of thought and went with the battery model over the solar model(they are almost the same price) because as far as I can tell the solar model still has a battery in it but the battery is considered non replaceable, I would rather just replace the battery every seven years. I picked up an adapter for a one piece nylon strap(sometimes called a nato or zulu strap, there might be a difference but I can't tell what it is) mainly because I like the nylon straps more than the resin ones.
So far it has been a good serviceable watch, I shall now do it a disservice and enumerate what I don't like about it.