News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:48AM (#33094800)
Europe thought rainbows, friendship, and deeper economic investment would be a more effective deterrent than military might. They doubled down on investing in Russian energy while criticizing the US and NATO for their doctrine of military deterrence.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by croes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:52AM (#33094864)
They thought peace is more stable when both sides are economically intertwined.

And that is also the case. What options would there be against Russia without the possibility of economic sanctions?

War! And not only in Ukraine

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:50AM (#33096279)
There's a difference between trading with Russia and depending so heavily on Russia for the most critical resources. Notably, sanctions work best when ceasing trade harms the sanctioner more than the sanctioned, but the opposite is true with respect to energy--Russia can sell to the rest of the world (apart from those countries who are also sanctioning Russian energy, who can do so due to more energy-independent policies) while Europe can't easily source energy from new suppliers.

> What options would there be against Russia without the possibility of economic sanctions?

Continue to supply arms to Ukraine without an energy crisis?

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by kyriakos on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:31PM (#33098584)
Russia can't sell as easily as it sells to Europe for the same reasons Europe can't buy from other sources easily. Pipeline availability and capacity.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:42PM (#33098754)
Russia seems to be selling just fine because it has infrastructure and capacity to send to other regions (though no doubt it's diminished). Europe has relatively few LNG pipelines from other regions (and LNG tankers and other infrastructure is similarly in short supply).
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by qsort on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:56AM (#33094927)
> What options would there be against Russia without the possibility of economic sanctions?

Not fueling their imperial fanfiction to begin with. The original mistake was offering them aid after the fall of the USSR without requiring steps towards liberal democracy in exchange.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by hef19898 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:15AM (#33095155)
Ah, of course. Because execting a Morgenthau plan on one of the two major nuclear powers, one that is currently desintegrating, ever was a good idea...
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by croes on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:36PM (#33098657)
They took steps towards a liberal democracy. Remember Yeltsin?

That led to the rise of oil and gas oligarchs meanwhile the ordinary people suffered. That's why they voted for a "strong" leader: Putin.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by wongarsu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @08:58AM (#33094950)
The EU member states used to be in near constant war for centuries, starting two world wars in the process. Economic entanglement was one of the major factors that finally lead to a lasting peace. Applying the same concept to Russia was reasonable.

With another Russian leader it might have worked. But Putin, for whatever reason, chose potential glory over economic prosperity. A move so foreign to European democracies that we refused to see it coming.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by hef19898 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:19AM (#33095201)
Agree with everything except the last sentence: that the Russian invasion failed so hard is partially due to the support Ukraine got since 2014 and still gets. For me, it was more like preparing for the worst while hoping for the best. Because who wouod have thought anyone would be stupid enough to lanch a major land war, in Europe, against a well prepared country that can easily be supplied by its allies, an invasion that was signaled light years in advance? So yeah, it was a surprise that it actually happened, and it hit a rather well prepared Ukraine.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:05AM (#33096498)
This is the whole point--you can't bank on 'economic entanglement' with a dictatorship because the dictator may or may not care about the economy (beyond its ability to finance his war, anyway). Moreover, Europe continued to increase its economic exposure to Russia while Russia was publicly decreasing its exposure to the west (this has been Russian policy since the west sanctioned Russia for invading and annexing Crimea almost a decade ago). Even if you believe in "economic entanglement" (and I doubt it was as potent as NATO, etc), surely it only works if the dependency is mutual.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:16AM (#33095157)
>Economic entanglement was one of the major factors that finally lead to a lasting peace.

There couldn't possibly be anything more false. This horse has been beaten to death already and should just be let to die.

European countries had entangled economies and were still going to war with each other. France and Germany were each other's biggest trading partners and that didn't stop them fighting each other in WW1 or WW2.

The reason why we have had peace after WW2 is the implementation of fully fledged democracies with separation of powers in the major European leaderships along with US peacekeeping and the Marshal plan.

Russia was not a democracy anymore after the 1993 coup since the president there could do whatever he wants without the parliament able to stop him and therefore should not have been trusted as a fair trading partner.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:12AM (#33096585)
I'm not sure why this was downvoted, this is largely the right answer. The US has had troops all over the continent and the USSR was an external, existential threat against which they were united. People weren't worried about their stock portfolio, they were worried about the Soviet Union nuking their cities.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by linuxftw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:27AM (#33095283)
> Putin, for whatever reason, chose potential glory over economic prosperity.

He stated his reasons. He believes there was a western-backed military coup in 2014. Ukraine failed to implement the Minsk agreements. Ukraine is attempting to join NATO. He believed an assault on the breakaway republics was imminent. He believes Ukraine is harboring literal Nazis, committing crimes against humanity against ethnic Russians.

Those are more or less the stated reasons.

IMO, Ukraine was a vassal state, much like Puerto Rico to the US. Maybe the relationship wasn't so formalized, but Russia viewed Ukraine as theirs one way or another. For some reason, people in the western world operate on some kind of technicality system, as if words on paper make a difference.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:12AM (#33096575)
> For some reason, people in the western world operate on some kind of technicality system, as if words on paper make a difference.

Yes, we call this "rule of law" and it works really well in the west.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by linuxftw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:24AM (#33096773)
Does it though? [1]

We have pretend rule of law. We pretend the law matters, and we pretend to follow it.

In any case, Putin argues that the war (or in his parlance, SMO) is legal under UN precedent in Yugoslavia, that a breakaway republic may be recognized even if the former nation dissents.

IMO, this whole ordeal could have been avoided, but Western backed Ukraine decided it was better to fight than capitulate to Russia's demands.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_the_Iraq_War

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by piva00 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:09PM (#33097369)
You are probably well aware but this is exactly the lines being sold by the Kremlin.

Ukraine, as we can see in reality, isn't Russia. Don't identify as Russia and has not been wanting to be part of Moscow-ruled territory for a few decades.

How exactly could this whole ordeal been avoided? Letting Putin continue the dismantling of Ukraine through civil wars and separatist movements?

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by linuxftw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:13PM (#33098328)
> How exactly could this whole ordeal been avoided?

Not have a western backed military coup in 2014, for starters?

As I said, Ukraine was essentially a vassal state of Russia. The coup in 2014 meant to overthrow vassal status. This kicked off a civil war.

There's a series of events that lead to the current war which could have been handled differently. But Nationalism won out, people decided that giving autonomy to some regions was unacceptable and worth fighting for.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:36PM (#33098680)
The Maidan Uprising was neither western-backed nor a military coup. It wasn't even a coup. The _legislature_ may have violated the constitutional process for removing a president, but the courts never ruled as such. It's also not a "civil war" when Russia invades Ukraine, even if there are separatists involved.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by linuxftw on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @06:02PM (#33101763)
> The Maidan Uprising was neither western-backed nor a military coup.

Many people think this, but it's factually incorrect.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:17PM (#33103549)
Many people think this because it is factually correct. The evidence to the contrary is a clip of a private conversation that Russian intelligence acquired in which one US diplomat opined to another that the uprising might not be a bad thing (or something to that effect).
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by linuxftw on Thursday October 06, 2022 @09:20AM (#33107847)
When John McCain flies out and meets the head of the opposition, who thereafter storm the capital with assault rifles, and the president of the country flees, it sure looks like a western backed coup to me.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @10:59AM (#33109062)
A politician visiting a country (even expressing support for a rival politician) doesn't imply backing a coup, and indeed there was no coup--the capital was never occupied (in a military sense) by armed protesters as you claim, the president fled to escape justice (and indeed the supreme court convicted him of treason). Notably, the Yanukovych wasn't pushed out by any military or paramilitary, he was voted out by the (democratically elected) legislature and convicted by the court. That said, I'm sure the protesters were armed, as they were being fired upon by Yanukovych's forces (including snipers trained in Russia) and many protesters were killed. Moreover, McCain was advocating for a peaceful transition of power to stop the violence.

While we're talking about suspicious foreign involvement, let's talk about the $15bn that Putin offered Yanukovych (and which Yanukovych accepted) hours before police were ordered to crack down on protests. Or the documents which showed that Russian officials served as advisers in the crackdown on protesters (operations Wave and Boomerang) including the use of snipers and the planned use of 22,000 security troops in Kyiv alone.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by linuxftw on Thursday October 06, 2022 @02:02PM (#33111683)
> the capital was never occupied (in a military sense) by armed protesters as you claim

I'm sorry, but this is a basic fact of the events, and you are tragically misinformed. Many people are misinformed, many media outlets played up the 'peaceful protests' angle, but there is no doubt, there was an armed insurrection.

I think this article offers a glimpse of what was being reported at the time [1]. Scores of police captured, 3 killed, 28 shot. This was prior to the presidential palace being captured, that happened once the police flipped sides.

1: https://www.politico.com/story/2014/02/kiev-ukraine-proteste...

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:41PM (#33097825)
> We have pretend rule of law. We pretend the law matters, and we pretend to follow it.

There's no pretense. We mostly do follow the law, and the law very much matters. The Iraq War is the exception that proves the rule.

> IMO, this whole ordeal could have been avoided, but Western backed Ukraine decided it was better to fight than capitulate to Russia's demands.

"WWII could have been avoided, but Allied Europe decided it was better to fight than capitulate to Nazi demands." Obviously nations are going to fight for their sovereignty.

> In any case, Putin argues that the war (or in his parlance, SMO) is legal under UN precedent in Yugoslavia, that a breakaway republic may be recognized even if the former nation dissents.

Anyone can argue that anything is legal, that doesn't make them right. Notably, the UN collectively disagrees with him.

Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by benwad on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:04AM (#33095020)
US/NATO have military all over Europe, and that hasn't prevented this either. The reason the threat doesn't work is because Ukraine isn't a NATO member.
Re:Europe’s Energy Crisis Forces Factories to Go Dark by throwaway894345 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:52AM (#33096318)
The US has been pulling troops out of Europe for the last 20 years, and during that time, NATO's policy has been letting Putin walk all over its neighbors. If NATO stood up 8 years ago like they're doing today, then there would never have been a second invasion of Ukraine to begin with.