News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by piotrkaminski on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:08PM (#33089057)
> Meanwhile, a spokeswoman for another trade organisation, the Advertising Association, says that "all advertising plays a crucial role in brand competition, drives product innovation, and fuels economic growth".

You know what actually drives product innovation? Not being able to lean on advertising to drive sales, so you're actually forced to improve your product and get the benefit of positive word of mouth instead.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by andrewmcwatters on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:24PM (#33089232)
Sounds like the position of a developer who has never had to advertise. Building things doesn't automatically make people gravitate toward them. Believe it or not, you have to go places and promote things.

Yes, talking about or inserting something into conversation is promoting. It's advertising. And guess what--almost none of your users or buyers are going to say a word about your product.

People need to stop believing this stuff and just accept the dirty fact that if you want something to get used, you HAVE to advertise. You HAVE to promote.

Edit: You know what word of mouth is? Worthless for people who don't have eyeballs on a product.

Go read around HN and tell me about a product you just heard about being praised that you don't already know about today that is not already the de facto solution or product in a space.

You know what word of mouth is? Word of mouth is a signal you have already won. It is absolutely nothing for growth.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by piotrkaminski on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:38PM (#33089368)
Spoken like a marketer / salesperson. I am indeed a developer and run a successful, bootstrapped software business. I agree that you need to initially get the word out that your product exists at all. However, this can be so targeted and the scope so small that I doubt most people would put it in the same category as the advertising practices that many find objectionable.

Once you've got some interest bootstrapped, you CAN in fact rely on unprompted word of mouth for growth. My users and buyers spread the word about my product simply because they find it useful. Many bring it to their new employer when they switch jobs.

So no, I disagree with the blanket position that you have to advertise -- especially in the intrusive fashion that's the subject of the article -- to get people to use your product. (Though I don't dispute that doing so can be a good shortcut.)

But all that is irrelevant to my claim above: my position is simply that a dearth of advertising options is what drives product innovation, by necessity. And hence, limiting advertising is likely to actually be good for consumers.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:00PM (#33089588)
Many products require massive investment to get to the point of being able to sell a product. Waiting around for word of mouth means your debt will overwhelm the business.

Bootstrapping only works if you haven't taken on much debt to finance the development and manufacturing of the product. Software can be developed with very little debt (which is what I did).

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by joe-collins on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:13PM (#33089733)
I wonder if there are generalities about the products that "require" advertising and those that don't. Perhaps we would find that, on the balance, those products are not worth their externalized costs.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by didgetmaster on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:21PM (#33089818)
My project (a new kind of data management system designed to replace file systems and relational databases) is a bootstrapped project. I self funded it, but that means it has taken several years to get it to its current state. There are many features still on the TODO list, but it can do some amazing things so far. The 'if you build it, they will come' is a great movie line, but rarely works in business.

It is difficult to raise awareness for it. Newsletters, blogs, demo videos, presenting at conferences, etc. are all means for trying to spread the word. I have considered taking out some paid advertisements, but you wonder if anyone but bots will actually see them.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:12PM (#33089720)
So, then... why not leave those product categories to bigcorps who can reinvest their existing treasury by chasing such risks?

We don't expect a small company to be able to make a Hollywood movie, or a new medicine... and that's just fine, isn't it?

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by smoldesu on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:49PM (#33089481)
> You know what word of mouth is? Worthless for people who don't have eyeballs on a product.

As a customer, I'm tired of hearing this excuse. I get wowed by free, open-source software dozens of times a week. You want me to put eyes on your product? Wow me! I'm tired of "enterprise-grade fart apps" and "B2C photo storage" garbage getting touted as life-changing or impressive technology. If you want to compete, do something impressive. If you want people to look fondly upon your product, consider giving back to the community instead of paying to become their adversary.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by scarface74 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:01PM (#33089596)
And guess who funds most development for the free open source software you use?
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:13PM (#33089740)
Given that most of the software I use consists very clearly of one-man passion projects where the author struggles to support themselves: nobody. (Remember OpenSSL?)
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by scarface74 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:55PM (#33090548)
Most software you use including your web browser? Your operating system?
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:15AM (#33091168)
Yes, most software. A piece of software being bigger or doing more things, does not make said piece of software count more. A program is a program; it's something you learn how to use separately, download/update separately; something which is separate from a project-maintainership and bug-filing point-of-view; etc.

I use four big fat codebases (browser, OS, etc); maybe 10 decently-sized language runtimes like the JVM; and then 800+ rinky-dink CLI utilities. Half of which came from a Github Gist, or which I had to compile from source from a repo containing just some bare source files and no documentation. Yet many of these little CLI utilities individually take up just as much mental space as my browser or OS does; and I get just as much use out of them professionally as I do my browser or OS. (In fact often more, because many of these utilities are multi-platform, such that I use them regardless of which browser or OS I happen to be using.)

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by jarbus on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:53PM (#33090069)
From what I've seen, github sponsors, patreon, donations, or nobody.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by verisimilitudes on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:24PM (#33089848)
Individuals do, clearly. I don't use Google-funded malware. I suppose the Linux kernel may qualify, but plenty of people in real industries also work on that.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by magicalhippo on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:30PM (#33089897)
> You know what word of mouth is? [...] It is absolutely nothing for growth.

When I joined the company some years ago, we were the 5th largest in our sector. We since grew to 2nd largest using almost entirely word of mouth for sales. We didn't have any dedicated sales people, and did hardly any advertising.

Instead, users would call friends in the industry and tell them to get our software. If they switched jobs they'd persuade their new boss to get our software.

Since reaching #2 spot we got some sales and marketing people, and we're now at the top.

So while I'll disagree that word of mouth can't be used for growth, I've seen first hand how good sales and marketing can put you on a steeper curve.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by smoe on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:38PM (#33089949)
> Go read around HN and tell me about a product you just heard about being praised that you don't already know about today that is not already the de facto solution or product in a space.

Easy. This morning in the "Ask HN: So you moved off Heroku, where did you go?" thread I saw multiple users mentioning a open source project I have never heard of but seemed very close to what i was looking for. I have it now running since 12 hours and I already recommended a friend to check it out.

I reckon about 70% of things I use are from recommendations of people (but usually not from the internet). From what command-line shell I use to what music I listen to.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by robotresearcher on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:16PM (#33090251)
> You know what word of mouth is? [...] It is absolutely nothing for growth.

I don't recall seeing TikTok billboards or banner ads.

I've never seen a Tesla ad.

Did Facebook advertise? Instagram?

GMail throttled demand with limited invitations.

Until this week you had to apply to get a Dall-E login. Heard of it?

Rolls-Royce and Tupperware do not advertise.

I'm not saying advertising isn't important for products. But it's easy to find enormously-grown counterexamples to your blanket claim.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by gamblor956 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:28PM (#33090805)
TikTok advertised on Facebook.

Tesla used to run billboards in LA and SF and paid influencers to shill their cars. They still market quite heavily today though not through billboards (AI Day is a marketing event.)

GMails invitation system was it's marketing, back in the day when people were excited about Google products.

Rolls Royce sponsors athletes, which is considered marketing. They also bring cars to auto shows and to various events targeted to the luxury crowd.

Tupperware's original business model was literally 100% about marketing. Most people would call it a multi level marketing scheme today.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by GekkePrutser on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:17PM (#33089785)
Well there is now a massive group of people that never sees online advertising anymore. Due to adblockers and piholes. Thanks Raymond Hill <3

For me the only advertising I see is on billboards because I never watch live TV either (and haven't for years). And many products are way too niche to advertise that way.

This group will get ever larger because it's just a great thing to live in an advertising-free world. If your business can't cope with it I would suggest making that a priority to adjust to :)

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by mtlynch on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:52PM (#33089507)
Food for thought: The user you're responding to is the founder of Reviewable. I use his product and found it through word of mouth. It is not the de facto solution in the space.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by scarface74 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:03PM (#33089618)
Now compare the revenues and profits of his company to the largest advertisers in the US…

https://www.statista.com/statistics/286448/largest-global-ad...

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by yellowapple on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:22PM (#33089825)
It's almost as if there's more to life than maximizing revenues and profits.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by andrewmcwatters on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:23PM (#33089844)
I’ve never heard of it.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by mtlynch on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:40PM (#33089965)
I'm not seeing how it's relevant whether or not the word of mouth of this particular product has reached you.

You were telling someone that he's out of touch for thinking that he can sell a product on word of mouth alone. I'm providing evidence that he can sell a product through word of mouth because I bought his product based on word of mouth.

Whether or not you've also heard of his product is irrelevant. There's a near infinite number of successful products in the world that you've never heard of, so you being unaware of a particular product does not indicate anything about whether that product is successful.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by colordrops on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:14PM (#33089750)
You are begging the question, in the logical fallacy sense. You have to advertise and promote because advertising has been allowed to grow unbounded like a cancer and drown out everything else. It's a tragedy of the commons.

If advertising were toned down a couple orders of magnitude, word of mouth might actually get more traction.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by thot_experiment on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:29PM (#33089290)
While that's obviously true, I'm not sure it's some sort of optimum state. I think if you're in the ocean, it is understandable that you would keep treading water to stop yourself from drowning, but perhaps a better solution is to look for ways to leave the ocean. I'm entirely unconvinced that this isn't a local maximum that we're stuck in.

Even if I leave room that advertising (and capitalism) is the only stable system, that doesn't mean it can't be limited and restricted for better outcomes for people on the whole.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by jrm4 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:23PM (#33089845)
This is complete and utter BS. 100%.

I get if you're trying to starve for a buck out here in a crowded space like tech, but on the consumer side of things I have never put deep use in any product that was marketed (i.e. someone paid for it to get to my eyeballs.)

It may be true that for a bunch of you to make money, you need to put money in marketing. But for us who want good products, marketing mostly only gets in our way. Good products really do sell themselves with word of mouth, or me actively seeking out good things.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by soulofmischief on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:19PM (#33090269)
Look at Rockstar's Red Dead 2. Cost about $540 million to produce. Split almost down the middle for advertising and development costs. For every dollar spent on dev, a dollar was spent on advertising.

It's now one of the most successful games ever made. The advertising did nothing to hurt innovation, and in fact proved Rockstar's hypothesis that the market is ready for this kind of innovation, but needs to be sold on the idea.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by netaustin on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:22PM (#33089829)
The boundary between useful advertising and word of mouth is exceedingly thin and contextual. When Uber turned off $100m of advertising and found no meaningful change to its installation growth, had it already won? Clearly not then and not now; it's barely posted an operating profit and it still a couple billion away from positive net income. Rather, it's in a duopoly in the US and an oligopoly in some other markets and facing a pretty gnarly advertise (defect) or not (cooperate) prisoner's dilemma. Word-of-mouth can be a form of promotion. Most products have obvious entry pathways which smart and experienced marketers will readily identify; few of these are display ads, fewer still are billboards.

The space of advertising decisions is high-dimensional and dependent on too many factors to succumb to generalization. Many awesome businesses have thrived without it; others would've starved without it.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by charcircuit on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:14PM (#33090229)
>Uber turned off $100m of advertising and found no meaningful change to its installation growth

This is misleading. Ad networks were defrauding Uber by generating fake clicks so such that organic installs of Uber would be attributed to these ad networks despite the install not being from an ad.

The problem was the ad networks and not advertising itself.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by makeitdouble on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:21PM (#33089822)
> is promoting. It's advertising

Those two notions aren’t the same, nor interchangeable. Advertising is about pushing something to a public and expanding the attention the product receives. “ There's no such thing as bad publicity” is advertising.

Promoting is about making a product’s (alleged)merits better known and enticing people to use said product for their benefit.

As a society, we want promotion, not advertisement.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by paxys on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:27PM (#33089264)
Not all advertising is the same. Yes every product needs to promote itself, but there are countless organic ways to do so, most of them being industry dependent. How many of the most popular tech products today got to where they are because they put up billboards in the middle of cities?
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by missedthecue on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:43PM (#33089415)
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by ryandrake on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:57PM (#33090106)
Would you be in favor of, in principle, obtaining consent from the people you market to? If what you say is true (people want to learn about new products) then surely most people would consent to these promotional messages.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by verisimilitudes on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:23PM (#33089838)
I'm not a parasite, so telling people about something I did by myself is fine, and I'm not asking for money anyway.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by vkou on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:54PM (#33089522)
> Building things doesn't automatically make people gravitate toward them.

No, but the two barber-shops in towns spending $X each on net-even advertising is a net-negative for me, because the only thing I get out of it is a higher bill when I cut my hair.

Some advertisement creates new markets. Some is a negative-sum game. None of it can be assumed to be honest, because of the obvious profit motive involved.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:05PM (#33089649)
> None of it can be assumed to be honest

Who do you assume to be honest? The politician wanting your vote? The prospective employee telling you about his job skills? The public schools telling you they do a great job? Dr. Fauci? The customer who tells you "the check is in the mail"?

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by vkou on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @10:45PM (#33090469)
Honesty is a spectrum, and someone being paid to shill should, all else being equal, be met with more skepticism than someone who isn't.

You can get all philosophical and start splitting hairs about what we can truly know, but whatever it is, I doubt I'll find it in an ad.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:13PM (#33090683)
There's a lot more than just getting paid that motivates people to shade the truth.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by wlesieutre on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:20PM (#33089198)
Word of mouth is increasingly the only source I trust for product recommendations. Once advertisers figure this out I imagine they'll start sponsoring my acquaintances to lie to me about their products in person and I'll have to narrow the field even further.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by registeredcorn on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:39PM (#33089383)
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by deadbolt on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:56PM (#33089547)
If my friend referred a dentist to me just for $50 without mentioning that they were only doing it for the incentive, we wouldn't be friends much longer.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by registeredcorn on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @11:48PM (#33090962)
That's one of the things that's confused me about those sorts of programs. Is the friend supposed to mention that they are getting paid for their recommendation? It's such a weird thing.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by wlesieutre on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:51AM (#33096295)
I'd feel better about it in that case, yeah. Personally have referred somebody to Mint Mobile and they were aware I got a discount out of it.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by feet on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:37PM (#33089357)
I think this is why influencers on social media are a thing
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by grantsch on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:12PM (#33089721)
If your product is so damn good

Why don't you want to tell more people about it - wouldn't that help them? (and you?)

Seriously asking - like I get it if you only want to make $x and call it a day but can you help me understand why you wouldn't want to help more people with your superior offer?

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by piotrkaminski on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:39PM (#33089962)
That's an easy one: your product is good only for some people, who happen to have the problem you're solving. You could tell everyone about it, but you'd reach a lot of people for whom wasting time hearing about your product is a net negative, and it's entirely possible that the overall value to other people's lives of advertising in that way would be negative as well. Of course you could try more targeted advertising to mitigate the negative externalities, but that carries its own costs in terms of invasion of privacy, etc.

So yes, it's certainly possible that advertising raises the overall well-being of the recipients, but it's by no means a given.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by grantsch on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:33AM (#33091280)
Who are you to decide that though?

If you don't try to reach them - your inferior competitors will. Then you and your potential users are both worse off

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by piotrkaminski on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:43AM (#33091346)
Yes, the tragedy of the commons. The only way to win is not to play. It may not be rational, but I refuse to do something bad just because the alternative is somebody else doing something worse.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by grantsch on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:46AM (#33091363)
It's ok. To each his own

I opt to keep growing

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:16PM (#33089767)
There could be per-unit CapEx costs that mean that you actually can't scale up to serve traffic very much faster than organic viral growth allows.

Imagine a small cake shop running a Superbowl ad. That'd be dumb, right? Even if they had the money to run the ad, they can't fulfill the number of orders that ad would generate.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by grantsch on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:35AM (#33091286)
What you're saying is just not true. It's also not what capex means.

Most companies do not and cannot "go viral"

that is a fantasy for most offers. Unfortunately it's just not that easy

There's a reason that millions of Americans work in some form of sales. At big, medium, and small companies of all types. It's not an accident or a mistake actually. Any offer worth enough profit to be worth a human pitching it will get pitched - and so too will many offers that aren't worth pitching for that matter

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:50AM (#33091397)
> It's also not what capex means.

Per-unit-amortized CapEx costs, sorry. (Typo.) Think: labor acquisition costs when you're providing a high-touch service. You can only hire so fast. Or acquisition/expansion costs for facilities and capital equipment (factory mechanization), in the case of the small bakery. You can only make so many cakes per hour, by hand, in a room of a given size.

And it's 100% true. Look at any consultant. Look at any maker of artisanal goods. If you have "inelastic supply", then there is a certain amount of demand that is saturating, at which point you don't need any more demand — you only need better demand. Every customer you acquire from that point on replaces a lower-value customer on your fixed timetable. Untargeted outreach (advertising) does nothing to make that happen. You need targeted outreach (sales) at that point. Or just some very aggressive lead-qualification of your organic inbound traffic.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by grantsch on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @12:56AM (#33091426)
I see what you're saying but the analogy isn't very good

The reason a local bake shop doesn't do superbowl spots is because they're wasting their spend on millions of people who their offer is irrelevant to. I don't think it's because they can't scale up to fulfill

there could be local bakeshops that advertise on local tv or a billboard for example. But bakeshops don't usually make enough profit to justify these efforts

to further emphasize this point - there's no rule a company has to fulfill an order on their own. if you can't figure out how to fulfill - many companies will sub that work out/outsource it. the highest touch services - think biglaw partners - those type businesses don't really scale and are more jobs than actual businesses

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:12AM (#33091538)
My hypothetical was that the bakeshop was given an opportunity to run a superbowl ad that it didn't have to pay for. There's still no point in running the ad (vs. paying to run an ad on local TV), because, despite theoretically being able to eventually scale up to becoming a global cake-factory megacorp (think https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continental_Baking_Company), there are discontinuous CapEx costs in the way of doing that scaling; and nobody's going to trust this tiny bake-shop enough to loan them the money necessary to do that scaling-up, in advance of fulfilling orders, in order to build up to meet said demand; when they haven't even proven that they know how to scale.

> if you can't figure out how to fulfill - many companies will sub that work out/outsource it

Yeah, but if they're coming to you, specifically, it's probably not just because you've ran a superbowl ad, but also because you're offering something nobody else does offer, or is set up to offer, or even knows how to offer.

If you ran a superbowl ad for your little sandwich shop, that wouldn't make a million people interested in flying out to you to get sandwiches; your sandwiches are probably good, but so are many people's — there's no USP to what you're doing. Sandwiches are fungible-enough that the ad will just make people want a sandwich from their own local place.

But, well — you know the "pink sauce" lady? She's got a USP. You can't get pink sauce anywhere but her (for now.) And she's certainly trying to outsource her production to a big condiment corp, due to the massive accidental viral demand she's triggered for her product; but there wasn't anyone already set up to make pink sauce, so she couldn't actually just turn around and immediately buy it on the market, or subcontract its production (AFAIK there's no "condiments mixed to order" job-shop factory; only "we put your label on our pre-made condiments" factories.) Right now, she's just trying to meet millions of orders from all over the US, from her kitchen, and everything's going to hell as a result.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by wpietri on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:27PM (#33089270)
Exactly. Advertising is an arms race. Coca Cola doesn't spend billions on ads because nobody had heard of Coke. They do it to suppress the more innovative competition.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by radicaldreamer on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:49PM (#33089484)
It's to remind people to buy a coke, it feeds the craving. Same thing for McDonalds and Starbucks advertising.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by wpietri on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:17PM (#33089777)
Right, yes, I believe we're saying the same thing. If Coca Cola doesn't remind people to buy their product, they might buy some other product.
Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by andrewinardeer on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:28AM (#33091990)
And to make people feel good about their purchase.

BMW doesn't really need to advertise as their new cars are only affordable for a small subset of the population. They advertise to re-enforce to their customers they made a great decision parting with their money.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by WalterBright on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:07PM (#33089674)
Coca Cola did innovate - "New Coke". It was a disaster. People like the old Coke formula much better.

Some things really don't need innovation.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by derefr on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @09:21PM (#33089820)
And interesting point I learned from a documentary recently, that I rarely see mentioned: New Coke failed mainly in the American South, among people who considered Coke to be a wholesome and traditional part of their lifestyle — kind of like sweet tea. But it failed so hard there, with people there getting so angry, that the media capitalized on that failure, running constant articles about it, giving an impression that New Coke was just failing in general.

New Coke was actually decently successful in the rest of the world; and especially in younger, more urban markets — i.e. the markets Pepsi is more popular in. New Coke did exactly what it was designed to do: steal market share from Pepsi.

Coke's mistake was never really in launching New Coke. Their mistake was in removing the "old" Coke at the same time. If New Coke was positioned differently — not as a replacement for Coke, but just as a "kind" of Coke (like Coke Zero is a "kind of" Coke), they would have cleaned up.

Re:Should billboard advertising be banned? by trystero on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:42PM (#33089408)
...which is an argument against advertisement.