News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul McCartney's Freakish Memory by jiggawatts on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @02:41AM (#33077256)
There's levels to this. I once worked in a room full of graphic artists, but one of them had a skill level that was far above everyone else. His "demo" was to draw a detailed dwarf character in full battle armour and wielding a stone hammer... with one continuous line. Without picking up his pen, he could draw this character in minutes with better detail than the other artists could in hours or days.

Similarly, Mozart copied down Allegri's Miserere after hearing it just once in 1770. That's a sufficiently amazing achievement that it's still talked about, a quarter of a millennium later!

Re:Paul McCartney's Freakish Memory by Maursault on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:49AM (#33079066)
Some are blessed with talent, some more than others, but when inherent talent is encouraged and stimulated and disciplined and focused from a young age, and the historical tools of music and music literacy are mastered, when there is total support, removal of distractions and the leisure and time to accomplish all this, the result is seen as nothing less than miraculous. Not everyone could have been Mozart, but certainly there are some that could have been had they been given the same support, encouragement and education from a young age. But I don't think many would have wanted Mozart's father as a parent. I have never heard it argued, but it is possible Mozart's father's treatment of his son could be seen as narcissistic abuse, and that Mozart had obsessive and compulsive symptoms. While Mozart had incredible talent and discipline in music, he lacked discipline and restraint in other areas of his life, and it ultimately killed him at a relatively young age.
Re:Paul McCartney's Freakish Memory by egypturnash on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:39AM (#33077824)
No preliminary rough, just pen to paper? Pretty impressive if so. Especially if he wasn’t sort of bashing in the overall shape first and going back in to add details.

And now that I think about it, trying to do this on a regular basis sounds like a pretty good way to boost one’s ability to hold a whole drawing in one’s head and “trace” it onto the paper, rather than doing a rough. I would not be surprised if this ability started as a game he played with himself when he was sitting in the back of his least favorite high school classes, doodling away.

(I am an artist; I can’t do this particular trick but I have definitely had moments when I was totally into a drawing and it felt like I was tracing it onto the paper from my mental image of it, with the hand of a dead artist I’d been studying guiding mine. I was also pretty high at the time; there’s some strains of weed that artists favor because it can give us a boost to this sort of ability.)

Re:Paul McCartney's Freakish Memory by jiggawatts on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:08AM (#33078733)
I'm pretty sure I have aphantisia, but for a few rare moments I could visualise a complete image against a blank surface and even start tracing it. I could never hold on to this for more than a few seconds.

My suspicion is that this artist had the opposite -- the ability to maintain a detailed image in his mind's eye as he traced it.

Re:Paul McCartney's Freakish Memory by badpun on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @08:46AM (#33079504)
> My suspicion is that this artist had the opposite -- the ability to maintain a detailed image in his mind's eye as he traced it.

Check out Kim Jung Gi. He's basically doing that in real time, with impossible speed, accuracy and level of detail. He's making a living via performing live shows of his skills.

Re:Paul McCartney's Freakish Memory by jiggawatts on Thursday October 06, 2022 @08:17AM (#33107272)
> He's making a living

Not any longer, sadly..