News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by hackerlight on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:52AM (#33064984)
Decentralized decision making is usually better because of the local knowledge problem. But not always. It's the wisdom of crowds vs madness of crowds dichotomy. That's why it's good to have constraints on democracy in the form of Constitution-type documents, and why representative democracy can sometimes be better than direct democracy. There's also the inescapable incentive conflict of 2 wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner. It's not really a just or perfect system, it's just the best one we have, to recycle that old cliche.
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by c7b on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:51AM (#33065352)
> There's also the inescapable incentive conflict of 2 wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner.

That problem isn't entirely inescapable, though. There's a whole mathematical discipline on voting systems (social choice theory) - unfortunately the important results are mostly negative (google eg Arrow's impossibility theorem, Condorcet paradox,...), but the specific problem of the "dictatorship of the majority" has a solution in principle, namely quadratic voting. But yeah, we won't really ever get a perfect voting system.

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by hackerlight on Monday October 03, 2022 @10:31AM (#33068038)
It's something I haven't studied before. Why does quadratic voting solve the dictatorship of the majority problem? Do you mean to say that it attenuates the worst effects even if it doesn't solve it completely?
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by c7b on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:49PM (#33074181)
oh wow, I really got drawn into a discussion here. now I'm not an expert on QV, but my recollection is this: cardinal voting allows people to express the strength of their preferences rather than just the order. so if there's an issue that a minority cares about a lot while the majority is just indifferent, then the minority can concentrate their votes on that issue and move it higher up the ballot (more so than in an ordinal voting system).

so in your example, if the wolves have a 2/3 preference for sheep for dinner and 1/3 for apples, and the sheep has a 100% preference for apples, then with linear voting the group decision would be 5/3 vs 4/3 in favour of apples. with quadratic voting, the vote weights would be sqrt(1)+2sqrt(1/3) for apples and 2sqrt(2/3) for sheep, and apples would still win. so in this example, the sheep can push the group decision because its preference is stronger than the wolves', something it couldn't express by just ranking the options (if the wolves had a 100% for sheep, that would still win)

so as we just saw, there are different ways to implement cardinal preferences, and QV is one of them that has been shown to be optimal under some standard (but still debatable) utility assumptions.

that being said, if we were going to seriously consider implementing QV, I'd still have a lot of questions - I mentioned collusion, but also about manipulation resistance: what if the wolves anticipate this outcome and strategically misrepresent the relative strength of their preferences to make sure that their absolutely preferred option wins? they could still do that even without collusion. it's another common problem in voting mechanisms, I don't know how strong that problem is in QV (maybe the manipulation would be exponentially hard to compute, or very easy, Idk rn)

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 03, 2022 @07:15AM (#33065919)
>efficiently selects the outcome for which the population has the highest willingness to pay

Majority rule does the same, no?

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by c7b on Monday October 03, 2022 @08:22AM (#33066476)
only if there are only two options, for more options any rank-ordering system will be plagued by Arrow's and other impossibility theorems. quadratic voting uses cardinal preferences, which avoids some of those issues, and QV specifically has linear marginal cost of votes, which can be shown to be optimal in a very simplified mathematical model of voter preferences.

but I don't want to evangelize QV too much here, it has enough proponents already and I'm not fully convinced that's is resilient to problems like collusion

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:17PM (#33069588)
You don't need collusion when quadratic voting works only in hypothetical cases.
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by darkwater on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:02AM (#33065430)
> There's also the inescapable incentive conflict of 2 wolves and a sheep voting on what to have for dinner.

I don't think that situation is THAT common, given that usually the majority of people has the same problems, usually economic. Biggest exception would be immigration, since immigrants are generally in lower numbers, especially the ones that can actually vote.

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by hackerlight on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:28AM (#33065617)
The problem is that voters outside of that issue will be mostly apathetic due to information asymmetries + finite bandwidth to care about issues + active disinformation and propaganda by lobby groups.

So much the case that you don't even need a majority to get negative sum policies passed. The same dynamic happens with sufficiently determined minorities. Here's a few examples. Agricultural subsidies, carried interest loophole, local planning laws, lack of action on global warming.

The cases of majority rule leading to negative sum policies are probably more rare than the impact of determined minorities. Although I can think of Black voter disenfranchisement and immigration laws off the top of my head.

It's partly a money in politics issue, but it's also deeper than that. Farmers will actively vote out anyone who wants to take away their subsidies. Non-farmers don't care enough one way or the other, because the cost is dilute. You don't need direct money in politics for that mechanism to play out.

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by ZeroGravitas on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:30AM (#33065207)
Though a more common failure state is 2 wolves telling 98 sheep that "democracy sucks, don't listen to these experts/socialists/Jews, we need a strong wolf in charge" and getting 1/3 of the sheep to vote for them, in a near literal "When I voted for the Leopards eating people's faces party, I didn't expect the leopards to eat my face!" situation.
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by matthewdgreen on Monday October 03, 2022 @11:00AM (#33068427)
This is the biggest risk right now. Not that democracies will make short-run bad decisions (they will, but that's probably survivable) but that democracies will vote away democracy.
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by hackerlight on Monday October 03, 2022 @11:41AM (#33069075)
It occurred to me that voting away democracy is an absorbing state. You get stuck there once you reach that state. So the law of large numbers is working against you. It just has to happen once.
Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by EGreg on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:14AM (#33065513)
The most common failure mode is when governments don’t listen to the legitimate concerns of other groups, cherrypick the attacks made by a small minority, carry out reprisals to “deter aggression” and start to dehumanize the other population by claiming they are inherently fascist or dumb or bloodthirsty. Then their mass media selects only the things that reinforce “other group does bad things, our group simply makes some mistakes but has great intentions” and “other side must be defeated 100% or it will come back and can’t be trusted to uphold a deal”.

Example: When both Ukraine and Russia were in one federation called USSR (similar to USA, Yugoslavia or EU) then Crimea or some cities moving from Russia to Ukraine would have been regarded as an administrative change, requiring various adjustments to signs and flags. No one would even think of killing each other over which republic’s flag would fly over what territory, let alone escalating to a nuclear war that threatens to destroy human life on the planet. Think about how insane that is.

In a libertarian world, cities would simply vote for a free market of competing agencies providing police, road maintenance, etc. And the whole package of “services” from a state would be unbundled and not worth fighting over. The concept of “territorial integrity of a country” or “national armies” would not be something that would even matter. The people of Hong Kong or Catalonia or Kurdistan or Bangladesh would be pretty happy and not have to fight for their “independence”. Countries shouldn’t own people. People should self-organize to get their needs met in peaceful arrangements and that’s all.

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by bulatb on Monday October 03, 2022 @09:11AM (#33066995)
That world exists in the imaginary term: the land of wonderful things we could have in the long term, if everyone would just not do the thing they absolutely will do in the short term.

All solutions that need everyone to "just" unfortunately have one thing in common: they fail.

It doesn't matter what could happen if everyone "just"—they won't. It doesn't matter that "but if they did"—they won't. It doesn't matter that "Ok, but if"—they won't.

"But if" is not a possibility, and operating like it is will only keep us from whatever progress toward that wonderful thing we could actually make, incomplete as it might be.

Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e... by Edman274 on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:14PM (#33069544)
What would prevent a city from raising an army to go capture another city's natural resources by force?