News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:51PM (#33062105)
> Unfortunately the circumstances where this is useful is very limited.

Even worse: Advancing missile technology has mostly invalidated the need for aircraft in a major war since a long while, and drones will literally sweep what's left of it.

The Iranian drones' amazing performance in Ukraine shows that warfare has changed forever. The drones can travel 1700 km autonomously, very hard to jam, and they are cheaper than the missiles that are used to shoot them. So that at this point you could bankrupt an enemy by just sending drones. If they can destroy them, they go bankrupt due to missile costs. If they cant or dont, you hit all the targets.

The only way to deal with this will be miniaturization of warfare, ie creation of mini drones and mini missiles to hunt drones. Which is still difficult to do and yet to be done because miniaturization is difficult.

Aircraft are old news. If you can destroy a target by sending an autonomous drone that travels 1700km, which costs less than a fraction of one sortie of an aircraft, leave aside the cost of aircraft, its armament and pilot training, it means that drones rule warfare now.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by hef19898 on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:21AM (#33064823)
Yeah, aircraft are as obsolete as tanks, the Ukrainian War showed us as much. And all major powers are only developing new generation fighters, bombers and tanks to keep the military-industrial complex busy. Or not.

A Javelin can take out a tank, but not replace it. A drone, or cruise missile, can take a ground target, a missile can take out aircraft, but they cannot replace their roles.

The reason tanks get destroyed left and right in Ukraine is a combination of bad docteine / tactics and deployment, the use of quasi obsolete models and the large scale use of last gen anti-tank weapons. The reason nobody has airial superiority is somewhat similar, near equal tech, decent air defence and comparable numbers.

As far as dogfights are concerned, they were declared dead prior to Vietnam. To the point fighter jets didn't get cannons anymore. Vietnam caused the creation of Top Gun, when the Navy realized their pilots were not up to par in airial combat. Stealth, and I am not a real proponent of that and still have to see the advantage it gives you, means one of the following scenarios will happen (assuming near peer adversaries):

- Gen 5 vs. Gen 4 (stealth vs. non-stealth, or rather low detectability): Gen 5 sees Gen 4 first, shoots multiple missiles, Gen 4 takes losses before they can counter attack -> Gen 4 retreats / is out of the fight (no dogfight) or Gen 4 is cought, numerically superior, closes in with Gen 5 and you have a dogfight

- Gen 4 vs. Gen 4: Everyone detects everyone at a large distance, missiles are fired, some losses occure (everyone can react so becasue they are not surprised), parties close in, you have a dog fight (assuming no onr retreats first)

- Gen 5 vs. Gen 5: Parties detect each other very late and close, you almost have a dogfight from the get go

So no, fighters aren't going away nor are dogfights.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:51PM (#33070144)
> Yeah, aircraft are as obsolete as tanks, the Ukrainian War showed us as much

I wouldnt go THAT far yet because there are still some uses for the aircraft. Especially very long range missions are economical by using aircraft. Ie, 2000 km and more ranges. Including interception and air defense. There are missiles that can travel such distances, but they are expensive still.

However true, very soon that kind of range will also be covered by drones, making aircraft totall obsolete.

> As far as dogfights are concerned, they were declared dead prior to Vietnam. To the point fighter jets didn't get cannons anymore. Vietnam caused the creation of Top Gun, when the Navy realized their pilots were not up to par in airial combat.

That was a time in which the missiles were still in their infancy. Hence the miss rate and the need to dogfight. Today its not like that.

> one of the following scenarios will happen

I propose that none of those scenarios will happen. Existing air defense systems now can reach distances up to 500 km and shoot down literally, actually anything. (S-500 and above). Suicide drones can travel 1700 km. Strike drones even more.

There is no need to have any aircraft take off and do mission at a long distance, in which they would get promptly shot down by advanced air defense systems. Just spam drones.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by hef19898 on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:26PM (#33073196)
I think there are very valid reason every Gen 5 fighter has a cannon. I also think neither manned fighters nor tanks are going anywhere soon. The war in Ukraine just painted a fastly wrong picture, for valid reasons for sure, but still wrong concerning modern weapon systems.

As long as someone needs something on the ground been blown up from up close, or protect infantry from being blown up frok up close, tanks are your weapon of choice. You want something on the ground blown up from a distance comparatively cheap? Artillery, idealy self propelled for mobility, is your friend. You want to blow up stuff on the ground far away, and fast, you go for fighter aircraft. Or if you don't want to your enemy to do just that, as those are fast, can cover a lot of groind and controlled locally, so no jaming of any kind. If you want to do the same thing from really far away, use a cruise missile. Or in contested airspace where your piloted aircraft are too valuable? Use a drone, same for long endurance surveillance of uncontested airspace.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by int_19h on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:11AM (#33065492)
To some extent, the reason why tanks get destroyed left and right in Ukraine is because that's not actually unexpected in a peer-to-peer conflict. It's just that it's been so long since the Cold War, we kinda forgot what anticipated losses in a war like that look like.

Same goes for aircraft.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by eru on Sunday October 02, 2022 @09:14PM (#33062270)
> The Iranian drones' amazing performance in Ukraine shows that warfare has changed forever.

Do you have more information on that?

Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @09:37PM (#33062441)
Not in easily accessible Western media, obviously. You have to follow Indian, Chinese or other unaligned sources. Indian outlets would be the easiest. However the best and most striking is to follow the Russian/Slavic channels in Telegram. The footage there is incredible (not gore). They post what Ukrainians post online - drones in flight just before hitting their target. Drones passing over. Multiple drones flying in and hitting their targets despite immense air defense fire. One drone even hit a weapons depot and the resulting fire from the explosion lasted for a day.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by rnk on Monday October 03, 2022 @01:47AM (#33063853)
This is interesting news about the iranian drones I haven't read anywhere. Indian and Chinese media is widely available on the web, surprising this hasn't come up. Can you provide a link to some stories? My own web search found this in Politico. So I don't think it's a secret kept from western media. https://www.politico.com/news/2022/09/26/iranian-drones-ukra...
Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Monday October 03, 2022 @10:47AM (#33068235)
You can google 'Intel Slava Z' telegram channel and join it to access such stuff. Its one of the larger slavic intelligence channels. There are others too.

Such stuff wouldnt be in mass media ever because first, it reduces the competition chances of US armament makers, and second, its something that Iran did, who is obviously evil according to such corporate Angloamerican media like the Politico.

I have to add, following anything from such mainstream corporate Anglosaxon sources is as foolish as it was back in 2003. Back in 2003, there was more effort on the part of the establishment and the corporate media to keep a degree of reliability and trustworthiness. Today, its just emotional manipulation.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by dragonwriter on Monday October 03, 2022 @10:55AM (#33068347)
> Such stuff wouldnt be in mass media ever because first, it reduces the competition chances of US armament makers

Mass media with global reach exists that is headquartered in, and has as much relationship to local arms makers as exists in the US media in countries whose armament makers are the competition to US armament makers, so that explanation seems inadequate and parochial.

> Anglosaxon

Pro tip: you’ll look less like a propaganda shill if you don’t start using contextually unusual and inaccurate labels that contribute nothing to the substance of your message right after the same regime whose propaganda substance you are echoing does so prominently with the exact same terms the same way in its propaganda.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:55PM (#33070215)
> Mass media with global reach exists that is headquartered in, and has as much relationship to local arms makers as exists in the US media in countries whose armament makers are the competition to US armament makers, so that explanation seems inadequate and parochial.

The basic tenet of the US military-industry has been destroying local arms makers in any way they can to replace them. What was done to German and British air defense industries during the Cold War are examples of them. Moreover, the majority of mass media have networked shareholders which include US entities. The immense pushing of US foreign policy in all mass media even in Europe is an indicator of how extensive the control is.

> Pro tip: you’ll look less like a propaganda shill if you don’t start using contextually unusual and inaccurate labels

Pro tip: Anglosaxon is a long-standing history and political science term. And those who are students of either won't stop using it because a certain segment of the Angloamerican public now has an aversion to the term because a certain enemy of their establishment used them. It describes a certain social, political and economic construct, and the term still remains valid today.

If you are offended by such a widely used term in history and political science, heaven knows how much you would be offended by some other terms that are used in those sciences. Here is a 300-year old example.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfidious_Albion

Re:Cobra Maneuver by tsimionescu on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:47AM (#33064243)
Note that in general media only covers stories that they want to see covered. Especially in a war, there will definitely be explicit pressure on how the war is covered, and most journalists are anyway aligned with their home countries even when there is no government pressure.

So just like you wouldn't expect RT to cover Russian losses except perhaps in the most general terms, you shouldn't expect our own countries' losses to be covered by our own media other than in passing (even if it's obviously not as directly controlled as RT is).

Re:Cobra Maneuver by dragonwriter on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:26PM (#33069739)
> However the best and most striking is to follow the Russian/Slavic channels in Telegram. The footage there is incredible

Social media video footage is a very good way to receive whatever emotional message the person who shot, edited, and published the video wants to convey.

Its much less useful as a basis for strategic analysis of the value of weapon systems.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by piyushpr134 on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:30AM (#33064130)
you can search on youtube too. For instance, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g9fXYvjxtYg&ab_channel=First...
Re:Cobra Maneuver by agapon on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:28AM (#33064493)
That video looks more like a commercial than a report on the actual performance of those "suicide drones".
Re:Cobra Maneuver by agapon on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:22AM (#33064461)
They are not that amazing. At least those that are being most commonly used now, Shahed-136 "rebranded" as Geran-2 in Russia. They are rather slow and very noisy . Ukraine claims that 29 of them were shot down while 12 hit their targets. They had a benefit of surprise when they started being used, but not any longer.

BTW, people in Ukraine call those Shaheds "mopeds" because of their engine sound.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by agapon on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:24AM (#33064472)
Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Monday October 03, 2022 @10:49AM (#33068258)
> Ukraine claims

If we go by Ukraine's claims, they should have been at the gates of Moscow at this point. So, just forget that.

> 12 hit their targets

You don't seem to be aware that even if we trusted that number from Ukraine itself, it would still qualify as a majestic performance since the drones are dirt cheap.

> They had a benefit of surprise when they started being used, but not any longer.

The actual videos from the front tell a different story.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by dragonwriter on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:48PM (#33070095)
> If we go by Ukraine’s claims, they should have been at the gates of Moscow at this point.

Ukraine has never claimed an intent to enter Russian territory, so that is clearly false.

> You don’t seem to be aware that even if we trusted that number from Ukraine itself, it would still qualify as a majestic performance since the drones are dirt cheap.

It is a demonstration that Ukraine’s air defenses have focused on what Russia had and was using previously, and not this particular threat. Israel’s performance against this and more advanced Iranian drones (and the fact that Israel keeps jets even though it is the world leader in this class of munitions) are pretty good signals that while these kind of munitions have a role in modern combat, they aren’t magic trump cards that replace manned jets in general, or even just for ground strike roles.

This thread is a pretty good breakdown: https://twitter.com/Justin_Br0nk/status/1574414714469335046

Re:Cobra Maneuver by mizzao on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:35PM (#33062882)
Are you referring to the Turkish Bayraktars or a different drone?
Re:Cobra Maneuver by ivalm on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:51PM (#33062975)
No, Russians are buying Iranian drones that are surprisingly capable. Also funny that Russians are so behind the times that they need to buy advanced military tech from Iran.

Edit: apparently Russians have advanced but uneconomical drones, Iran strikes a better balance!

Re:Cobra Maneuver by unity1001 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @11:29PM (#33063185)
That's not the case. Russian suicide drones seem to be WAY too advanced - it is said that they are so silent that you can't even hear them until they dive for the hit.

From there comes the advantage of the Iranian drones - they make a lot of noise and you can hear them from miles away. But they are WAY cheaper. So you can just swarm the air defences using them. And if the enemy actually uses missiles to hit them, it evaluates to a result like the Iranian drone having shot down the more expensive defense missile because the drone is way cheaper.

...

Iran defense industry just proved that in the current environment there is no need for drones to be that advanced like Russians' drones: The existing defense setups are SO unprepared and so behind in countering drone technology that you can just use simple, cheap drones to hit targets. And even more when you use swarms.

Then again, that's good engineering. It means that Iranians well-engineered their drones according to the existing circumstances.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by ivalm on Sunday October 02, 2022 @11:37PM (#33063223)
Ok, this is an interesting and nuanced post, thank you for the explanation, I edited my post!
Re:Cobra Maneuver by actionfromafar on Monday October 03, 2022 @01:19AM (#33063724)
I feel this has not shaken out properly yet. Obviously (to me) there is another yet-to-be-invented drone counter battery which is not yet invented. Probably smaller drones dive bombing onto the Iranian drones.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by hef19898 on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:37AM (#33065257)
Or it's time to break stuff like the Gepard out of mothballs:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flakpanzer_Gepard

https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2022/07/26/ukraines-ge... Or build new, similar systems. Should cover it pretty well. Or use down graded versions of the various ship-mounted anti-missile systems.

Drone vs. drone dog fights sound like fun. Thinking of it, didn't the Yakuza and Tokyo police have some of those?

Re:Cobra Maneuver by proxysna on Monday October 03, 2022 @03:50AM (#33064639)
Russian "Куб-бла" drones are silent, yes, but also inaccurate and have a significantly smaller payload compared to Iranian Shahed's. Also, both can't be mass produced due to a multitude of reasons.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by manquer on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:00AM (#33063928)
The design is also limited by sanctions on Iran to source advanced parts.
Re:Cobra Maneuver by dragonwriter on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:56PM (#33070240)
> No, Russians are buying Iranian drones that are surprisingly capable

“Loitering munitions”, which sensationalist media refers to as “suicide drones”. Basically, slow, long-range, very-small-warhead prop-driven GPS-guided missiles.

Not “drones” in the “reusable unmanned aerial vehicle” sense.

> Also funny that Russians are so behind the times that they need to buy advanced military tech from Iran.

These aren’t particularly advanced. They are pretty old tech with commercial GPS added for guidance. They have a pretty narrow niche, but its one that is particularly relevant to Russia’s current situation, especially given political constraints relating to Ukraine’s operations and the equipment they are being supplied with.

Re:Cobra Maneuver by dotancohen on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @01:32PM (#33083726)

  > So that at this point you could bankrupt an enemy by just sending drones
Isn't this already the case with the Hamas rockets and the Iron Dome? The Hamas rockets are sawed-down telephone poles, and the Iron Dome interceptors are $100,000 precision instruments.