News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by Nokinside on Sunday October 02, 2022 @06:38AM (#33054726)
Number of viable parties in long term depends on electoral system.

Ranked choice alone makes multiple parties viable but it's not ideal. Yet ranked choice would almost certainly lead to more than two parties in the US.

Electoral system is not only the voting system. Single member districts + plurality (current US system) is the worst system for representative democracy by multiple criteria, so almost any proposal improves the situation.

Proportional representation (PR) is any system where seats are divided between parties/lists by their vote share. Ranked choice is not enough. The US would also need multi member districts.

>By federal law, all members of the United States Congress are elected from single-member districts, and most states also elect their state legislators from single-member districts. Some states, however, utilize multi-member districts. For example, Arizona, New Jersey, South Dakota, and Washington elect all members of their lower state legislative chambers from multi-member districts. https://ballotpedia.org/Multi-member_district

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by dane-pgp on Sunday October 02, 2022 @07:32AM (#33055005)
I think that electoral reform advocates have started to accept that the public is wary of large changes to the voting system and the allocation of districts.

Partly that's for good reason, since the public has seen how those aspects of the electoral process have been manipulated for partisan benefit in the past (or at least, they've been told that the other side is guilty of that, and they believe it) and it's partly because it's easy to argue against any changes by using FUD techniques, relying on people's mindset of "if it ain't broke".

So it's probably right to focus on a change that's limited to just the balloting and winner-determining processes for now, hoping that a future generation of more engaged voters and more representative politicians can push for changes that lead to more proportional outcomes, as you say.

The corollary of this logic, though, is that it would be better to change just the winner-determining process and not change the ballots at all. While I do think that RCV is a huge improvement to FPTP in the US, I do have some sympathy for the claim that RCV is more complicated, which can have a disenfranchising effect.

For example, it introduces unfamiliar new tactical dimensions, where people might be encouraged to rank their least preferred candidate disingenuously higher than another rival in order to cause that rival to be eliminated first. More generally, it pressures voters to have to produce an exhaustive ranking of all possible candidates, some of whom they might not have heard of, and potentially penalizing voters that opt to leave some ranks unspecified. Then there's the problem of needing to use untrustworthy electronic voting machines (or a much longer manual process) to count ballot papers that have N-factorial possible markings for N candidates, in a process which strongly encourages centralization rather than being distributed.

The solution to these problems is a method called Asset Voting, where ballots work exactly the same way as under FPTP, but at the end of the count, the candidates get eliminated one by one and can re-assign their votes to one of the remaining candidates. This completely removes the spoiler effect and the problem of "wasted" votes, while not introducing any extra cost or delay (other than two minutes of asking the eliminated candidates who their votes should be re-assigned to). Unfortunately, though, I don't think this method has the same momentum behind it as RCV or other popular alternatives like Approval Voting.

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by Nokinside on Sunday October 02, 2022 @07:58AM (#33055146)
Asset voting gives no guarantees whatsoever without extensive set of assumptions unless one candidate gets single majority.

Most of these systems can be made better with multi-member districts. At this point D'Hondt-method is tried an true. The US could use Jefferson method (invented Thomas Jefferson) because "Murica" but it gives the same result :)

I agree with you, that the most important thing is to implement some change, not strive to fix everything at once. Once voting methods change, politics change and other changes can become easier.

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by dane-pgp on Sunday October 02, 2022 @11:36AM (#33056832)
> Asset voting gives no guarantees whatsoever

I'm not sure what guarantees you require a voting system to provide. Do you not agree it is better than plurality voting?

I suppose you could say that it's not "guaranteed" to solve the spoiler problem, because if you vote for a candidate who claims to have very similar policies to another candidate you like, they might turn around and betray you and re-assign your vote to another candidate you are completely opposed to. However, the fact that candidates might talk one way but act another way seems to be an issue that's common to all voting systems, and therefore out of scope.

> At this point D'Hondt-method is tried an true.

Any electoral change that requires an explanation of the form "First we calculate the quotient with the following formula..." is doomed to failure in a world of misinformation and vested interests trying to undermine confidence in elections. You're right, though, that in the US it would be wise to advocate for Jefferson's method, and brand it that way.

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by Nokinside on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:36PM (#33059408)
> I'm not sure what guarantees you require a voting system to provide.

Just as´ examples of desirable properties are Unanimity, Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives. If you know enough to suggest asset voting, I suspected you know enough about social choose theory or electoral systems to have at least some of them in mind. Asset voting is just plurality voting that reverts into weighted electors. It allows any kind of surprises that voters did not want.

>Any electoral change that requires an explanation of the form

The simplest explanation for is

1. Each party gets representatives relative to the number of votes they received.

2. Party representatives are picked in the order they received votes (open list).

small print: how it is done mathematically was explained by Thomas Jefferson, in a letter to George Washington in 1792. Belgian mathematician Victor D'Hondt found simpler method in 1878. The methods are equivalent.

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by dane-pgp on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:01AM (#33063336)
> Just as´ examples of desirable properties are Unanimity, Independence of Irrelevant Alternatives.

I'm aware of many desirable properties, such as the ones listed here[0], but "Unanimity" is not mentioned on that page. I struggle to even imagine what such a criterion would be. "If every voter votes for a given candidate, then that candidate should win"? That sounds like an obviously desirable property, but of course Asset Voting has that property, so I'm still not sure what the objection is.

The other property you mention (IIA) is one I'm not actually convinced is desirable. It makes the analysis of voting systems easier if you can assume it as an axiom, but I think it only applies to spherical voters in a vacuum. People change their preferences due to minor "unrelated" pieces of information all the time, so it doesn't seem odd to me that a voter might see party C on a list and update their view of the world, such that they decide they were wrong to support party A over party B, for example.

Anyway, you said "Asset voting gives no guarantees whatsoever", which I guess must be hyperbole, because Asset Voting is guaranteed to provide the desirable property of the Majority Criterion (MC), since a candidate with a majority of the (first round) vote cannot be beaten no matter the distribution of votes for other candidates.

The best I can do at steelmanning your complaint is that some of these desirable properties are difficult to reason about in relation to Asset Voting, because its result-generating process takes as part of its input the decisions made by the candidates themselves, which these formalized properties don't consider. However, that seems like a failure of the properties themselves rather than the voting method, unless you can think of a way that Asset Voting fails in practice due to their inapplicability.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_electoral_system...

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by singhblom on Sunday October 02, 2022 @12:15PM (#33057261)
You could require candidates to publicly disclose their ranking of the other candidates before the election. If they have to lock in their preference a few days before voting day that in itself would be informative for voters.
Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by dane-pgp on Sunday October 02, 2022 @12:41PM (#33057591)
I think candidates might be reluctant to do this, since it could be seen as an admission that the candidate thinks they might not win (although personally I would view a candidate as being arrogant and complacent if they couldn't imagine losing).

You're probably right, though, that candidates should be forced to do this, and maybe they should be able to choose whether or not to disclose their preference in advance to potential voters. If they opt to keep it secret and they win, then their preference never has to be revealed, and if they are eliminated then only their highest remaining preference is revealed.

Admittedly I haven't proved that there aren't times when a candidate may need to tactically reorder their preferences based on the actual distribution of votes, but I can't think of a situation where they wouldn't want to re-assign their votes to the candidate whose values are most similar to theirs / their voters.

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by pessimizer on Sunday October 02, 2022 @12:51PM (#33057706)
I like this and would like to see someone work out its implications. Otherwise, asset voting just seems like a way that campaign funders could stuff 13 straw candidates on the ballot with positions tangled enough to dilute the support of 2-3 threatening candidates (threatening to a particular policy, for example), then after the vote the straw candidates all fall and throw their votes to Mussolini, Jr..
Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by dane-pgp on Sunday October 02, 2022 @03:07PM (#33059149)
That's an interesting theoretical attack that I hadn't considered, thank you for sharing it.

I think a possible rule to defend against it would be to mandate that any political party needs to have received at least 5% of the popular vote in that local region in the previous local elections in order to be eligible to stand candidates for the national congress/parliament.

If a candidate wants to stand without the backing of any political party, they would need to receive at least 20% of the (first round) votes in their district in order to win (without needing to stand in the local elections first).

Forcing candidates to publish their vote assignments at registration time might be the way to go, though, as it would help to expose these straw candidates, and also mean that the candidates wouldn't have to be present when the voting result is announced.

To avoid embarrassment, candidates could place a "null" option in their lists, meaning "If I am eliminated, then discard all the votes I received (including the votes assigned to me from earlier-eliminated candidates) and let the remaining candidates win or lose based on the remaining votes".

Re:We don’t need a third party. We need ranked choice voting by landemva on Sunday October 02, 2022 @09:17PM (#33062292)
The number of parties depends on State election law and has nothing to do with ranked choice or proportional voting. For chicagotribune.com area it is laws in Illinois which say:

- 'new political party shall become an "established political party"'

and

- Sec. 7-19. 'The primary ballot ..' shall be arranged and printed ...:

    1. Designating words. At the top of the ballot "REPUBLICAN PRIMARY BALLOT"; "DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY BALLOT"'

That is from https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs5.asp?ActID=170&Ch...

It is State election law which creates the domination of the two-party major/minor system. It's simply hard-coded this way. Coders might say RTFM.