News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:00AM (#3303536)
"the EU is taking away liberties of people and countries in name of a 'common good' and a 'better europe'"

I'm struggling to think of what individual liberties I've lost to the EU.

On the other hand the fact that people from anywhere in the EU can come here to live and work here in the UK is great and the fact I can work, live and travel where I want within the EU looks like a huge increase in liberty to me.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by BSousa on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:23AM (#3303595)
Ok, first I'm not totally against EU and I know they did some good things, but heres some things from the top of my mind that relate to my personal liberties:

- Barroso being elected in a secret vote by EU parliament (I'm sorry, but that isn't very democratic)

- Circumventing Ireland's vote on the the Lisbon treaty, but saying in the EU parliament that even without Ireland's vote, they will modify whatever in the rules is needed for the Lisbon treaty to come into effect (Think it was Barroso and some Belgium guy that said that)

- Trying to ban sale (not sure what was the resolution on that one but was supposed to come into effect early this year) on all over the counter supplements.

- Forcing US vendors to setup a local presence to pay VAT on online shopping (even of digital goods).

- While this was was sorta deserved, since we did take their 'bailout' but Germany/France and now the EU saying countries should lose their part of their sovereign powers if they request help.

- Preventing, by direct influencing politicians, referendums in countries where a vote against some resolution is against EU ideas (leaving the Euro, leaving EU, signing the Lisbon treaty which by the polls some other countries pepole would also be against it) removing from the people the right to choose democratically.

The problems I see with EU was when they tried to shift it from a set of 'gentlemen' agreements about trade and free pass to trying to make it a full state (ala USA) without allowing the people to vote on whether they want to or not.

Edit: While I can't find an unedited video, here is a good example why more and more I'm starting to hate the EU. Please do watch it and than explain to me that there are no liberties being lost: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M6QmH-7fu68

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:31AM (#3303617)
Of course, I should be careful about coming across as completely uncritical of the EU. Some things it does are pretty awful.

However, on balance, I'm pretty keen on wider and deeper European integration.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by masklinn on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:21AM (#3303588)
> I'm struggling to think of what individual liberties I've lost to the EU

Likewise. So far for France it's mostly been a very positive driving force, especially in fixing the completely fucked up legal system and strengthening defense rights (the french political class and police force are still fighting those, but they've been on the losing side every time so far). If anything, most of the EU decisions have seemed to improve the situation of individual liberties and reign in country insanity.

> On the other hand the fact that people from anywhere in the EU can come here to live and work here in the UK is great and the fact I can work, live and travel where I want within the EU looks like a huge increase in liberty to me.

Yep, great one as well (although technically the UK is not covered by the EU, it's a separate set of agreements)

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:53AM (#3303663)
You may be mixing up the Schengen Agreement, which the UK is not part of, and the EU which the UK is most certainly part of!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Agreement

As far as I know it's the EU that gives me the right to work and live anywhere in the EU. Schengen gives citizens of member countries the ability to travel between countries without passport controls.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by danmaz74 on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:05AM (#3303547)
I'm from Italy, and, even if there are some things I don't like coming from the EU (for example, some regulations about food), I find that a LOT has improved in Europe thanks to it. I would just like things to improve even more ;)
Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:19AM (#3303582)
Even with food, things like the Protected Geographical Status seem like a damn good idea - we have fantastic local foods in the EU and this can do a lot to protect manufacturers from blatantly unfair competition and give good guarantees to consumers:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_Geographical_Status

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by Shivetya on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:29AM (#3303611)
So forty six thousand words designating what is acceptable as a 'quality wine' is a good thing? To be a quality wine requires that the wine be produced in a designated area?

Sorry, but to me that is nothing more than good old protectionism to prevent worthy competitors from entering a market. I would not doubt that it is so corrupt that you can buy your way into a designated area provided you have the connections.

While some protection of known names is valid, determine who makes a good product simply based on their geographical domain is not. What we have is government bureaucrats picking winners and losers.

Fantastic local foods protect themselves by upholding their quality and their name. I fully agree that names need protecting, however determine quality by the region its produced in; the wine example; is wrong.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by danmaz74 on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:52AM (#3303660)
Quality wine doesn't need to come from a specific area. But if you write "Chianti Wine", it has to come from Chianti (which is a specific area in Italy).

There is protectionism, and there is consumer protection: I'm glad to buy food from everywhere, but I want to know what it is.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:47AM (#3303647)
I agree that the wine example is stupid, but here is (fairly) local example to me:

http://www.arbroathsmokies.net/pgi.php

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by zeugma on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:25AM (#3303599)
> On the other hand the fact that people from anywhere in the EU can come here to live and work here in the UK is great and the fact I can work, live and travel where I want within the EU looks like a huge increase in liberty

Unfortunately, this is not true for UK as UK is not part of Shengen. I think most(but not all) EU citizen can settle in UK and UK citizen settle in EU countries, but this is due to bilateral treaty not European one. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area)

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by nknight on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:37AM (#3303629)
Schengen concerns passport/border controls, it has nothing to do with rights concerning living and working in EEA countries.