News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by Shivetya on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:29AM (#3303611)
So forty six thousand words designating what is acceptable as a 'quality wine' is a good thing? To be a quality wine requires that the wine be produced in a designated area?

Sorry, but to me that is nothing more than good old protectionism to prevent worthy competitors from entering a market. I would not doubt that it is so corrupt that you can buy your way into a designated area provided you have the connections.

While some protection of known names is valid, determine who makes a good product simply based on their geographical domain is not. What we have is government bureaucrats picking winners and losers.

Fantastic local foods protect themselves by upholding their quality and their name. I fully agree that names need protecting, however determine quality by the region its produced in; the wine example; is wrong.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by danmaz74 on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:52AM (#3303660)
Quality wine doesn't need to come from a specific area. But if you write "Chianti Wine", it has to come from Chianti (which is a specific area in Italy).

There is protectionism, and there is consumer protection: I'm glad to buy food from everywhere, but I want to know what it is.

Re:Poll: HN EU readers, should we start lobbying the EU? by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:47AM (#3303647)
I agree that the wine example is stupid, but here is (fairly) local example to me:

http://www.arbroathsmokies.net/pgi.php