News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by antoniojtorres on Thursday September 29, 2022 @01:49PM (#33024523)
oh wow, thanks for submitting our research! So, we've essentially found that free mobile games engage in a form of traffic arbitrage by making users load entire websites that are ad monetized in order to earn in-game currency. This is considered invalid traffic (IVT) in the digital advertising industry.

The bit that HN may find interesting is that when entire web pages are embedded in a webview like that, the verification javascript embedded in the ads that are present on the page cannot (sometimes at all) realize that they are within a webview. Making this traffic seem totally organic.

What's worse, recently we found that a major podcast network was autoplaying podcasts in order to juice their numbers for all their shows using this rewarded traffic scheme, and again, nearly impossible to verify on the other end.

There's a lot of interesting technology challenges to solve in the ad-tech space because let's be honest, it's pretty rough and privacy hostile.

Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:10PM (#33025596)
>the verification javascript embedded in the ads that are present on the page cannot (sometimes at all) realize that they are within a webview

Good! Webviews are browsers. Browsers are webviews. There’s no way to tell the difference, because there is no difference!

Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by Huh1337 on Friday September 30, 2022 @05:31AM (#33032809)
But there is a significant difference. Browser is an impenetrable sandbox, while Webview can be accessed and modified by the app in many ways.
Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Friday September 30, 2022 @04:50PM (#33040610)
Lmao, no.

When you put a webview in an app, the app is the browser. Period. A browser is by definition an app that displays webviews. And yes, a browser can access and modify the webpages it is displaying, no shit. That’s literallt the job of the browser, aka the user agent.

Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by Huh1337 on Friday September 30, 2022 @05:56PM (#33041317)
Yeah, that's the problem.
Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by aaaaaaaaaaab on Friday September 30, 2022 @08:49PM (#33042634)
The problem?

So you're saying that laypeople shouldn't be allowed to create new browsers that interact with the Web in whatever way they want to? Why exactly?

Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by nitrixion on Thursday September 29, 2022 @05:19PM (#33027357)
> recently we found that a major podcast network was autoplaying podcasts in order to juice their numbers

This is a tactic that some video game streamers use as well. One big example of this is the fextralife wiki site[0]. I get very frustrated when it is the top result from a web search or if it is the only place to get relevant information.

[0] - https://monsterhunterworld.wiki.fextralife.com/Monster+Hunte...

Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by nmacias on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:48PM (#33026104)
I think that Apple should insist that webviews used this way identify themselves via JS as monetization containers, with clear definitions for when and why subject to App Store review. Done.
Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by bee_rider on Thursday September 29, 2022 @04:34PM (#33026768)
IDK it seems like a problem between the ad networks and the developers. What motivation does Apple have to fix it? It seems like it benefits both of their customers -- the third party developers and the end consumers.

Isn't Apple engaging in a war against the ad networks? They should do all they can to facilitate this -- add a special type of embedded browser window to their OS that has garbage cookies/fingerprinting info and is rendered off-screen.

Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by nmacias on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:52PM (#33026162)
I get that idealists will be up in arms about user-agent based self-censorship and still feel this way. It’s reversible immediately if it was proven to be harmful.
Re:An inorganic user engine driving ad campaigns on major we... by canjobear on Thursday September 29, 2022 @09:27PM (#33029738)
Apple should insist that these webviews be as indistinguishable from organic traffic as possible, in order to extinguish parasitical ad networks.