News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by PuppyTailWags on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:36AM (#33021276)
Giving money to parents doesn't necessarily fix the problem of hungry children (this is not a slight to minimum income policies generally; I think all adults should be guaranteed a minimum quality of life regardless of if they've "earned" it, but I understand this is a much larger lift politically and will not necessarily fix everything). I want to fix the problem to hungry children directly by feeding them regardless of the parents capacity to feed them from their own wealth.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:47AM (#33021446)
"Giving money to parents doesn't necessarily fix the problem of hungry children"

If the parents have the money to feed their children and choose not to, there are bigger problems. Addressing the root of that problem would be better than just providing a meal (likely other abuse exists).

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:33AM (#33022125)
Giving money to parents might result in the rent getting paid; it might not result in better nutrition for kids.

Thing is, you can't learn if you're hungry. You can't even sit still in class - you disrupt the education of other kids, and you make life hell for the teacher.

If schools are required to educate kids, and the kids are hungry, then the schools will fail to educate those kids. That is, if they're not ensuring they're fed, then they're doing it wrong.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @12:06PM (#33022603)
What scenarios are the needs-based USDA programs, SNAP/WIC, and food banks missing?
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:11PM (#33025604)
I am not well-informed about the inadequacies of the USA's means-testing of "welfare" (a term that is clean in the UK, but in the USA it's regarded as either plain wrong, or as evidence of bad character).

Being forced to fall back on a food bank is considered demeaning here. From what I've read upthread, a lot of food banks in the USA are church-run. Many people will be ultra-reluctant to essentially beg for help from churchy people, however careful those people are are to keep their churchiness out of their aid provision.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:42PM (#33026025)
Many food banks are not associated with churches.

Why is it a problem that asking for free food is "demeaning"? Seems like that's more of a perspective or attitude issue than a functional one.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:15AM (#33034428)
It's a problem, because people avoid demeaning postures. I'm an old man, but you'd have to punch me quite a few times before I'd be prepared to grovel at your feet.

The simple fact is that there's enough food in the world for everyone. So if people are going hungry, that can only be because either (a) the system is broken; or (b) the system is fine, and it's fine for people to go hungry. You seem to be a proponent of (b).

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by soco on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:49AM (#33022359)
True. Just as not providing those meals doesn't fix that problem either, many temporary fixes get rejected on the reason that they don't address the underlying problems. True, they don't, but alleviating the effects has value as well.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @12:04PM (#33022585)
Until we have a patchwork of ineffective and inefficient temporary fixes that become a permanent drag on society. Temporary fixes can be fine, but they actually have to be temporary. Doing things right can have a much larger benefit than half-assing it and making a bigger mess in the future.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by soco on Thursday September 29, 2022 @01:00PM (#33023625)
Yes, so we're doing neither...
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @02:26PM (#33025062)
Depends on how you look at it. With all the programs that currently exist, we clearly have done something. This is more like the Overton window shifting, where now we think we've done nothing but have already addressed most of the issue through prior (incomplete) "fixes".
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by humanrebar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:38AM (#33021308)
Given sufficient family finances, you can't really fix that without fixing the problem of neglectful or abusive parents.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by PuppyTailWags on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:40AM (#33021355)
That's why I'm asking why can't we provide meals in the schools themselves so at minimum regardless of what's happening at home, children can eat.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by vorpalhex on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:53AM (#33021559)
Go to your local school. Offer to fund their lunch program for a semester or a year.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:48AM (#33021464)
That's just covering a symptom. Truly helping abused children means removing them from the environment of abuse.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by PuppyTailWags on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:53AM (#33021551)
And while that's happening, the kids can eat at school. Removal is often a long process, and you can't rely on proper enforcement, even post-removal foster programs. None of this solves a kid being hungry at school. All I am asking is the minimum floor: Regardless of what's happening outside of school, in school a child can have food if they are hungry.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:57AM (#33021620)
This makes no sense since the same argument can be made about school lunches not being correctly enforced and allowing a child to go hungry because it does meet their dietary restrictions or other enforcement/implementing is flawed.

If there are flaws in the overall system, then Mayne we should focus on treating those. Again, treat the causes, not the symptoms.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:35AM (#33022143)
We're not talking about abused children. We're talking about children from poor homes.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:46AM (#33022315)
Please follow the context of this comment. This was about providing minimum income or otherwise providing money to parents to support their children.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:03PM (#33025525)
The GP was saying that if children arrive hungry for school, they're being abused by their parents; who should be arrested as criminals, and their children taken into care or adopted. Did you miss that bit of the context of the comment?
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by giantg2 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:39PM (#33025986)
I don't see that anywhere. It seems you're misinterpreting, especially if you're not posting quotes.

If the parents have the money (or access to programs that provide resources) and still choose to not properly feed or care for their kid, then perhaps the things you mention do fit. There's clearly case law that supports anyways.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by humanrebar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:04AM (#33021718)
You seemed to want to hear other perspectives and I provided one. And that's in contrast with most of the other replies which boil down to "conservatives are dumb or selfish".

I'm not interested in debating politics on HN.