News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by Gravityloss on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:12AM (#33020879)
Can't think of a thing with a better benefit to cost ratio for a than providing school children a free meal. It's very cheap and it sucks very much if isn't done.

This applies on society, government, municipality, village, family - so many levels.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by yamtaddle on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:18AM (#33020978)
Our schools serve pretty awful meals here (fairly shitty US state), but it was hard to say no to them when they were free due to Covid policies, and man, just the logistical improvement of not having to worry about having stuff on hand for lunches and getting it put together and packed in the morning and making sure the lunches made it into backpacks and into the car was so damn nice. That's like 25% of the getting-the-kids-around morning stress just gone. Made things way more chill.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by wollsmoth on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:35AM (#33021260)
It's definitely possible to give better school lunches out. There sort of a general school funding issue too which is frustrating to hear about so often.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by yamtaddle on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:49AM (#33021481)
I know at least one private school around here has pretty damn good & healthy (but not extravagant or fancy) lunches at something like $2 more per meal per day than what the public schools charge. It amounts to roughly double the cost.

The public schools here don't even seem to operate real kitchens anymore like they did when I was a kid, and aren't equipped to actually cook at all, but just to heat up frozen stuff. Instead of even assembling sandwiches from ingredients, they serve those might-as-well-be-a-candy-bar "uncrustables". That's the degree to which they don't function as a real kitchen anymore. Not-coincidentally, I expect, I'm pretty sure most "kitchen" staff isn't even employed by the schools anymore, but by companies they contract to handle lunch for them.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by jlmorton on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:27AM (#33022022)
It's certainly possible, yes, but it's worth considering the cost, because it adds up quickly.

In England, the cost of a school lunch is about ~£2.35. In the US, it's about ~$3.80.

When I go out to eat in the US for lunch, a typical take-away place to get something like a sandwich is maybe around $12. In the US, if we increased school lunch funding equivalent to that, the increase would be something like $8 per student per day. There are 50 million K-12 students in the US, so that would cost $400 million per day.

The per-pupil cost would be $1,472 per year. In a classroom of 20 students, that would be nearly $30,000/year -- enough to substantially increase teacher salaries, and nearly enough to pay for a teaching assistant in every classroom.

Obviously, there's nothing saying we couldn't increase funding by $1 or $2. But my point is simply that there are indeed trade-offs.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by yamtaddle on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:42AM (#33022252)
It costs way, way less than $12/meal to deliver a healthy, quality, fixed-menu hot meal to a 100-400 people in the US. We could do it for $5/meal, maybe less. Still expensive, but not that expensive.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by jlmorton on Thursday September 29, 2022 @05:00PM (#33027156)
I'm sure you're right. Maybe an easier way to describe the trade-off is to simply say every $1 spent on school lunches in the United States is about a $3,700 annual cost per classroom, and about ~$10 billion nationally.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by yamtaddle on Friday September 30, 2022 @10:37AM (#33035467)
Right, your broader point that it'd be a non-tiny expense is correct, the ballpark total was just far enough off (~double) from the highest remotely plausible figure we might conceivably spend on public school lunches that I thought it worth pointing out.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by bombcar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:32AM (#33021217)
I would be entirely in support for nation-wide soup kitchens open for lunch that provide a basic nutritious and free meal to anyone and everyone, no questions asked.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by ljf on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:46AM (#33021442)
I genuinely think this could solve so many ills.

I really love a library near me that has near the door a load of nice paper shopping bags, labelled up - that anyone can take. Each will have different things in but contain stuff like wash kits and deodorant, tampons and sanitary towels, socks, gloves and even warm jumpers in winter. Anyone who needs one can just grab one. It is sad that we have to give out stuff like this, but equally, if we need to provide these things for people, let's do it in the lowest drama way of doing it, and that doesn't cause stigma or shame.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by conductr on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:47AM (#33021462)
Making it universally accessible is the expensive part.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by tomjen3 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @12:40PM (#33023227)
You start with cities and towns of a certain size, but the only problem I can forse is allergies. You can work around that to some extend (no nuts, no fresh tomatoes), but you are right that for some people they will be SOL.

The key is that you can help 99.9% and then existing services will be able to help the few remaining. The alternative is to help nobody.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by bombcar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @01:31PM (#33024237)
Lots of things like this get shut down because of that 0.01%, and sometimes perhaps rightfully so.

But it also can be harmful if you cancel some great good because some small fraction of the population can't avail themselves of it.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by tomrod on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:23PM (#33025772)
Indeed.

Something like this would need an accessibility plan to be available where needed. It would be a little more expensive at first but then workflows can be improved.

The military and schools already provide food for large groups. As do private companies like Aramark (although to be fair Aramark reported often provides _spoiled_ food to prisons). The point is, these logistics are all well established with most of the hangups worked out in general principle.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by bombcar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:43PM (#33026035)
Let's assume $1 per meal per person (perhaps low, perhaps high, I don't know) - that would be $330 million per day if everyone availed themselves of the free lunch. That is (let's round up a bit) $125 billion a year.

Now if everyone did avail themselves of the free lunch slop each day, we'd clearly see a downturn in lunch business at many restaurants, so there would be other effects, but it does not seem entirely impossible.

And certainly not impossible to start with the students at schools, then expand to all children, and then to the children and elderly, and then to all.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by tomrod on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:49PM (#33026117)
Indeed. Also, at $X/day, 330M x $X/day is a high overestimate simply because you don't HAVE to eat at these places.

So low quality places, like McDonalds (consistent, but low, quality -- I'll not concede this point) would be impacted. But better quality food providers would not. So you would have crowding out on the low end. Does that make society as a whole worse off? Maybe not completely first-order pareto improving (people would pay taxes), but imagine how much better society is if kids can get fed and then focus on their educations? I think the second order knock-on effects are huge.

Now apply that world-wide. I am getting the Kurzgesagt warm fuzzies.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by conductr on Thursday September 29, 2022 @05:58PM (#33027854)
Feeding America's financials indicate their cost is ~$0.7 per meal. However, not on the financials is that they likely rely on a large volunteer support network of food banks, churches, etc. A lot of free, and expensive, labor. Also, I don't think they prepare the food, they just provide raw ingredients to folks.

That said, I think if you were creative with the menu - serving food staples known for low cost and decent nutrition it would be comparable. But this is beans and rice, lentils, PB&J sandwiches, etc. But I personally think this is fine. For me, the goal is to ensure no one starves it's not to provide a complete nutrition for every single person. Since the offerings are slim and not exactly desirable, the impact to McDonald's lunch business would likely be small. Pretty much anyone with the means to do so would rather eat something they paid for. It depends on if you view it as a general public service or if you view it as a safety net I suppose.

All that said, I think this has no chance of actually gaining momentum. Not in the US anyway. It sounds like something a Nordic country could pull off.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by bombcar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @06:03PM (#33027931)
I'd aim it at just above a safety net, but decent enough that it'd be "ok" if you didn't want to bother with anything else. Like you said, beans, rice, staples. You certainly wouldn't have gallons of sugar water going along with it.

Something like this: https://www.aljazeera.com/gallery/2013/11/17/in-pictures-kit...

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by tomjen3 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @04:30PM (#33026706)
You can provide food that ticks whatever boxes these companies have to make, but I would like to provide high nutrition food. And frankly, I don't want to spend extra on your food because you have to have the Jewish option. Or the vegan option or the one without beef.

On the other hand, in prison I would want there to be an option that satisfy each religions requirements, because I don't want the state to dictate peoples belief.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by bombcar on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:50AM (#33021508)
I wonder how expensive it would be after awhile, if the food was very basic and boring. I suspect that most people who do have other options would get bored with it relatively quickly; McDonalds may exist but so do many other restaurants.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by andrekandre on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:57AM (#33021614)
not necessarily, since you can just tax it back from rich families later (no need for means-testing bureaucracy, which can be the real expensive part since it has to scale with usage)
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by conductr on Thursday September 29, 2022 @12:37PM (#33023148)
The food has to be near the hungry though.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by andrekandre on Thursday September 29, 2022 @05:33PM (#33027512)
good point
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by adabyron on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:18AM (#33020975)
Free school meals for all kids could simplify a lot of things. Obviously it could be paid for by an income based tax. Nation wide tax makes most sense to me.

It's the cheapest & easy way to help these kids get nutrition. It benefits society more than the cost.

It also prevents the need to waste money on lunch cards, payment systems & some poor lady having to manage & collect payments.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by nerdawson on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:53AM (#33021560)
Taxation is already used to fund schooling and ensuring kids are fed should simply be an extension of that.

The government have just cut taxes so they're heading in the opposite direction.

With that said, it doesn't address the underlying problem of kids being allowed to go hungry. If free school meals were universal (and they should be), that's still only 5 / 21 weekly meals provided for.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by adabyron on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:36PM (#33030206)
Not sure about England but in the US there are programs like "Backpack for Kids" that allow kids to sign up to receive a backpack for the weekends. They also do lunches during the summer.

It's not the best food but it's calories with some nutrition & easy for kids to make.

During my time volunteering I learned that the challenges are not getting enough funding or food but getting the food to the people who need it. From elderly to babies.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by pessimizer on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:35AM (#33021263)
> Free school meals for all kids could simplify a lot of things.

A universal benefit guarantees 100% utilization. If you put in bureaucracy and/or a token payment, people will fail to navigate it (and downstream bureaucracies with their own budgets can make it more difficult to navigate), so like magic the program becomes a lot cheaper (by leaving children hungry.)

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by BitwiseFool on Thursday September 29, 2022 @10:50AM (#33021503)
>"A universal benefit guarantees 100% utilization"

Not necessarily, I know a lot of progress has been made since I left school but back in my day there were some seriously low grade meals served at the cafeteria. It was not uncommon for other kids to bring lunchables and homemade meals to eat instead and we'd throw out the tray of food provided to us. I'm not anti-free school meals for all, however. I just wanted to add the caveat that the 100% utilization metric is not quite as it seems.

Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Thursday September 29, 2022 @11:10AM (#33021792)
My kids wouldn't eat the (paid-for) hot school meals. They both preferred the sandwiches I made for them.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by tomrod on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:46PM (#33026073)
Your kids are privileged to have loving parent(s) in their lives -- many of my children's classmates are not as fortunate. Free meals took one bit of stress out of their lives, and benefited us too on those occasional days we weren't able to get a good lunch together.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by denton-scratch on Friday September 30, 2022 @09:17AM (#33034452)
For clarity, I'm strongly in favour of free school meals; preferably not means-tested.
Re:Schools in England warn of crisis of ‘heartbreaking’ rise... by tomjen3 on Thursday September 29, 2022 @12:36PM (#33023126)
Based on the food that is served in US schools, I wonder if you are not better of without.

That said, it is ridiculous to have hungry children in a country that also has national health care. It is much, much cheaper to feed a child than to deal with health issues from hunger.