Also, this comment nails it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33002963
And yes it’s backed by a paper contract. That’s why I’m ok with it. But it’s still gives me liquidity and ownership security I couldn’t get with a central database.
For everything you want a c corporation provides the exact same guarantees while not becoming a money laundering hotspot
> backed by a paper contract
So.... What's the point of blockchain in this case? Other than "hey, we have blockchain"?
> But it’s still gives me liquidity and ownership security
What gives you ownership security is the paper contract, not some bytes in some database.
Fractional ownership in real estate has a long history of scams.
Being digital makes it much more liquid. There's literally nothing about fractional real estate ownership that needs distributed consensus.
>Another advantage is that it doesn't matter if the facilitator goes out of business, because all the ownership records are on a public blockchain instead of their secret central database.
You could solve that problem by only working with companies that have publicly readable centralized databases? Again no need for distributed consensus.
But I think that the distributed-public-database thing has real value. Companies come and companies go, and opening up data to the scrutiny of daylight is sorta a prisoner’s dilemma problem much of the time. Building a long-lived business on top of a by-design-public data store seems like a really cool thing.
Sure, any company could decide to host a Postgres instance on AWS with world-readable creds. But does that happen? And what happens when the company goes under? Who keeps paying the AWS bills?
This type of investing has long been done on paper, but the blockchain makes it much more liquid. Selling your fractional ownership in a property was onerous at best, and took a long time and a lot of fees.
Now it's just sending a token to someone else in exchange for money (fiat or crypto).
Another advantage is that it doesn't matter if the facilitator goes out of business, because all the ownership records are on a public blockchain instead of their secret central database.
I generally agree with you, A LOT of crypto is crap and could be better solved with a central database. But there are valid use cases.