News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3x new books added to the Pirate Library Mirror by pessimizer on Sunday September 25, 2022 @03:55PM (#32975366)
Academic publishing says this too, and for them at least it turns out not to be true, because they insist that typesetting be done before they see it. The value-add from the publishing industry in general is payment advances and marketing. Same as the music industry. They're both a whole lot more and a whole lot less than somebody drafting in word.

Anybody can hire an editor.

Re:3x new books added to the Pirate Library Mirror by tptacek on Sunday September 25, 2022 @08:36PM (#32978025)
Anybody can indeed hire an editor, but you have to hire them. Nobody edits (or copyedits) for free. Which is Kasey's point.
Re:3x new books added to the Pirate Library Mirror by autoexec on Monday September 26, 2022 @05:11PM (#32988477)
> Nobody edits (or copyedits) for free.

They absolutely do and would do more often without copyright laws holding them back. Every person who finds a book they want to share with others would be free to make improvements as they saw fit, and that would certainty include edits and correcting errors.

Even today we have rouge editors who take copyrighted works, then illegally edit and distribute them along with their changes because they feel it improves the works in question. Examples include fan edits of films to improve the narrative and streamline edits of mythbusters to remove obnoxious repetitive cruft.

Other examples of free editors can be found in Wikipeida articles, fanfic projects, fan translation projects, and video game walkthroughs. Even mods/patches for video games can be a form of "free editing".

There are very few forms of media where I haven't seen people providing some form of editing services for free. (I can't say I've seen it for oil paintings yet I guess)

Re:3x new books added to the Pirate Library Mirror by JadeNB on Monday September 26, 2022 @07:12PM (#32989833)
> Nobody edits (or copyedits) for free.

I think Wikipedia is a massive, living counterexample to this. It has tons of problems, but the lack of people willing to do the work for free is not one of them.