Of course, it makes sense that when introducing a new product like this to the market, it is potentially going to be more expensive than existing products. It seems like, in theory, one should be able to make it much cheaper just because producing meat by way of animals is just very wasteful from an energy perspective. However, I have no clue what is required to synthesize such compounds without the use of animals, so I don't know how far away we are from being able to do this.
That being said, I did a price check and found that soy milk was not cheaper than regular milk. Kroger milk is $3.29 for 1gal and soymilk is $2.59 for 0.5gal.
1 Liter of 3.5 Fat Milk = 0.99 EUR
1 Liter of unsweetened soy drink = 0.95 EUR
Burger meat was 0.80€ person for 125g, not organic/bio. But good quality from a German butcher.
I got Beyond burgers for the veg option. Best price I could get wholesale was 2.00€ per person.
- Bean (often spicy)
- Halloumi
- Parsnip & Carrot Nut
- Plantlife Crunchy Vegetable Crispbake
If you do want to use a meat substitute, I've found the following have comparable prices to the meat based versions at ~£2.00 for 2:
- Linda McCartney's Burgers
- Richmond Vegan Meat Free
Other meat replacement brands (Beyond Meat, Moving Mountains, Fried Jackfruit, etc.) are dearer at ~£4.00-£4.50 for 2.
I'm not sure how the wholesale prices compare, I just checked the prices on Waitrose's website. I've had several of these.
As someone who doesn't eat meat, I prefer not to have fake meat. I'll often just pass on eating anything if fake meat is the only non-meat option.
A stir fry with rice or veggie fajitas (could be just peppers and onions) with Mexican tortillas possibly with a side of beans would be much preferable, and cost nearly nothing. Adjust for regional tastes.
Easy to justify when it is something that can be a main dish for the non-meat eaters and a side dish for the meat eaters. But, if people are serving themselves, the non-meat item should be earlier on the table / separated from the meat, so meat eaters do not contaminate it with meat (common).
Fake meat is a nice option for meat eaters who are trying to reduce their consumption of meat for $reason(s), but still crave meat. But, for folks like me who do not eat meat nor have any inclination to do so, it is kinda weird.
When I cook vegetarian, it can be a lot more work. How long do I do so-and-so, how much whatever goes in the what not, stuff like that.
There’s a lot of intuition in cooking, and switching paradigms can be challenging.
Especially if someone is new to vegetarian food and don't know what those "zillions of awesome vegetarian dishes" even are, let alone how to prepare them.
The problem isn't bing vegetarian/vegan, the problem is that people have absolutely no education when it comes to nutrition
On the other hand it could be because if restaurants have a similar product at a lower price, then customers might go for the cheaper option, thus reducing overall profits.
> The United States federal government spends $38 billion every year subsidizing the meat and dairy industries. Research from 2015 shows this subsidization reduces the price of Big Macs from $13 to $5 and the price of a pound of hamburger meat from $30 to the $5 we see today.
1. https://www.aier.org/article/the-true-cost-of-a-hamburger/
Average meat consumption per person is 260 pounds, which would come out to about 40 cents per pound in subsidy.
I don't know what the factors are, but there might be some reason in particular ground beef ends up taking a large share of the subsidies. I know what steak at the grocery store is quite expensive compared to ground beef, so maybe ground beef is targeted so lower income people can afford it while steak is not. Who knows. It would take more than napkin math to convince me that they're lying.
And it is given without a citation, and the document's authors are Directors/R&D/Tech Lead people at Samsung, VMWare, and Google.
And: "This paper was created in an open classroom environment as part of a program within the Sutardja Center for Entrepreneurship & Technology"
So it's just laundered fake research.
The source of such a figure is surely going to be some reasoning like this, plus inflation, which cites the vast majority of "subsidy" being "healthcare costs":
https://meatonomics.com/2013/08/15/each-time-mcdonalds-sells...
But without looking at the source, napkin math tells you at the very least the number is way out of whack, and at best it'd have been cherry-picked for the purpose of deception.
Because the scale of meat alternatives did not reach the scale of being cheaper yet...
Vegetarians and vegans are willing to endure a lot of costs, financial and otherwise, to adhere to a special diet.
Interestingly, it seems that every time I see an Impossible burger on a menu, it's not cheaper. Often it's more expensive, but usually roughly the same price. I'm not sure why this is, but it seems like it's probably holding folks back from eating it regularly.