News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by Smithalicious on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:10PM (#32955844)
Absolutely tragic that the US government's war on anonymous transactions is getting in the way of FOSS receiving donations here. I presume the donations itself is an attempt to make a statement, and I applaud it. Make people feel the impact of this attempt of absolute financial control without hurting them. I hope the developer can get access to the funds in the end!
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by mmastrac on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:01PM (#32956389)
Are you sure this money isn't stolen? We just don't know.

If I was a charity and got a suitcase full of dirty cash, I wouldn't necessarily be upset if I had to jump through hoops to make use of it.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by drdrey on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:27PM (#32956665)
If someone pays you in cash, how do you know the money was not stolen?
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by mrgoldenbrown on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:45PM (#32956848)
You don't know. That's why there are rules about when to report large cash transactions. For example: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/understand-how-to-report-large-...
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by ram4jesus on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:14PM (#32955900)
If someone donated me a brand new mid-engine Corvette, it would be a huge headache because I couldn't afford the taxes & maintenance.

I think in this case, FOSS would stand to gain more by not receiving money-laundered transactions which, as someone else pointed out in this discussion, would create a compliance nightmare.

To put it this way: would you accept 1,000 dollars from me if it would take you 100 hours of your life to receive?

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by Ajedi32 on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:27PM (#32956047)
Right, and that's the point. If an open source project can't receive an anonymous donation without a "compliance nightmare", then what does that say about the laws and regulations which created that nightmare in the first place?

Keep in mind that there is, as of right now, no evidence that this cash was "laundered" or in any way associated with any nefarious activity. It's merely anonymous.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by pavlov on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:07PM (#32956448)
Who can receive $400k today from an unknown source without any questions asked? Nobody — not an ordinary person, not a small business, not a foundation.

What exactly makes an open source project so special that it should be exempt from the regulations that apply to everyone else?

And if that were the case, what would prevent an open source project from being just a smokescreen for something else? Obscure API implementations paying pseudonymous developers for PRs with anonymous donation money seems like a fine kind of laundering operation.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by Ajedi32 on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:35PM (#32958713)
> Obscure API implementations paying pseudonymous developers for PRs with anonymous donation money seems like a fine kind of laundering operation.

If that happens then you investigate, find out if it is a money laundering scheme, and bring a criminal prosecution if it is. You don't just assume they're guilty because the transaction was anonymous, or ban privacy tools and conduct mass surveillance on every transaction to make sure none of them are suspicious.

It's kinda wild how many people on HN suddenly become anti decentralization and pro mass surveillance whenever the topic of cryptocurrency comes up.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by acdha on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:06PM (#32956434)
> If an open source project can't receive an anonymous donation without a "compliance nightmare", then what does that say about the laws and regulations which created that nightmare in the first place?

This makes it sound like this happened in a vacuum, but those laws and regulations are in response to real world events and you have to consider that when talking about whether laws are unreasonable. For example, many people would have ethical objections to accepting a donation from an unknown source (what if the money was generated from some activity I object to?), don't want to deal with potential hassle if the source does something to trigger legal attention, or the risk of a non-zero chance of some unsavory sorts showing up and “suggesting” that you give them some fraction of it as clean cash, etc.

Allowing anonymous transactions means that the latter two kinds of events will happen on an somewhat regular basis, which is why most people accept laws requiring financial institutions to know their customers' identities as a necessary cost. If you say magic internet money is exempted from those requirements, well, there are going to be a whole bunch of surprisingly well-funded open source projects in Mexico paying salaries which make FAANG employees weep with envy.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by Dylan16807 on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:27PM (#32956045)
If someone gives you a brand new car, and you really don't want to be bothered with it, I think you could arrange a sale for 2/3 its value in a couple hours.

> To put it this way: would you accept 1,000 dollars from me if it would take you 100 hours of your life to receive?

Does that really apply here? If this money can't be touched, then it's a minor time sink with zero benefit.

If there is a way to dump in 100 hours and extract the money, it's worth it because it's so much.

That analogy is more fitting to a 1 ETH donation.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by ascar on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:01PM (#32956387)
> To put it this way: would you accept [350,000] dollars from me if it would take you 100 hours of your life to receive?

Fixed the amount for you. Yes, absolutely. I would spend 100 hours to receive the 350,000. That's 3500 per hour.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by ram4jesus on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:20PM (#32956579)
Thank you for the correction.

Assuming the money would be ethical and cleared by the government (two separate things), I too would absolutely take it. :P

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by mrtranscendence on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:24PM (#32956001)
I suppose that in this case the project received enough money to hire two lawyers to deal with it full time for a year, so as long as there's a chance it could still be worth it. I'd put the odds pretty low, though.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by bergenty on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:38PM (#32956163)
What are you talking about? You just sell the thing immediately.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by kube-system on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:57PM (#32956349)
The sanctions caused the donation. Criminals with big bucks in their account are blowing it on donations because they can't convert it to Lamborghinis, hookers, and mansions anymore.

Tornado Cash wasn't some haven for big money philanthropy pre-sanctions.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by xur17 on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:14PM (#32956514)
Do you have evidence to back this assertion?

> Tornado Cash wasn't some haven for big money philanthropy pre-sanctions.

Vitalik used it to donate to Ukraine [0], and there are several other examples here [1] as well.

[0] https://forkast.news/vitalik-buterin-says-used-tornado-cash-...

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-08/coinbase-...

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by kube-system on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:19PM (#32956569)
I'll go further than your examples: I am sure hundreds of Ethereum enthusiasts have sent pocket change to Ukraine with it.

Nobody was sending a half-million dollars to FOSS projects with it pre-sanctions.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by xur17 on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:30PM (#32956719)
Please provide evidence, not assumptions.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by kube-system on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:40PM (#32956797)
I don't know how I can prove a negative. Here's a list of all philanthropist FOSS project donors I'm aware of who spoke out against the Tornado Cash sanctions, and all the Twitter posts of surprised FOSS project developers who were happy to receive gigantic donations from TC pre-sanctions:

    []
We can, however, consider your sources of people who did speak out -- none of them are philanthropists who contributed to large sums to FOSS projects. They were ETH enthusiasts who spoke up to make a point. The probably made some incidental donations to causes they supported, as a matter of being ETH enthusiasts.

Philanthropists use fiat, de facto. Anything else is notable.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by Ferret7446 on Saturday September 24, 2022 @01:58AM (#32960040)
Alternatively, people with strong values donated money with Tornado Cash to spite the sanctions.

> Tornado Cash wasn't some haven for big money philanthropy pre-sanctions.

Citation needed.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by solveit on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:02PM (#32956392)
You seem to be going so far out of your way to be uncharitable that you've stopped caring about whether your statement makes the slightest bit of sense. Surely there's still some form of mindless consumption available that would provide more entertainment than donations to FOSS projects? It's not a very high bar to clear?
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by kube-system on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:11PM (#32956482)
The folks running ransomware rings make a lot of money. Sending $400k to a project they like might be their mindless entertainment. There's only so many ways to spend money that doesn't involve meatspace transactions... which you'd probably want to avoid if you know your wallet is being scrutinized by the best-funded investigators on the planet.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by mrgoldenbrown on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:43PM (#32956827)
If the donor tried to make a statement by getting a FOSS developer in trouble with the IRS, that is not something to applaud! The people being who would be punished here are not the people attempting absolute financial control. I would not very publicly send a "donation" of valuable but illegal drugs to my favorite charity, even though I support ending the war on drugs.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by TrapLord_Rhodo on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:39PM (#32956182)
Thanks for this comment even though it's being downvoted. This is a huge overstep to sanction a set of open source protocols.

Funny enough, even VB himself has 'Tainted' Eth in his wallet. He's used tornado cash on three different occassions.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by colesantiago on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:15PM (#32955911)
Or just send this most likely sanctioned laundered cryptocurrency to a dead wallet and not deal with a incoming legal headaches
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by belltaco on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:42PM (#32956203)
>Absolutely tragic that the US government's war on anonymous transactions is getting in the way of FOSS receiving donations here

No, the intent of the donation is to cause trouble to FOSS projects and waste their time. Not sure why you're appreciating this. It's like donating stolen property to the local orphanage.

Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by anvic on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:45PM (#32956224)
Is the money known to be stolen?
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by solveit on Friday September 23, 2022 @04:03PM (#32956402)
If the donor is making a statement, it would be strategically best if the money could be proven at the donor's convenience not to be stolen.
Re:An anonymous person donated 299 ETH from Tornado Cash to ... by loeg on Friday September 23, 2022 @03:59PM (#32956361)
Dirty money in, dirty money out.