News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Durable Computronics” by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday September 23, 2022 @12:34PM (#32954116)
I think the rings concept should be extended to have further down rings. It's kind of fun as a fantasy, but the pain point on this is that for a lot of things it genuinely doesn't matter if the computer side of things kind of sucks. I would be totally 100% in favor of all electronics sold on the mass market having a designated mark on them that says what level of assurance they were built with, but I don't think I mind people being allowed to sell things at ring three or four all the way down to the equivalent of what happens today. Obviously there are some cases where this isn't acceptable; medical, avionics, anything where humans can die obviously needs to be in ring zero, and I agree with other commenters in this thread that financial stuff should be at a fairly high assurance level as well.
Re:“Durable Computronics” by velcrovan on Friday September 23, 2022 @01:21PM (#32954655)
I had more rings in mind, just haven’t thought it through yet. There might not need to be that many more though. Anything involving any communication at all would probably get an instant Ring 1. Possibly anything and everything else could go in a catch-all Ring 2. (PRs welcome)