News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by pclmulqdq on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:28AM (#32939233)
Lightning is a lot less untraceable than people think. Settlement payments on a lightning channel are still traceable, and can be matched up. Also, lightning nodes get a lot of information about transactions that they don't publish to the blockchain, and you can bet that most lightning nodes that are around today keep logs. Most of them are run by big crypto companies, several of which are US-based.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by cowtools on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:44AM (#32939488)
It is quite difficult to compare the obfuscation features of lightning network with that of "conventional" systems like cryptonote-style ring signatures. Consider two different situations:

A) A user picks the economically best peer to open channels with, or chooses peers randomly. Neither of these are sybil proof, which basically means you are transmitting your requests publicly.

B) A user only opens channels privately within a cohort of peers that privately agree not to keep logs, have special means of transmitting requests privately, etc.

I would assume that most users follow some of A's heuristic and some of B's. To the extent that situation B offers privacy, it prevents you from transacting with other users globally in a more general sense.

In other words, it is useful as a privacy mechanism only if you trust your peers not to keep logs, but don't trust them not to double-spend, and also you are not worried about guilt-by-association of owning a channel with these peers. If you were running some sort of dark net market or something, it would be easier to implement some sort of (cryptocurrency-backed?) chaumian cash, as you already implicitly trust the marketplace's sysadmin to some extent (as they can simply MITM your relationships unless you establish them by keypairs out-of-band (this is another sybil problem), which is probably more dangerous than double-spending).

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by jejeyyy77 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:35AM (#32939340)
It's not meant to be "untraceable". But it's fast, and as mentioned not a public ledger.

If you want untraceable, you can go out of your way to achieve that using something akin to tornado.cash

I think the point is that the technology is already here and available - it's just not evenly distributed yet.

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by pclmulqdq on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:36AM (#32939363)
More people have tried to sell me on the lightning network on the basis that it offers privacy and reduces net transaction fees than on the basis that it offers speed.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by jejeyyy77 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @10:38AM (#32939386)
It does all those things to different degrees?
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by Apocryphon on Friday September 23, 2022 @02:46AM (#32948793)
Really bizarre that the whole asset class is labelled "crypto" when it's not even traceable. The blockchain being an unalterable ledger makes this generation of cryptocurrencies weirdly public. Perhaps in the future there will be true crypto currency.