Re:FogBugz goes dark
by londons_explore on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @06:12PM
(#32918509)
Opensource licenses don't allow that... The most an evil maintainer can do is make new versions of a library be expensive. For things like GPL code an evil maintainer can add in code that checks a license key and only runs if said key is present. Or add a dependency on a closed source component.
You still have a right to use the old version forever for free. And that's what any business in this position should do - just make a 'maintenance only' fork.
Couldn't they just not upgrade the Akka dep?
Yes, but not for long. Typelevel will patch the last open source version (2.6) with critical security updates for the next year (until Sept 2023), but not afterwards.
Then they should maintain it themselves, or pay the maintainers what they are asking for
Oh jeez. I'm no lawyer, but well copyleft sure sounds nice right now. I'd imagine if it was GPL it couldn't be relicensed incompatibly because the new version is still derived from the old one, right?
Same strategy - the pricing is insanely high (for a library), and the project is effectively dead now, but it’ll take some larger enterprises awhile to move away from.
I find it especially sleazy due to the nature of transitive dependencies in open source. For example, somebody creates a popular open source lib out of their own sense of good will, let’s call it “Foo lib.” It depends on Akka, all is fine for years, then all of the sudden Typelevel (Akka maintainers) say “physche, Akka is proprietary now, Foo lib users now owe us $$$.” Gross.