News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by Lutger on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:42PM (#32903678)
I don't really understand why not doing it to US citizens makes it ok. I can imagine one would find it permissible to use such techniques against your enemies, but this is very clearly also about your allies.

To the US, American lives are all that really matter? I mean, there's also the policy that torture is ok but not against Americans and not on US territory, hence the secret CIA torture spaces during the Gulf War and guantonomo bay (simplifying a bit here). Isn't that obviously wrong?

How can one maintain that their country is the greatest with such dubious ethics? I mean specifically using the argument 'doing objectionable things only to non US citizens' as part of the case for America's greatness seems...odd at best. I feel like I'm missing something here. A cultural gap maybe. Or is American superiority deemed so self evident that it legitimates itself in a circular justification?

I don't want to sound combative, though I probably do, but really I want to understand how this works for Americans.

Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by CSMastermind on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:57PM (#32904635)
> I don't really understand why not doing it to US citizens makes it ok. I can imagine one would find it permissible to use such techniques against your enemies, but this is very clearly also about your allies.

Because of conflict of interest.

When you're persuading people outside of the US of something you're presumably doing it in (at least nominally) the US' best interest because as a citizen of the US your personal interests are also aligned with those of the nation (at least at the scale these operations work at).

Turned internally there's all sorts of messy conflicts like political parties using the tools to gain power, agencies using the tools to gain funding, etc.

Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by flerchin on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:47PM (#32904515)
As a democracy we don't want our institutions to be shaping the opinions which are used to elect them. Shaping the opinions of foreigners has no such compunction.
Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by LudwigNagasena on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:06PM (#32906782)
Who are “we”? Government technocrats and many Americans on HN think that it’s absolutely fine that their government mistrusts stupid voters and tells them half-truths: “masks don’t work” and all that.
Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by Implicated on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:04PM (#32903942)
We (Americans) don’t all feel this way. Personally, I feel the same way you do when I read things like this. I’m puzzled how it’s ok for anyone that wasn’t assigned an American citizenship in the birth lottery.
Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by zmgsabst on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:25PM (#32904226)
> How can one maintain that their country is the greatest with such dubious ethics?

Compared to who?

> I mean specifically using the argument 'doing objectionable things only to non US citizens' as part of the case for America's greatness seems...odd at best.

That is a rule of law (for their citizens) better than much of the world.

Re:Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychologic... by neilv on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:23PM (#32904199)
I think different Americans have different awareness and thinking about those questions.

I'd started to address that in my message, then awkwardly edited it out (see last sentence) before posting.

It's easy to persuade that we should be honorable towards ourselves.

Outside of ourselves are much more complicated and contentious geopolitical questions, I don't know the answers, and I thought negative reactions to raising that would defeat the smaller point.