That goal could presumably also be accomplished by enabling the owner to check a "stolen" box in their iCloud and after that all serialized parts of that phone go on a blacklist. An iPhone checks every day or something if any of it's parts are blacklisted and refuses to work if true.

To prevent a massive attack on Apple by corrupting the blacklist, the phones would only perform this check if any of the factory parts have been replaced.

Your plan has serious a flaw. Imagine this timeline:

1. steal iphone A

2. split it into parts

3. install parts into iPhone B

4. parts not yet marked stolen, they work, check passes

5. Iphone A marked stolen

...

I did actually think of that but decided it would be a net good. People would learn to buy from trusted sources (which would probably work in Apple's favour) and also it would out the thieves in a rather unfortunate way for them, so they'd probably get the reputation they deserve rather quickly.

You miss the point. I do not care what "the people" learn. I care that my car window is not smashed if some low-life sees an iPhone inside, cause it is known that it holds no value if stolen.

Yeah I mean I get that. I'm assuming enough people would care to mark their devices stolen so that the same happens.

You are missing step 6, which is for iphone B to stop working after step 5. And part 6 would also include some kind of nasty "your phone has stolen parts in it" message to the user.

Just like the "don't boot with non-registered hardware", this is all software and can be changed. Maybe in future releases of iOS they change how this "check for legit parts" process works.

I don't think they missed it. I think this is exactly the flaw they're pointing out.

There’s no expectation of getting an open platform with iDevices so anything that disincentives stealing them is a plus.

The thief could just ask you for your iCloud password and unlock the phone (with a gun/knife for motivation).

https://xkcd.com/538/

That is not how smash-n-grabs work

I saw a video of two thieves doing exactly that in Chicago (or Detroit I don't remember) they kept hitting the guy over the head until he gave them the password and then shot him like 5 times.