That's not really the fault of the Optional. That's Java adding null as value to every type. Java also allows lists of nulls, mappings to null etc. An optional is just a container that stores one item at most. I do agree that it makes optionals less useful in Java. In Haskell and OCaml they are used essentially instead of null.
var result = map(x,x=>x.y)
which is equivalent to var result = isNull(x) ? null : x.y
where isNull is static imported from Objects.An approach which is authentic to some other languages is to consistently used a list with 0 or 1 members instead of optionals.
Sounds like you were working with some folks that were just learning the language/idioms (which is admittedly a big hurdle).
I haven't used actors in a very long time. Simple future composition and reactive streams get you very far, at an absolute fraction of the code size and complexity of the equivalent vanilla Java approach (ie: not using Rx).
For me there was a lot of learning (that often just felt like grinding), and I can confidently say that I'm leagues more productive than trying to mimic this with low level vanilla Java primitives.
I'm sure this would also apply with go channels, async/await, etc. Raising the bar of abstraction in this case can be valuable. As compared to something really high leverage like reactive streams it's just going to take a ton of code and be far less flexible in a naive approach (in most cases).
I've seen this same pattern with others. Is it worth the investment of time to get there? Not sure, maybe Go is a better set of tradeoffs for most, but I wouldn't go back to straight executors, locks, and the rest of the Java 1.5 concurrency offerings (which is what I thought the OP was saying).
I also think Either and Optional are cancers. Type erasure takes some of the fun away from Either. Before you had Optional you had one problem, you might have a null. With Optional you have two problems, you can get a null AND you can get an empty.
I worked at a place that used Scala and the engineering manager would talk your ear off like an Amway scam person about how much better monads were for error handling than Exceptions. I started working on non-Scala stuff but once they put me on the Scala side I found out that error handling was just missing in most places even though they allegedly did code reviews. It was definitely a frying pan to fire situation relative to Exceptions.
(The time before that whenI coded in Scala I found that people would spend 3 days writing something concurrent with Actors that only used 2 out of 8 cores and was rife with error conditions that could be done in 20 minutes with an Executor in Java.)
In a a parallel universe where LISP was the dominant language, people would be writing essays about how great COBOL and Cold Fusion and PHP are, about what a genius Noam Chomsky was, how recursive descent parsers are a force multiplier, etc.