I did, nearly 20 years ago. The computers were over 2500 km apart, though it was over a good university to university connection. The Gimp was certainly usable, though I will not go as far as saying it was good since 20 year old memories can be hazy and the standards of the day are different from the standards of today.
I also experimented with X over a 14.4 kbps modem a few years earlier. It was mostly while writing papers (plotting graphs and viewing dvi files, not the actual writing). It was slow, but it got the job done and was better than juggling documents between software on two computers.
The one really nice thing about X was the ability to use individual applications across a network connection, rather than dealing with an entire remote desktop. All of this remote desktop stuff strikes me as being better suited for accessing a remote system, rather than for running remote software.
That sounds like a UX problem that’s quite trivial to fix, not a technical one and absolutely not inherent with Wayland.
Yes, it's laggy, but it's nice to have the option, and it's really nice that it's already integrated with ssh and doesn't need extra setup (past passing `-Y` to ssh). If this was the only thing I'd lose by switching window managers it wouldn't be a dealbreaker.
Xaw and Motif worked okay, and it’s getting hard to imagine a heavy user who has access to only one computer, yet newer GUI toolkits have lost interest in X11 as a platform for remote rendering.
We could expect everyone to start investing in datacenter GPUs, but architecturally “one GPU per display, plugged directly into the display” always made a lot more sense to me.
Icons, textures, all these things will be passed as bitmaps with X remoting, in a strictly worse way than a modern compression could do.
Have you ever tried this? I've never had X11 network transparency be a good experience.
It would be cool but to be good all apps would have to be designed with it in mind. And they are not.
The software moves on from X11 as a protocol for remote computing.
Even well before Wayland, all the things you'd use X over the network for were moved to web browsers.