News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cutting their own throats by patio11 on Monday November 28, 2011 @08:44PM (#3288576)
It's good for customers in the short term, but it's not good for anyone in the long run: they're sweating their suppliers, all the way back down the supply chain (read: to authors like me) and sooner or later they'll put their suppliers out of business.

As a reader, this does not strike me as against my interests in the long run. I get books teleported to my Kindle instantly -- what isn't to like? (They're cheap, too, but that isn't a huge win for me. I'd pay twice as much as I do currently without thinking twice.) A shame about Charlie's publisher. They've sold me minimally $200 worth of product in the last year, I could not tell you their name if my life depended on it, and they bring precisely zero value to me relative to any other publisher aside from having signed Charlie. If Amazon signs Charlie instead, it will be literally impossible for me to identify any way in which my life changes at a consequence.

Re:Cutting their own throats by asolove on Monday November 28, 2011 @09:36PM (#3288701)
Ah, this is the key misconception. If you think Charlie is the only thing going into his books that provides you value, think again. Good development editing, copyediting, fact-checking, typography, and illustrations all go into an excellent book. Amazon has no skill at any of these things.

The future of publishing will belong not to middlemen like Amazon, but to people who can reliably put out high-quality, profitable books even from middling writers, and who can turn a profit based on the carrot of quality rather than the stick of DRM. That means cutting out a lot of the people in traditional publishing, but it doesn't mean that publishing as an industry will go away.

O'Reilly, Five Simple Steps, A Book Apart and other technical publishers are paving the way here, and it won't be long before someone starts an ebook-specific publishing house for trashy romance or adventure novels and makes a killing.

Re:Cutting their own throats by patio11 on Monday November 28, 2011 @09:40PM (#3288719)
Ah, this is the key misconception

I'm aware of that argument, I just don't find it credible. The prevailing arrangement is that the publisher pays people to edit and do cover art, just like they pay people to actually print the physical copies. It does not matter to me whose name is on the check that goes to the person who edits Charlie's book -- Charlie, Amazon, the publisher, whatever. The internals of supplier's accounting systems do not surface value to me.

Re:Cutting their own throats by untog on Monday November 28, 2011 @10:09PM (#3288822)
Right, but if Charlie pays, does he know good editors? He might not have the time to research and network (and, in fact, it might be a bad idea to let him choose his own editor). If Amazon pays then they are, for all intents and purposes, playing the exact same role as publisher.

Just because something is possible without a middleman doesn't mean that it is desirable.

Re:Cutting their own throats by tptacek on Monday November 28, 2011 @10:54PM (#3288962)
Really? That's what we're down to? Save the publishers because they're the only ones who can find good editors? That's another arrangement that sucks for everyone --- the readers, the writers, and the editors --- except for the publishers.

This strikes me as the same as saying "save the newspapers, they're the only ones who can run classified ads!". Except, the newspapers do other stuff. What else do the publishers do?

The arrangement we have today made a lot more sense when books lived or died on the retail channel, to which access was a scarcity acquired and allocated ("curated", to use their words) by the publishers. But that world is gone. My grandkids will look at bookstores like soda shops: historical curiosities. There's value in curation, too, but when it isn't backed by the scarcity of access to bookstore shelves, it's not enough value to justify the middleman role.

Re:Cutting their own throats by statictype on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @05:10AM (#3289785)
I think he was making a good point: That there is a role for a middleman to add value by providing services (or access to services) that an author may not already have on his own.

That we refer to this middleman as a 'publisher' (which already has meaning in the soon-to-be-outdated book publishing model) is, I think, what you take exception to.

Re:Cutting their own throats by ebrenes on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @10:47AM (#3295368)
And if these middle do actually provide value, they will continue to be included in the process. If these organizations (currently known as publishers) are capable of providing capable editors and providing other value to the finished work, I'm sure they'll be able to charge a fee and stay in business.

Job boards have not replaced the headhunter. If anything, people complain about the job boards being a miasma of trash resume. Likewise, those authors who seek such expert consulting might end up positively differentiating themselves.

In the long run though, the business has been disrupted and it is up to the publishers to positions themselves in a way that their expertise and value is appreciated and accessible to authors who might not want to go through them in the traditional means. So perhaps they would do well to charge for the services which still add value (like editorial work or cover art services).

Re:Cutting their own throats by gamble on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @01:29AM (#3289358)
Judging by the deplorable quality of the editing and cover illustrations on many Kindle books, I question whether the traditional publishers are adding anything of value. Oftentimes it's obvious that the cover illustration was tossed together in Photoshop or Illustrator in an afternoon, and the editing wouldn't pass muster in a freshman composition class. Sometimes it doesn't look like they've even bothered to run the spell-checker.
Re:Cutting their own throats by fpgeek on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @06:37AM (#3289927)
This doesn't excuse the editing, but I've heard that one problem is that publishers often don't have electronic rights to use the cover illustrations they use on physical books.
Re:Cutting their own throats by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @08:42AM (#3294962)
B&W E-Ink graphics? That may be responsible for the cheesy look in large part.
Re:Cutting their own throats by brazzy on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @08:34AM (#3290211)
Why would editing, cover art, etc. be something that can be best done by a middleman though?

It seems more logical to me to see this as a service provided by separate agencies, paid for by either the author or the publisher. Such agencies could be of various sizes and compete on price or a reputation for quality work.

Re:Cutting their own throats by untog on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @09:02AM (#3290294)
* Such agencies could be of various sizes and compete on price or a reputation for quality work.*

Right, but would an author want to deal with comparing all the agencies and selecting the best one? Is he/she necessarily qualified to do so? Like I said, having a middleman in there is of use at times.

Re:Cutting their own throats by tptacek on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @09:36AM (#3290425)
So people will set up companies that work for the authors to set this stuff up, and those companies won't be able to capture most of the proceeds from the authors work, but instead will be forced to price according to the value their work provides to the authors.
Re:Cutting their own throats by brazzy on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @11:39AM (#3290975)
Does an author want to deal with comparing all the publishers and selecting the best one? Is he/she necessarily qualified to do so?

Whatever the answer is, it applies just as well to my scenario.

Re:Cutting their own throats by edanm on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @03:53AM (#3289653)
It is against your interest for Amazon to have a monopoly, and DRM is helping give them a monopoly. That's the thrust of the argument.

I really wanted to buy an ebook reader when I last visited the States. As soon as I realized that if I buy anything that isn't a Kindle means I can't access all the books I've already bought from Amazon, I knew I'd have to buy a Kindle. This is a bad situation for a consumer, since I'm locked in to a specific platform. Right now it's fine for me, since the Kindle also happens to be the cheapest offering. But fast-forward 5 years, and if there's no longer competition, Amazon no longer has to make the price affordable for me.

Re:Cutting their own throats by waterlesscloud on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @10:11AM (#3290584)
What other systems can you play your xbox games on?
Re:Cutting their own throats by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @08:43AM (#3294967)
XBox is a platform, with many, many IP points.

Kindle is a cheesy pad for displaying text. It has 80-hour battery lifetime and .... nothing else.

It would be trivial to display ALL Kindle content on nearly any device. The lock is economic and nothing else.

Re:Cutting their own throats by nikatwork on Monday November 28, 2011 @09:34PM (#3288697)
The problem for you as a reader: a monopoly would allow Amazon to jack up retail prices as high as it feels like.

Amazon could also eg set very unfavourable terms for authors, so only mainstream literature becomes commercially viable.

Of course, other channels would open up in this event, but there would be a massive time lag. And if Amazon didn't squeeze too hard, they could maintain the status quo for a long time.

Monopolies are bad for everyone.

Re:Cutting their own throats by fpgeek on Monday November 28, 2011 @11:43PM (#3289094)
> Amazon could also eg set very unfavourable terms for authors, so only mainstream literature becomes commercially viable.

Even as a monopoly, why would Amazon do that? The cost of distributing another ebook is negligible (and may even effectively be negative if the competitive advantages of a larger catalog outweigh the server, bandwidth and other operating costs).

It seems to me that, even as a monopoly, Amazon doesn't really care whether the books they sell are mainstream or non-mainstream as long as they make as much money as they can from them. And that doesn't mean jacking up the retail price just for the hell of it (or squeezing authors for fun). That means trying to gather enough data to estimate the supply and demand curves and pricing based on that (something Amazon is already good at).

I think authors are likely to get squeezed regardless because, like musicians, there are too many that are willing to write for (effectively) free just to get the lottery ticket for the big leagues. On the consumer side, it is important to remember that every book is already a tiny little monopoly of its own, so it isn't clear which way things will go if they are aggregated.

Re:Cutting their own throats by patio11 on Monday November 28, 2011 @09:41PM (#3288721)
only mainstream literature becomes commercially viable.

Only mainstream literature is commercially viable in the status quo.

Re:Cutting their own throats by wging on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @12:29AM (#3289222)
Stross seems to make it work. In what world is he mainstream? I'm presuming you know that Stross was the one who wrote the blog post above.
Re:Cutting their own throats by barry-cotter on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @04:18PM (#3292216)
One of my brother's Creative Writing lecturers was fond of the following fact

There are more professional concert pianists in the UK than full-time authors of fiction.

Re:Cutting their own throats by Confusion on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @02:35AM (#3289500)
nikatwork's definition of 'mainstream literature' obviously is different from your definition of 'mainstream literature'. Using his definition, your assertion is false.
Re:Cutting their own throats by richardw on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @12:00AM (#3289147)
I'd imagine Amazon fears becoming a monopoly. US/EU antitrust would break them up pronto.
Re:Cutting their own throats by anamax on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @11:12AM (#3290856)
> I'd imagine Amazon fears becoming a monopoly. US/EU antitrust would break them up pronto.

Name three monopolies that were broken up while it made a difference. In which of those cases did consumer prices go down as a result of the breakup?

The only "broken up while it made a difference" case that I'm aware of is Standard Oil. However, the result was higher prices, not lower. (Standard absolutely hammered transportation companies and passed on the savings to consumers. After the breakup, transportation companies could turn down biz from one oil company to get biz from another and thus were able to raise their prices. That's why railroads pushed for the breakup.)

Re:Cutting their own throats by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @08:45AM (#3294971)
Ok, off topic, but AT&T breakup was good. Didn't actually lower prices, but services sprouted like weeds. For 100 years, a simple desktop landline (2 different models! Black or green!) turned into the explosion of products and services we have today.
Re:Cutting their own throats by anamax on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @11:50AM (#3295645)
The AT&T breakup happened after sprint et al started offering long distance services.

The carterfone decision, which happened before that, is what gave us phone choice.

There was some post-breakup price-reduction in local services, but they all came from the local monopolies that were the result of the AT&T breakup. The services themselves, with the exception of caller-id, were offered by pre-breakup AT&T but were more expensive. Since the land-line service price decline happened when cell-phone carriers started offering those same services for less, I think that cell-phone competition gets the credit, not the breakup.

And beige was available before green. (I think that white was as well.)

Re:Cutting their own throats by JoeAltmaier on Thursday December 01, 2011 @12:11AM (#3298475)
Hm. I'd think cell-phones themselves came to life post-ATT monopoly. That whole industry was part of the windfall.
Re:Cutting their own throats by anamax on Thursday December 01, 2011 @12:41AM (#3298544)
> I'd think cell-phones themselves came to life post-ATT monopoly.

I thought that I said that.

> That whole industry was part of the windfall.

How so? Are you claiming that AT&T would have been granted a cell-phone monopoly if it hadn't been broken up? If so, why weren't the baby bells, which still had a land-line monopoly, given a cell phone monopoly?

I think that the success of sprint et al wrt long distance by the time that cell-phones were taking off pretty much guaranteed that there AT&T wouldn't be granted a cell phone monoply even if the break-up hadn't occurred.

Re:Cutting their own throats by vilya on Tuesday November 29, 2011 @08:52AM (#3290254)
I think Charlie's worrying about Amazon putting him out of business, meaning he won't be able to afford to write books any more and will have to find alternative employment. If you like Charlie's books - like I do! - that's definitely against your interests