Re:The absurdity of Europe burning wood for energy
by nkurz on Saturday September 17, 2022 @08:49AM
(#32877108)
Great post. We're in a parallel situation in Vermont: current EPA woodstove using locally harvested wood, fuel oil backup that we use only when we aren't home. We did install a heat pump hot water heater and have been happy with it, but it was replacing electric so a clearer win.
I'm not sure what to make of the Finnish study. Full version is here: https://sci-hub.se/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2012.02.027. It's hard to know how the elevated levels compare to other sources, since 2x of almost zero might still be negligible. It does mention though that the "PCDD/F level exceeded the emission limit in Europe for MSW incinerators" so maybe it's real.
One other factor that might help us remain "smug" about our modern wood stoves is that the Finnish study was done on sauna stoves without secondary combustion and with high flue gas temps. I suspect the results might be completely different for compliant woodstove with good secondary and much lower flue temps. Of course, different might end up worse.
Re:The absurdity of Europe burning wood for energy
by selimnairb on Saturday September 17, 2022 @09:49AM
(#32877529)
Thanks for posting the original article. One of these days I’ll look for citations that might elaborate this work.
Luckily we just added hyper heat air source heat pumps to the rest of the house. We also have hydronic heat from an oil-fired boiler, which we are planning to only use when it’s too cold for the heat pumps (less than 25 degrees F).
The boiler also supplies hot water, so looking to replace that with a heat pump water heater to avoid burning oil in the summer. However, even with the efficiency of heat pumps, the electricity is mostly generated with gas, which is <40% efficient (factoring in transmission and distribution losses). Our boiler is 82% efficient, so from a carbon/GHG point of view, heat pump water heater may not be any better. Of course electricity is fungible, so more nuclear, solar, and wind would change the equation.
What I want to know is, where is the Department of Energy, etc. guidance on this. I have a fair amount of experience with energy policy and technology and the right path is far from clear to me.
[1] https://www.familiesforcleanair.org/catalytic-wood-stoves-sh...