News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by adrianN on Monday November 28, 2011 @02:16AM (#3284943)
That's not a very satisfying definition of art. I could put poop on a pedestal[^1] and it would do the same things, even more so. Yet I don't believe you should be calling that art.

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artist%27s_shit

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by pilgrim689 on Monday November 28, 2011 @02:57AM (#3285028)
"Art is the product or process of deliberately arranging items (often with symbolic significance) in a way that influences and affects one or more of the senses, emotions, and intellect" - Wikipedia.

By definition, the shit in a can is also art.

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by Dylan16807 on Monday November 28, 2011 @05:30AM (#3285342)
As is the pizza I had last week.

That's not a good definition.

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by Fargren on Monday November 28, 2011 @11:03AM (#3286372)
Why not? Culinary art is art. If a crappy painting can be concidered badly made art, your pizza surely can be concidered badly made culinary art, at the very least.

I personally think that anything that was made with intention can be qualified as art; the only things that don't have any artistic merit are thos that are made completely by accident or hapenstance.

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by Dylan16807 on Monday November 28, 2011 @12:52PM (#3286823)
That just brings us back to jey's comment. If everything counts as art then the term 'art' has been stripped of meaning and now we need a new term for what used to be called 'art'. It's a waste of time.

There is a world of difference between claiming that something fits the common definition of art and claiming that we need to use an extremely expansive definition of art. I thought the argument here was about the former. If it's about the later then I'll not fight; I'll just note that we're not even discussing the piece and bow out.

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by pilgrim689 on Monday November 28, 2011 @10:41PM (#3288926)
By definition, your pizza is very low-grade art. It doesn't have any symbolic significance, it affects only 1 of "senses, emotions, intellect". Otherwise, it fits.

Why does it have to be "art OR not art"? Can't it be a spectrum? Like love? Or beauty? Or any other subjective concept you can think of?

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by Dylan16807 on Wednesday November 30, 2011 @05:38PM (#3297226)
Because when people say that something is art, there is an implied "vs. not art". Otherwise it's a misleading tautology.

Ex. Grey is a color but that doesn't make it a color tv.

Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by MostAwesomeDude on Monday November 28, 2011 @04:27AM (#3285227)
It's not that somebody signed a urinal, it's that that urinal was signed. If you can't appreciate art, that doesn't invalidate the artistic statement being made.
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by Dylan16807 on Monday November 28, 2011 @05:35AM (#3285352)
Being unique is not by itself enough to qualify something as art, and signing a urinal has no other merit.
Re:Does a terabyte of illegal downloads constitute art? by Tichy on Monday November 28, 2011 @06:50AM (#3285502)
I am sure a urinal signed by Steve Jobs would fetch a good price at an auction.