But arguing that McKinsey alumni are all-bad is clearly over the top. They can produce results incredibly quickly and are comfortable dealing with very senior levels at corporates. Business development and major deals are a specialty.
Try calling one when it's time to think about major decisions, pricing, figuring out how industries work and just general business advice.
So what do you make of the grandparent's observation that none of them go on to form vital startups themselves?
With few if any exceptions they will never add value. Their expertise is in locating value someone else has created and then drinking from that fountain for as long as they can. And they are very good at it.
Their position is similar to lawyers. With very few exceptions if any, they are simply an expense.
They need a client to cling to and sap off of.
And no matter how intelligent they may be, that is how they think.