News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

110101001010100

Re:The Trouble with Bright Kids on Monday November 28, 2011 @01:59AM (#3284907)
I know someone who earned an undergraduate degree in Biochemistry without attending a single lecture. He finished in the top 1/3 of the graduating class for that department.

But I know that during the time that we were in class suffering through boring lectures that often made no sense, he was dissecting each and every handout, combing through mutliple textbooks he got from the library and downloading and reading every journal reference in the class notes.

The crazy thing is, I think he learned more than any of us who had perfect attendance at lectures.

I know he wasn't the "smartest" guy in our classes but he often knew more about certain areas than even the MS and PhD candidates who were assisting us in labs. He was just getting much more out of the things we did because he had some background going in.

The guy was just super curious and did his homework like nobody's business. Sheer effort. It was impressive.

Re:The Trouble with Bright Kids on Monday November 28, 2011 @01:33AM (#3284836)
s/test/standardised &
Re:Peggy Noonan on Steve Jobs and Why Big Companies Die on Monday November 28, 2011 @12:34AM (#3284698)
Can't disagree with what she's saying. But I'd add that if we're talking about firms whose business is computers, 15 years feels like 75.
Re:The Trouble with Bright Kids on Sunday November 27, 2011 @11:59PM (#3284604)
Maybe we just set the bar too low. By doing so, not only do we hurt the bright kids by boring them to tears, but we presume based on test scores(?) that certain children could through sheer effort never exceed what level we presume they are capable of reaching- we lower our expectations of them. We deny the "bright" kids a reasonably stimulating education and the other kids the chance to prove what they can do.

Standardised testing does not test for ability to improve.

It's one thing if a kid fails because he didn't try hard enough. That can be explained to him. And it's a good lesson. But it's another thing to give him a standardised test and decide a priori what's he capable of. That just creates a strange value system where all kids, bright or not, may be denied an opportunity to show what they can do and they learn to think of ability as fixed. And it creates a lot of fascination with "innate" ability.

Is it true there's growing evidence that ability is perhaps not as "fixed" as we think?

Re:The Trouble with Bright Kids on Sunday November 27, 2011 @11:28PM (#3284531)
This does not say much for the value of testing _and making presumptions based on test results_. Note the emphasis on the second part of that sentence. Testing is ok. Recognising that all children are not the same intellectually is fine. But making presumptions based on limited evidence, like test scores, is something I have always wondered about. This story only reinforces my beliefs.
Re:The Trouble with Bright Kids on Sunday November 27, 2011 @10:50PM (#3284422)
Very true. For how to "solve" those problems in education I have never had any decent ideas. No doubt many readers here have experienced them first hand.

I just see a lot of attention on "innate" ability, who has it, and why, and less attention placed on effort. I think effort is underrated. That is my biased opinion.

Would anyone disagree that if bright kids were forced to have to expend more effort, they might themselves benefit, as they _might_ be more likely to see some of their true potential? No guarantees of course.

Re:The Trouble with Bright Kids on Sunday November 27, 2011 @10:35PM (#3284364)
Another deceptive title designed to attract clicks.

The problem is with how we attribute achievement, how we praise kids, not the kids themselves. But the title as written attracts more attention. The reader thinks, "What could possibly be wrong with the bright kids?" Click.

I'd argue this finding implicitly speaks to the way we view and value intelligence and ability. Seems to me we refuse to acknowledge effort is as useful as some sort of innate ability. Our dominant fascination (judging by scholarly and mass media publications) seems not to be with hard work, and achievement despite the odds, but instead with those who are "gifted" and do not need to work as hard as everyone else to achieve the same results.

Surprise! The bright kids are not as motivated. That's the revolutionary finding presented in this fluff HBR blog "content".

We go to great lengths to try to find such "innate" above average ability, to label and preselect "the bright kids", instead of devoting our attention toward motivating and rewarding _effort_, which in my opinion might ultimately harness more human potential in the aggregate than focusing excessively on "the bright kids".

Especially when you consider that the attention we place on ability and the "bright" label we give them could possibly lower their overall performance, if you believe what's suggested by this study.

Re:Inside McKinsey on Sunday November 27, 2011 @09:19PM (#3284146)
"Value extractors". Spot on.

With few if any exceptions they will never add value. Their expertise is in locating value someone else has created and then drinking from that fountain for as long as they can. And they are very good at it.

Their position is similar to lawyers. With very few exceptions if any, they are simply an expense.

They need a client to cling to and sap off of.

And no matter how intelligent they may be, that is how they think.

Re:Linux Mint signs a partnership with DuckDuckGo on Sunday November 27, 2011 @07:38PM (#3283899)
Maybe the question is not why you have to pay for your car, but why you _do not_ have to pay to view information via a website, store a copy of this in RAM and/or save a copy using secondary storage. Why is it typically "free" for you to do that?
Re:Programming Languages: What tool is right for which job? on Sunday November 27, 2011 @05:28PM (#3283602)
So with Lisp or even Forth, the proper approach would be to have "Lisp chips" or "Forth chips" (which were recently discussed here)?
Re:Sure, Post a Review. But the Last Word Won’t Be Yours. on Sunday November 27, 2011 @05:01PM (#3283543)
Thoughts of Yelp come to mind. Businesses paying to protect their reputations. Except we extend this even further.

He envisions "a review site that reviews the review sites".

It appears that's what his employer is doing with his column. He's reviewing a review site. And as he says, the goal is getting page views. Mission accomplished.

What does he think he's going to do with financing?

Implement a massive marketing and sales campaign, getting review sites to sign up to protect their reputations?

If he wants to review review sites, nothing is stopping him from starting a blog and doing so.

You can write or get users to write absolute rubbish and still get page views. That seems to be a solid way to attract eyeballs. It continues to work, year after year.

I can envision a relatively easy way to implement this without writing lots of code. How big do you think the market is for internet-based "code search"?

I think code search is very useful and I've come near to trying to construct a searchable database just for personal use. It's an itch I've been tempted to scratch. But it would require some time.

Re:Programming Languages: What tool is right for which job? on Sunday November 27, 2011 @04:32PM (#3283481)
It's just a thought. A "what if".

I trace the existence of many languages to having no common instruction set in hardware.

Different assembly languages for different hardware. This was very frustrating for people many years ago.

If protocols (rules) are awesome what if we had had a protocol that asked the chip makers to use a common (extendable) instruction set for all hardware? What if there had only been one assembly language?

It seems that all abstractions, from Pascal or Lisp virtual machines to C to higher and higher level languages to the ones popular today, are all descended from the search for a way to deal with that initial lack of protocol (rule) to get hardware makers to use the same instruction set and thereby let programmers use the same assembly language.

I could be very wrong on this.

Re:Programming Languages: What tool is right for which job? on Sunday November 27, 2011 @03:08PM (#3283254)
Even if you are adept in using a highly efficient and effective language for doing each job, if no one else is using the language it's utility becomes limited. That's because none of us work in vacuum. Computers run by different people in separate locations cannot talk to each other unless those people cooperate. They have to agree on some things. And further, we're all using software and systems designed and built in whole or in part by someone else.

I sometimes wonder what we could achieve if choices of language were reduced and we were all forced into "speaking the same language". Would the advantages of a common language supercede the advantages of any one language's design?

Re:Why wireless mesh networks won’t save us from censorship on Sunday November 27, 2011 @02:35PM (#3283167)
It is crucial in my opinion how you define the goals of your project.
Re:Linux Mint signs a partnership with DuckDuckGo on Sunday November 27, 2011 @02:03PM (#3283089)
From the genius who brought us what Google adapted as AdSense. I applaud this effort. I'm no Spike Lee, but in my opinion this is doing the right thing.

Let people compete over what to do with the raw data (data which is of course publicly accessible but subject to the strange inequities of crawling), how best to process and present it, not over access to it. DDG has to pay Yahoo! for a BOSS license. That is just strange when you think about how the raw data was obtained. It is publicly available information.

Nothing against Yahoo! for doing that (selling access to publicly available data), as there are many other examples of this practice across web- "everyone else is doing it". But I do not think it is "the right thing" to do.