News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by orthecreedence on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:57PM (#32840791)
> And of course that white person had innumerable advantages their entire life

This is the problem. You don't know this, and you can't tell this just from the color of someone's skin.

A white man can grow up in a trailer park with a drunk, abusive father. A black woman can grow up in a loving, upper middle class family in the suburbs.

Skin color is only a fractional indication of someone's experience.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:46PM (#32841487)
A person can both have advantages in society and yet have specific situations in their life that are much more impactful.

You could have used the same arguments in 1860... Not all black people were enslaved, some were quite prosperous in fact! Therefore there was no benefit to being white.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by rootusrootus on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:57PM (#32842532)
And thus the exact problem. It's okay to observe that a whole class of people enjoy a privilege. Where it goes off the rails is when you use that knowledge to discriminate against individuals in an attempt to correct the historical injustice.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:22PM (#32842833)
And thus we perpetuate the injustice indefinitely!

Your essential argument seems to be that once an injustice is over one generation old, it is as if it never happened, no matter if the after effects continue to cascade into modern day.

You cannot just magically pretend an individual is not part of a society.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by yibg on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:00PM (#32844012)
What's the proposed solution? Put a finger on the scale against the privileged group? By how much? for how long? Lumping any race together and treating it as the same is a problem in my view.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by Natsu on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:44AM (#32847554)
> What's the proposed solution?

There actually is an equitable solution there: help all of the poor equally. To the extent any identifiable group has been historically disadvantaged, this solution will balance things out by disproportionately helping those groups.

I really don't know why it's not more popular as a way to make society more fair, or why group-based interventions are seen as necessary despite the existence of a simple and stable way of leveling the playing field and keeping it closer to level over time, instead of constantly debating how much we have to tip it in which direction(s) and for how long.

Of course, there's still the problem that things will probably never be perfectly fair no matter what we do and that grievance can always be used as a reason for people to push for rules that favor their groups over others.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by yibg on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:51PM (#32858278)
I agree, and this is more of what many other developed countries are doing with things like cheap or free education, social safety nets, wealth transfer etc. But the US seems to be allergic to all of those.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:29PM (#32844299)
And ignoring it altogether is better?

I don't have a magical solution, but I also am not going to flip out everytime a private company chooses to give some type of minor preferential treatment to historically underprivileged groups to attempt to balance out systemic inequities.

I can't say with complete confidence one way or the other if Twilio's policy is right or wrong but I can say with confidence a lot of the critiques are both in bad faith and lack any real attempt in understanding the rationale behind the policies.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by yibg on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:45PM (#32844484)
If there is an unfairness in obtaining opportunity, either lack of education opportunity or whatever, that seems like the right thing to address. Not at the end of the process and then trying to tilt things.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:13PM (#32844753)
That reminds me of what happens when we see a house on fire: We let it burn to the ground (don't want to upset the status quo of the house on fire), then say we'll make a few small tweaks to the building codes to prevent any house fires in the future.

A major problem should be tackled in all of the areas where there is injustice. The beginning, the end and the middle.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by yibg on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:53PM (#32858302)
That's not what I'm saying at all. I'm saying (in my opinion), there are other areas more worthy of investment that for whatever reason the populous aren't behind. How about we provide easier and cheaper access to education? More after school programs, child care, social safety nets etc so that disadvantaged groups don't stay disadvantaged.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by fche on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:02PM (#32843313)
> And of course that white person had innumerable advantages their entire life

such as being overtly and illegally dispreferred for college admissions, scholarships, hiring, promotion, and preferred for being fired

such privilege much wow

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by trention on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @11:53AM (#32838927)
Given that affirmative action has been a thing in both hiring and college admissions for multiple decades now, that's of course incorrect. Those "innumerable advantages" in today's USA overwhelmingly go to (immigrant) minorities.

I'm so glad I live in a country in continental Europe where this shit is unconstitutional and any company that even tried to hint at doing this is going to get sued to oblivion.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @11:56AM (#32838991)
The people being laid off likely grew up in America 25-40 years ago. Modern policies are not relevant to the people I'm talking about (though obviously still a very interesting and important discussion).
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by trention on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @11:59AM (#32839048)
Affirmative action in college admissions and hiring has been a thing at least since the early 90s.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by csa on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:33PM (#32839584)
> Affirmative action in college admissions and hiring has been a thing at least since the early 90s.

1969 iirc for college admissions and federal government contracts (and maybe federal government hiring).

Interestingly, the 90s are when some states, like California in 1996 (prop 209), banned affirmative action in admissions.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:05PM (#32839136)
Oh I misread your original post, sorry about that.

So your belief is that affirmative action in college admissions is the defining factor in race inequality, even though the vast majority of the structural disadvantages happen much younger?

Remember that this is the American society that upon integration decided over and over again they'd rather fill public pools with cement than have them shared between white and black children.

You don't believe those same barriers carried over to housing and schools? You just ignore the data and massive, persistent wealth gaps?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by trention on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:09PM (#32839189)
No, there are zero barriers "in front" of minorities in the states, only advantages. There is no institutional discrimination against minorities, only against the now-majority, soon-to-be minority.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:18PM (#32839340)
If we look at a 1 year old black child, and a 1 year old while child, the average household wealth of the white child is around 10x higher.

What did the white child do to deserve this? How much better could they possibly be at drooling and crawling to have so much more wealth available to them?

So I guess your belief is that household wealth has no impact on children?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by trention on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:23PM (#32839442)
>What did the white child do to deserve this?

Ah, the fallacy that everything you receive from your ancestors is undeserved. Will we be doing race-based asset appropriation tomorrow, comrade?

I think I'm not interested in discussing this with someone holding such a position which I consider completely deluded.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by quesera on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:54PM (#32843217)
> the fallacy that everything you receive from your ancestors is undeserved

Is there an intelligent argument that some infants are more deserving than others?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by trention on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:02PM (#32843308)
More deserving of what? The argument is that wealth/social capital/whatever accumulated by your ancestors rightfully belongs and can be transferred to you.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:16PM (#32843453)
Hypothetically speaking, what if your parents stole that money from somebody else in a provable way?

Does it still rightfully belong to you?

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by commandlinefan on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @12:01PM (#32839085)
> multiple decades now

About half a century, in fact. There aren't many people still alive who can remember a time what it wasn't.

Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by yibg on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:58PM (#32843988)
How do you know this? You think this is true for every white person? If so that IS racist.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by the_doctah on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#32841983)
This is the definition of prejudice.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by peter422 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:50PM (#32843170)
If you willfully disregard any context about the situation and historical context then I'd agree with you.
Re:Twilio to lay off 11% of workforce by djbebs on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @11:49AM (#32838873)
Thanks for proving his point.