Re:Low vitamin D linked to heart disease, death
by jberryman on Sunday November 27, 2011 @03:29PM
(#3283315)
An example of a similar obvious hypothesis that appears to be flawed: raising "good cholestrol" with niacin supplements appears not to lower risk of heart attacks as was widely assumed
http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2011/05/28/136678665/study-b...
It's an obvious hypothesis, of course (low X associated with negative outcomes, so increasing X will improve outcomes), but not necessarily guaranteed: the low Vitamin D levels could've been symptoms of a different problem that isn't fixed by just supplementing with Vitamin D; or the supplements might've failed in various ways to be taken up or activate the right mechanisms.