Re:Who cares about diversity?
by tptacek on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:50PM
(#32815001)
"This argument is written and reasoned like that of a high school sophomore" is, believe it or not, not an ad-hominem argument.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Who cares about diversity?
by matt-attack on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:33PM
(#32815621)
Nonetheless, critiquing the writing style rather than the substance makes it seem like you've lost the argument from the start.
Re:Who cares about diversity?
by pseudalopex on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:54PM
(#32815949)
They called the substance axiomatic and much of it depending on specific definitions of specific words.
Well... they sure think their argument is axiomatic.
I would say that the more important critique I have is of the reasoning style.
Re:Who cares about diversity?
by PuppyTailWags on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:42PM
(#32815747)
Critiquing the style of a persuasive essay makes a lot of sense to me, however, because it accurately points out a flaw that will make it less successful according to this specific reader.
Re:Who cares about diversity?
by matt-attack on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:49PM
(#32815880)
I'd suggest that if a reader is less successful at grasping the crux of an essay due solely to the writing style, that merely points out a failing of the reader. Digesting essays of varying styles is an important skill that one needs as an academic. That skill needs to be fostered.
Re:Who cares about diversity?
by PuppyTailWags on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:54PM
(#32815951)
But this isn't an academic context; this is a substack essay published on the internet for some internet denizens to read. In this case it makes a lot of sense to ask whether or not the essay succeeds at being persuasive, in the way it makes sense to critique whether or not a speech is delivered well. A public speaker can make a great point, but if they vomit on themselves halfway through the point, it makes sense to go "well, maybe we should address to vomiting thing" instead of "disgust in someone's vomiting on themselves is a failure of the audience".
It’s a low-effort substack troll post, it’s not that complicated
Re:Who cares about diversity?
by matthewrobertso on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:51PM
(#32815020)
"sort of comically smug"
Also not an ad-hominem argument! In fact, it's even less of an ad-hominem argument than "written like a teenager" is. And it is in fact smug!
I mean I think the point is that the top comment for this article is now about the tone of the article rather than the contents. You yourself say there are valid criticisms to be made, so why not do that and compare them to the article instead?