Or you're suggesting a violation of conservation of energy and momentum of light over large distances, by vacuum itself. Which would probably be detectable here. Not even sure how you can suggest it in a consistent way.
Then there's the reasonable option, that it's just gravity and the spacetime metric itself changing, which is the leading theory anyways. Explaining it away with some invisible matter that acts only gravitationally, like you suggested, is literally what they are doing.
And what about particles we do see? What if the debris we know is out there (the stuff of collisions and non-congealed leftover particulates, early gases since its many light years away) over immense distances have an accumulative affect? We see the red sunset but do not discern any individual particles with our eyes.
Then there are the things we don't see. Dark matter... and so much of it. I'm guessing that disproving the relevance of all of this has proven tedious, and recounting it to a newbie like myself even more tiresome!
So much physics misunderstanding right there.
The red hue of the sky is from filtering by dispersion. The spectroscopy of red sunlight during sunset is similar to the spectroscopy of regular sunlight. You have same absorption lines. Just lower amplitudes in higher frequencies.
Redshift from stars moves the absorption lines. There are no known mediums which would have this effect after light left the medium. The only things which have that effect are gravitation and Doppler shift. Those are literally the two things astrophysicists take into account very well, leading to current theories.